5 ms·
The law isn’t like programming. The reason you sign something is to show clear intent that you intended to agree to something. Nobody’s under the impression a
by chrisseaton 8y ago
The law isn’t like programming.
The reason you sign something is to show clear intent that you intended to agree to something.
Nobody’s under the impression a paper signature cannot be forged either. It’s no different.
It’s social not mathematical.
- gruez 8y agoThen that leads to my second question >Why do we need them at all? Why not just email the contract, and the person replies back with "I agree to this"? Simpler and cheaper than paying $150/year.
- faitswulff 8y agoMost likely backwards compatibility. You can print an email chain and bring it in front of a judge, but it's probably not going to work very well.
- ceejayoz 8y agoYou basically can. https://www.pcworld.com/article/253523/how_to_make_sure_that_digital_signature_is_legit.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/253523/how_to_make_sure_that... > The second class of signatures, which Parmar uses all the time in her practice, is signing one's name to a document electronically by typing your name in one of the following formats: > For submissions to the Federal court system: /s/Angela West > For submissions to the Patent & Trademark Office: /Angela West/ > Both the // and the /s/ methods are considered to be legitimate signatures under the Federal E-Sign act, and acceptable enough for the legal industry. Here's proof of that where Federal courts are concerned: https://www.cand.uscourts.gov/ecf/signatures https://www.cand.uscourts.gov/ecf/signatures
- chrisseaton 8y agoRight - and the point is that in a casual email you may reply 'yes that's fine' and is that signing a contract or not? But if we have some ceremony, like a physical signature, or using this // notation, then it's clear what your intent was.
- ceejayoz 8y agoEven a verbal contract has some weight. A "yes that's fine" reply to an unambiguous email is likely to stand up in court. "I, <full legal name> agree to this" is even better. A formal contract with a real ink signature makes things easier, but it's often not required.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBecause the ceremony of a signature has been socially recognised for thousands of years. That's what our society expects.
- gruez 8y ago>Because the ceremony of a signature Come to think of it, I remember "signing" pdfs in adobe reader by clicking a form field that produced a signature similar to[1]: John Smith Digitally signed by CN=John Smith [...] This would satisfy the "ceremony" requirement. According to adobe[2] it looks like you can do this with self signed certificates, so it's completely free as well. But this option is significantly less popular than hellosign/docusign. I guess the value-add for them is having a web interface, but I'm not convinced it's worth the $150/year (significantly more for "business" or "enterprise" plans) for a web interface that essentially signs pdfs with self-signed certificates. [1] https://helpx.adobe.com/content/dam/help/en/acrobat/11/using/signing-pdfs/_jcr_content/main-pars/procedure_1345595113/proc_par/step/step_par/image/signature-placed.png https://helpx.adobe.com/content/dam/help/en/acrobat/11/using... [2] https://helpx.adobe.com/acrobat/11/using/signing-pdfs.html#SignaPDFusingadigitalID https://helpx.adobe.com/acrobat/11/using/signing-pdfs.html#S...
- deepGem 8y agoYou can even satisfy the ceremony of signature in a pdf document by inserting your hand drawn signature in Preview.
- ct520 8y agoGoodluck with that holding up in court. I think docusign has the best sustinct summary of the bare requirements needed for a electronicly signed document to be recognized as legally binding. https://www.docusign.com/learn/us-electronic-signature-laws-and-history https://www.docusign.com/learn/us-electronic-signature-laws-...
- twunde 8y agoThe main benefit is around workflows. First and foremost, if you are in a position where you need external people to sign documents (say you're a photographer and need signed releases), it's a lot easier to send someone a link to the standard document and get them to sign a release then to email them and then call the person and walk them through digitally signing a document. Especially if you're doing this 50+ times a year. And you typically get the documents signed much quicker. It's pretty much the difference between having to mail in a check for every payment vs using a web portal. It's more convenient and there's a faster turnaround time. Oh and you've removed the risk that something isn't signed correctly (was there a section that wasn't initialed?) or that something was redlined. It's certainly not for everyone or every business, but there are certain use cases where the money is well worth it.
- gilbetron 8y agoEasier to argue that you were agreeing to something else, got confused, things were changed, etc. The ceremony of "hey, you are now doing something legally binding" is important socially and legally, and the process with HelloSign doesn't start and stop with the signatures, there's all the handshaking and communication around the event.
- taude 8y agoAlso, using docusign, etc. are stupid simple for people's who's signatures are needing in multiple places in a document, and initials or certain pages, etc...
- amyjess 8y agoMy townhouse complex switched from having us hand-sign paper leases to using DocuSign last year, and it's been wonderful. Being able to just click-sign through a lease that requires almost every other page to be signed is a godsend. My hand genuinely got tired before, and quite frankly, I've lived here over 11 years, and there's not going to be anything in the lease I don't already know, so I don't really give a shit about going slowly through the damn thing. In my case, it's better for consistency too. My signature is just a random scribble, so at least with DocuSign it'll now look identical on every page whereas it's different every time if I write by hand. The only thing I really care about is my initials, because I insist on writing my initials as a three-way ligature, and DocuSign is great about that, too. DocuSign will let you either pick one of many fonts or let you mouse-draw it, and you can make that decision separately for your signature and your initials. So I just pick one of their stock fonts for my signature and then mouse-draw my initials.
- danielrhodes 8y agoYou can do this. The best way to see signatures, in my IANAL opinion, is as layers of protection. The goal is that the person who signs the agreement has total understanding of what they are signing, and there is a paper trail of intent to abide by the agreement. To that degree, if the agreement is important and you have a lot on the line if the counterparty decides to re-neg on the agreement, you should probably not do the above. But going in the opposite direction and insisting on notaries and wet ink might go too far in respect to how much effort is required.
- scarface74 8y agoI’ve signed offer emails and “agreement to represent” recruiter emails by just replying “I agree” a few times.
- Spooky23 8y agoYou can absolutely do that. It works between two parties especially when small very well, but doesn’t scale well. It’s also problematic when you deal with an asshole, as it’s difficult to determine who has the correct version of the message.
- danielrhodes 8y agoThis 1000% percent. The way the law looks at signatures is about the signaling of intent. The way engineers/tech look at signatures is more about trust and identity. There is some overlap of course, but if the agreement to be signed is of any real importance, nobody is going to take the chance that the identity is false or that there were no witnesses or a mis-understanding of what is in the agreement, so signing is done with wet ink.
- oh_sigh 8y agoSure, but then why do people use these expensive services like HelloSign, when they could just get away with a "I agree" checkbox, or even a canvas element asking for your signature?