4 ms·
The engineer in me is judging them... why the heck did you make a design that required 3 weird screws? Screws are standardized parts; creating an esoteric hardw
by exabrial 8y ago
The engineer in me is judging them... why the heck did you make a design that required 3 weird screws? Screws are standardized parts; creating an esoteric hardware design in a vacuum with an "oh we'll fix that in production" [literal meaning of production] seems to be the actual problem.
- Nerdfest 8y agoYou just used Apple and the word "standards" in a sentence without the requisite "eschews".
- mitchty 8y agoI voted you down, your comment seems to think that the engineers couldn't possibly have a reason for custom screws. Without knowing the requirements, you'll never know if they had a good reason for custom screws. As such this comment is not constructive at best, and just standard "apple is bad cause no standards" drivel at worst.
- freehunter 8y agoNot to mention Apple's non-standard-compliance is a notable exception, not the rule. The 30-pin connector and Lightning are basically the only proprietary connectors they've had in recent history, and one is phased out while the other is being phased out as we speak (for the standard USB-C, I might add). Firewire, USB-C, Bluetooth, POSIX, etc... Apple doesn't do as much non-standard stuff as people on the Internet would have you think.
- berbec 8y agoI agree with all your points, but have you ever disassembled an iPhone or an aluminum Intel Mac? Everyone has them now, but when they started producing them, no one had triwing, pentawing or those microscopic torx bits. And let's not even start on bricking items repaired by non-"apple-approved" shops months later.
- freehunter 8y agoI would differentiate between "standards" vs "easy to repair". You're not going to find too many standard parts inside of a cell phone no matter who the vendor is. Even if Apple supported replacing the battery yourself, you'd still need an Apple-compatible battery that's not compatible with a Samsung.
- exabrial 8y agoIt's a consumer grade computer. We're not talking about a high performance aircraft, safety critical application, medical accessory, being in hazardous or corrosive environment, something that needs solvent resistance, or vibration resistance. It sits on a desk, that's it. There are tons of screws they could choose from.
- fxfan 8y agoNot an apple fan but I don't think they pull the "non-standard" shenanigans on hardware not directly facing consumers. They must have had a reasoning here.
- gameswithgo 8y agoApple's whole business model is trying to differentiate by not taking shortcuts. So if a weird screw is part of making a slightly better or more interesting design, they are going to do that. We already have plenty of Dell/Asus/Lenovo/etc companies for doing things in more efficient ways.
- setquk 8y agoSimply they are tamper resistance. Albeit crap because it took about a week for the Chinese screwdriver factories to churn them out as well :) I suspect they had to design their own screws however because most of the tamper bits have a lot of torque designed in which makes the heads deeper so they couldn't use an off the shelf design or it would intrude further into the chassis of the device.
- leereeves 8y agoTamper resistant is just a euphemism for "pay Apple $500 for a repair someone else could do for $50".
- setquk 8y agoMore "I didn't want to pay for AppleCare so took and risk and now need to take the phone to a dodgy after market repair company who will stick a generic OEM part on it which may or may not work properly". Apple replaced my 6s before xmas 23 months into AppleCare with a brand new one because there was a light patch on the screen. Cost me £0.
- leereeves 8y agoThat's not a reason to prevent people from repairing/altering their products themselves if they want to. People who didn't have the skills and didn't know a repair shop they trust could still pay for AppleCare, but AppleCare should have to compete on value, not be the only option because Apple locked down the product.
- setquk 8y agoIt's no different to having to buy a TX8 screwdriver because you don't have one already. Even the big brands make them now: https://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/screwdrivers/1230844/ https://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/screwdrivers/1230844/ I have replaced various things on Apple products over the years myself and have had no problems at all. It's not exactly prevention!
- azinman2 8y agoIn modern product design, there is no such thing as a standard screw. You just get a factory (in China) to make exactly the screw you want for the job.
- kilo_bravo_3 8y agoThe iFixit teardown of the Mac Pro notes that no proprietary screws were observed in their teardown. https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Mac+Pro+Late+2013+Teardown/20778 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Mac+Pro+Late+2013+Teardown/2... It may be that there were some non-standard screws used in assemblies that were not disassembled by iFixit, but to me it is more likely that Apple simply used standard Torx screws in custom lengths. Using custom-length screws is not "esoteric" design. My employer uses custom-made custom-length screws in its products, albeit at a much lower volume and with a much longer production time than I assume Apple is dealing with. When we're designing something we don't look at the T5 screws available on the market and design around those, we design the product to meet its requirements and if that means getting a 5.125mm T5 Torx screw custom made instead of the standard 5mm available on the market, that's what we get. Because of the industry I work in, we also have very strict requirements for the type of materials used in our products. If we need a screw it probably needs to be made out of a specific metal that has specific properties like A-286 or similar. You have to be guaranteed that the screws weren't made out of whatever metal was on the dock that day, with a label slapped on them after the fact. We have thermal characteristics we have to meet, but Apple has manufacturing reliability standards it has to meet. There is a near-zero chance that, unless you have a guy IN China going to the factory every day inspecting stuff as it comes off the line, a pallet of 5.125mm T5 Torx screws is going to contain screws that are all exactly 5.125mm in length. Like Apple, we contract out the manufacturing of the screws to regional machine shops. I have only been involved in the manufacturing side of things for about five years, but one of my first lessons was not to rely on dealers and distributors for mission-critical applications. One order of components we received from a very large and well-known supply house was slightly out of spec and set us back several weeks of work because it took time to realize there was a problem, determine what the problem was, and deal with the distributor to fix the problem. Now for one-off jobs we rely on an in-house machine shop and for bulk orders we contract out to local manufacturers rather than relying on a supply chain that traverses multiple disinterested middlemen on its way back to Shenzhen. That way when the 5.125mm screws we ordered come out to 5.13mm our guy can get in his car with a baggie of screws and his Mitutoyo and go to the shop and show them what's wrong. For every problem my small 130-man organization has encountered with manufacturing in the US, Apple probably has dealt with similar problems on a scale that is unimaginably larger, and in my experience no amount of money can fix those problems quickly. Building stuff in the US is harder and slower than just saying "screw it" and slapping a badge on something pumped out of a factory in China. No amount of money, not even Apple Money, can fix that quickly. People fail to understand this, they think money can solve everything. Quite literally, if you have a hundred trillion dollars in cash and an army of buyers ready to spend it you can't fix most lead time problems.