4 ms·
So, I have a question and it may seem like a childish or stupid one because I think I've missed something somewhere. Our society, and I think capitalism in gen
by dijit 8y ago
So, I have a question and it may seem like a childish or stupid one because I think I've missed something somewhere.
Our society, and I think capitalism in general, seems to be pinned on the foundation of perpetual growth.
The question for me is: how can we have infinite growth on a planet with limited resources?
- mrfusion 8y agoTechnology? Well not infinite but up to the point of a dyson sphere.
- scottlocklin 8y agoWhat massive efficiencies have technology brought us lately? I count ... fracking as a real improvement. That's it!
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoFracking as we know it today started in the 40’s, it’s just a matter of economics that it’s feasible to do on a wide scale today. Mind you, that only goes to further reinforce your point. Edit. Every example other people are posting have been around for longer than most of us have been alive. I’m not trying to take a dump on the notion of progress, but I feel the distinction between “new” and “maturing” is being lost.
- xiphias2 8y agoInternet? You know you wouldn't be able to take part in this debate without it. I wasn't able to read so many interesting things 20 years ago, and I was behind in everything because I wasn't born at the right place in the world.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoThe internet is probably older than you are. A lot of the “exciting new tech” is a mature or market-ready form of technology that has been around since the Cold War or much earlier. There is also a lot of very old tech that is “new” only by virtue of having a microcontroller stuck in, much in the same way an IoT device is often just Device X + Network connection.
- scottlocklin 8y ago20 years ago, the internet was vastly superior to what we have now, which is basically turning into a much worse version of Genie, Compuserve and/or Prodigy (... now with more surveillance dystopia ...).
- shaki-dora 8y agoLong-distance phone calls Long-distance message transmission DTP Photography Short-haul flights Electric lighting (LED uses less than 10% of the power of incascendent bulbs) Travel, in general (remember luggage did not have wheels until the 70s because it was expected that a traveler would have servants to carry their luggage)
- toomuchtodo 8y agoElectricity from utility scale solar PV and wind turbines cost ~2 cents/kwh. That's orders of magnitude decline over the last 15 years.
- ummonk 8y agoSpace travel.
- shaki-dora 8y agoWhile economic output has historically correlated with ressource usage, there is nothing that requires such a link. For energy, this is called “energy intensity”, and we already see it stagnating, and energy being sourced from infinite (renewable) resources rather than fossil fuels. The same can happen with materials: there is definitely enough iron and brick and glass and cobalt on this planet to enable everyone to live in comfort and safety. One iPad likely requires far less natural resources than a C64 and screen, while delivering far more value. And once people are clothed, and fed, and housed, consumption increasingly turns to “intellectual” value, i. e. theatre, or Netflix, or a good book.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoConsumption also turns into a way to show status to attract mates, and one of the most resource consuming activities, traveling, is currently in vogue for those who have attained housing and food security.
- choeger 8y agoEconomic growth is not measured in the usage of limited resources. You can have growth by simply increasing the efficiency not the production sector and offering more services.
- countryqt30 8y ago1) Think of the universe, don't limit yourself to 1 tiny planet 2) Technology 3) Re-using resources
- nabla9 8y agoIncreasing productivity can increase the output while other factors of production stay the same. Reducing material intensity and energy intensity allows growth under material and energy constraints. If population starts to decline, you can continue increasing GDP/capita even in material terms. Although in practice I think reduced demand from population decline is bigger issue than material resources.
- fallingfrog 8y agoProductivity can’t increase forever either.
- koboll 8y ago>The question for me is: how can we have infinite growth on a planet with limited resources? 1. Some resources are truly unlimited. We can ultimately meet all our food and energy needs via unlimited energy from the sun, for example. If necessary, the economy would adjust to do just that. 2. We aren't going to be limited to one planet forever. We'll be mining extraterrestrial objects long before we run out of stone or metal on Earth.
- fallingfrog 8y agoAs for point 2: you’re underestimating the distance between stars. Trade on the interstellar scale can’t exist; so we’re limited to at most our own solar system (I would count a colony in a new solar system to be a separate system altogether).
- koboll 8y agoIn the extremely long term, yes, we will probably have to abandon the solar system. But others exist and are reachable.
- fallingfrog 8y agoYou can’t, but the belief that you can is a deeply ingrained feature of capitalist ideology, so everyone walks around believing that you can.
- pesmhey 8y agoThe genius of capitalism is that it realizes a world in which constant growth is a natural law of the universe. The folly of capitalism is that it realizes a world in which constant growth is a natural law of the universe.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoEconomic growth is not primarily derived through the extraction of resources, is why. As we become more sophisticated, we learn how to make better and better use of resources. Right now, we value some resources more than others. As we evolve, that dynamic shifts. How valuable was Uranium ore 100 years ago? Well, it was just a kind of poisonous rock. Now it can power cities. Freshwater was 'unlimited' 100 years ago, now it's a little more scarce so we have to put economic terms around it, meaning it'll be too costly for some industries which will adapt. Etc. etc..
- shoo 8y ago> how can we have infinite growth on a planet with limited resources? I find it sad but unsurprising that a reasonable question like this attracts a bunch of downvotes here. I heartily recommend Higgs' book "Collision Course" -- it doesn't provide solutions about how to get ourselves out of the mess that we're in, but it does provide a lot of historical evidence explaining how much public thought and speech around economic growth has been warped by propaganda: Kerryn Higgs -- Collision Course: Endless Growth on a Finite Planet https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/collision-course https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/collision-course A few quotes from reviews: > If modern society ever had a core taboo it is against speaking favorably of limits, especially with respect to growth. > Higgs explains brilliantly how our ideas about economics and the environment have been carefully warped and manipulated over decades, just so a small minority could get rich.
- dijit 8y agoThanks for the recommendation, from the quotes that seems like the exact thing to fill my knowledge gap. :)