4 ms·
Could someone who understands the technical issues explain the details better? While perfect security is of course impossible, I would think that a 'secure' fl
by nkurz 16y ago
Could someone who understands the technical issues explain the details better? While perfect security is of course impossible, I would think that a 'secure' flash player could basically be grabbed off-the-shelf. And I haven't really thought about it, but I don't understand why a native app would be that hard. I presume the goal is just to make it difficult to record the movies to disk?
- mattparcher 16y agoI agree. Clarification would be especially appreciated for: The hurdle has been the lack of a generic and complete platform security and content protection mechanism available for Android. The same security issues that have led to piracy concerns on the Android platform have made it difficult for us to secure a common Digital Rights Management (DRM) system on these devices.
- nutjob123 16y agoAre they only willing to use copy protection designed by the makers of the operating system they are using? I'm just speculating but this seems to be the case for ps3, xbox, wii, mac, pc, ipad.
- mortenjorck 16y agoI never thought about it like that, but now that you mention it, it does seem a likely pattern. It's especially plausible because it frees Netflix from responsibility for content protection systems across platforms -- if one of the targets is compromised, the studios have to deal with the hardware vendor, not Netflix.
- doron 16y agoAndroid hack development has reached a point where replacing the manufacturer OS with a custom version built by hackers has become completely trivial on some leading models. not only do I see more and more nontechnical users carrying android phones, but an increasing number of them carry rooted and custom OS builds. The office manager at my workplace found her Verizon stock OS slow,and prone to occasional crashes in trying to understand why, she stumbled about (google search)a howto article on replacing the OS in two clicks (using unrevoked, adding a zip file to your phone, and clicking some key combination), having done so, happy and empowered by the change she performed, she instructs other nontech how to own (!!!) their handsets. The point of this story is that: 1. This is probably the intention behind why google allowed this to happen (if you check XDA developers, its thriving). in this sense phones are different then full fledged computers, hacks tend to work fine and even better then the bundle, certainly cleaner. you can download and replace your phone ROM on the fly now with rom manager (available on Google app market, and try several flavor for your own phone, (with/without htc sense, clean froyo etc..) restoring your bought apps is simple, just log into your Google account, and re download. 2. The Movie industry will shun a platform that non sanctioned (i.e not supporting DRM) developers and users can easily command, Netflix has no choice but to comply.
- YooLi 16y agoThey are more than willing, it is what they require. That is what he is saying is the problem. Android has none 'built in', so in order to bring the app to a handset, the manufacturer of the handset has to provide it.
- nkurz 16y agoI don't think this is quite true. Doesn't Netflix on Mac use Microsoft's Silverlight, which is not provided by Apple? And wouldn't the streaming requirements for Hulu (which is using Flash) be the essentially the same as for Netflix? So while they are saying that the manufacturer has to provide the DRM, I'm not sure where this 'requirement' is coming from.
- YooLi 16y agoOn PCs they chose the Silverlight platform, but what do PCs have to do with mobile devices. Silverlight isn't available on mobile devices, and choosing Flash for android deployment wouldn't help them much either. How many android devices run flash? How many of those run it well? Does anyone provide a content protection framework for Android? No, and that's the problem. What part isn't 'quite true'?
- nkurz 16y agowhat do PCs have to do with mobile devices I see them as pretty much indistinguishable, but maybe my perspective is skewed: my cell phone (HTC Incredible) and my laptop (Thinkpad X31) have roughly comparable processors and both run Linux. There's some differences in API, but I don't see anything inherently different about them. As time goes on, I think the blurring will continue. How many android devices run flash I'm not sure, but I presume that anything running Android 2.2 will. This should include all high end phones sold this year, plus everything for the future. I think most of these run it well, and would bet that all future Android phones will. What part isn't 'quite true'? I feel it is false to say that either Netflix or the studios require that the DRM be provided by the underlying OS. I think this is proven the existence of Netflix streaming to Silverlight in OSX. The ability of Hulu to use a flash solution also casts doubt, but this might depend on whether 'they' refers to the studios or to Netflix. But if it's a Netflix requirement to require OS level DRM, I'd wonder why they have this requirement.
- bigmac 16y agoThere are certain specs that anyone implementing a video streaming/content delivery service must comply with. The studios mandate that certain specs be followed, and an engineer has to sign off that they've implemented the DRM spec correctly. For an example, look at DTCP-IP (http://www.dtcp.com/ http://www.dtcp.com/) The specs mandate usage of certain types of encryption algorithms, key lengths, key expirations, etc. All the data that is sent over the wire is encrypted, so that no one using a packet sniffer can trivially obtain the unencrypted video. Thus, from the point of view of the attacker, the problem becomes extracting the encryption keys from the software and using that to decrypt the sniffed traffic. Every device/software module ends up having a some root key that must be seriously obfuscated, because that key provides the security for the entire system. It must be embedded in the software or hardware. If its in hardware the problem is easier, because it cannot be disassembled and discovered as readily. In software, the problem is more challenging. Some form of White-Box Cryptography has to be used. So, a secure flash player or a native app is only the first step in the solution. The whole key management system has to be built or provided by a 3rd party library. Google doesn't have such a library built in to Android. After you have the library, all kinds of nasty tricks have to be used on the library itself. Generally, the goal is to prevent debugging and code modification. The tactics used are very similar to what malware authors use to protect their malware from reverse engineering.
- nkurz 16y agoAre the requirements for Hulu different than those for Netflix? Or is the Hulu solution flash plus a hardened native library of the sort you describe. I guess my confusion is why Netflix couldn't do the same. My instinct is that key exchange is tricky but a solved problem, that the encryption itself is trivial once you have the keys, that true security is impossible without hardware support (TPM), that analog holes will always exist, and that the current hard part is preventing someone from swiping your digital video stream on its way to the screen. Does this seem accurate?
- bigmac 16y agoIts all based on whose content you are streaming, and what specifications they mandate for access to their content. Generally, I'd imagine both Hulu and Netflix are subject to the same specs, but I'm not familiar with the specifics. Your instinct is close. key exchange is tricky but a solved problem. True encryption itself is trivial once you have the keys Encryption/decryption itself is trivial in hardware. In software, its wholly non-trivial to the point that it merits investigation by the academic community. analog holes will always exist and the current hard part is preventing someone from swiping your digital video stream on its way to the screen Analog holes do exist, but its still easier to extract keys from software and decrypt wireshark dumps. Especially because this can allow you to fully automate the process. A few more notes about software decryption. The problem that is trying to be solved by all DRM providers is one that is not well addressed by existing cryptographic protocols. That is, what do you when Eve is Bob? In DRM the attacker is also the consumer. The best we can hope for is that only one piece of software/hardware is capable of doing the job of decryption, and that you can bake it in in such a way that no one else can use the key material. I consider this an open question. It is possible there is a great solution waiting to be discovered by researchers. It wasn't always clear that Public Key cryptography was possible -- this problem could be similar.
- chewbranca 16y agoI'm not exactly sure what the underlying issue is on android devices, but at least for linux desktops, the problem is netflix uses silverlight which does have support for DRM, whereas the linux version moonlight does not. It could be a similar issue for flash on android devices, although that is just speculation on my part. All I know for sure is that I'm anxiously waiting netflix on both linux and android. I currently use a windows VM to watch netflix from my computer. On a similar note, one of the most appealing things to me about the ipad is that it does have netflix support. I would love to see it supported on android tablets.