4 ms·
I find it unfortunate that I don't speak German, because the Energiewende is so interesting. The data that is clear is that carbon emissions have not dropped an
by roenxi 8y ago
I find it unfortunate that I don't speak German, because the Energiewende is so interesting. The data that is clear is that carbon emissions have not dropped and energy prices have risen. Population is up a little (maybe ~2%). The steady emissions are a bit so-so, and aren't promising of an Energiewende success.
What is missing for me is I can't source a current (~2017 or 2018) timeseries on German Energy/Capita use, which is a very important piece of the puzzle. Even if I could, I can't check sources because of the language barrier, so I wouldn't really be able to argue using it. If the per capita number has gone up then the Energiewende is very impressive. If it has gone down a lot, a failure. If it is middling, success is a political question.
The data will get out eventually. A lot of the interim reporting seems to combine spin and evidence-that-isn't really-evidence like negative power prices (which don't really say if 'things are working or not').
- lispm 8y ago> If the per capita number has gone up then the Energiewende is very impressive. If it has gone down a lot, a failure. If it is middling, success is a political question. That makes little sense. A goal of German energy politics is to reduce energy per capita use.
- roenxi 8y ago> A goal of German energy politics is to reduce energy per capita use. Really? That sounds remarkably foolish; I'm surprised there are riots in France but not Germany. Is there some sort of justification for such a damaging policy?
- sveme 8y agoWhy is that foolish? What‘s foolish about replacing light bulbs, reducing energy consumption of your appliances or reducing the energy consumption of your transport system?
- roenxi 8y agoThose things probably wouldn't reduce per capita energy consumption. Energy is extremely fungible; it would likely trigger Jevon's paradox [0] and results in rising demand for energy. The only way to reduce per capita energy consumption is to ban people from doing things, or tax them until the poor can't afford it any more. An economy won't leave energy untapped because people are using it more efficiently. Energy is very valuable. Particularly in Germany's case, if per capita energy use is dropping, it is quite likely it is because people can't afford to buy some of Europe's most expensive power. That tends to upset. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- lispm 8y ago> The only way to reduce per capita energy consumption is to ban people from doing things The way to reduce energy consumption is to a have a more efficient infrastructure and more efficient consumer devices. In the private sector, public sectors and the industry. Increasing 'efficiency' is a huge goal. This starts with using less primary energy for the production of the same amount of electricity, using so-far wasted energy (like heat from power plants), using less stand-by energy, increasing transport efficiency, use of less energy-intensive production processes in industry, ...
- roenxi 8y agoI'm not sure I'm picking up what your putting down, but I don't think I disagree with much you've written. However, if you just increase energy efficiency, energy consumption will not go down. If it was worth your time to get X energy to produce Y results, and now X energy produces Y+1 results, it isn't particularly obvious to wind back X. It makes more sense to keep X constant and enjoy the greater results. If you could justify using X before, it is even easier to justify it now. If you want to reduce energy consumption without compromising living standards, then you will indeed need to increase energy efficiency, but simultaneously you are going to need very firm measures (bans, punitive taxes, etc) to stop people just enjoying having more stuff for the same amount of effort. I think that is a mistake myself, and likely to lead to very angry voters. There were predictions years ago that we wouldn't need to work because we would be so productive by this century. They got the productivity increases right, but radically underestimated how much people value leisure vs having more stuff. We still work a 5 day week, despite the fact that we just don't need to do that to maintain a lifestyle our great grandparents had.
- T-A 8y agoI don't think final figures for 2018 are out yet. For 2017: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fde.statista.com%2Fstatistik%2Fdaten%2Fstudie%2F42195%2Fumfrage%2Fdeutschland---verbrauch-an-primaerenergie-in-millionen-tonnen-oelaequivalent%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https... https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fde.statista.com%2Fstatistik%2Fdaten%2Fstudie%2F2861%2Fumfrage%2Fentwicklung-der-gesamtbevoelkerung-deutschlands%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...