4 ms·
He makes some valid points, but what doesn't quite add up is that not all of these "monopolies" are built on network effects. Google search, for instance, doesn
by fauigerzigerk 16y ago
He makes some valid points, but what doesn't quite add up is that not all of these "monopolies" are built on network effects. Google search, for instance, doesn't benefit from network effects. Gmail doesn't benefit from network effects, nor does anything else that Google does (successfully). Of course Google benefits from its size in many ways but that's not the same kind of self feeding dynamic as a network effect.
Amazon became big by selling books. Did publishers really say, hey, let's sell to the biggest online book store only? Would it be any more inconvenient for buyers to buy from a different online book store just because it was not the biggest? I don't think so. There is no network effect, just plain old economies of scale and the power of brands.
Myspace was the biggest. Friendster was the biggest. Both in areas that clearly do benefit massively from network effects.
So, I agree with the author on some points, but I think he plays down the "being better" part a little too much and he ignores substitution effects.
- bryanlarsen 16y agoDid we read the same article? The author definitely payed much less attention to "network effects" than most articles on this subject usually do, explaining that it is quite common for monopolies to be created for new technologies, as well as giving several other reasons, some of which you reiterated.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoIt appears to me that he explains the emergence of these monopolies almost exclusively with network effects: "Internet industries develop pretty much like any other industry that depends on a network: A single firm can dominate the market if the product becomes more valuable to each user as the number of users rises. Such networks have a natural tendency to grow, and that growth leads to dominance." and "Still, in a land where at least two mega-colas and two brands of diaper can duke it out indefinitely, why are there so many single-firm information markets? The explanation would seem to lie in the famous American preference for convenience. With networks, size brings convenience." Did you find any other explanation in the article?
- bryanlarsen 16y agoI think this is the meaty quote: "Apart from brief periods of openness created by new inventions or antitrust breakups, every medium, starting with the telegraph, has eventually proved to be a case study in monopoly. In fact, many of those firms are still around, if not quite as powerful as they once were, including AT&T, Paramount and NBC." Also, your latter quote seems to me to be about size & convenience, not networks. He's using "network" in the sense "on the internet", not in the sense of "network effects". My basic point is that the article has a lot of good things to say, and says relatively little about network effects. So if people read your comment first, they're not going to read the article because they can think "oh yeah network effects, been there done that"
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoI do agree that the article has other things to say as well. It's not a bad article. But I'm pretty sure that the second quote is supposed to mean that network effects cause larger online services to be more convenient for users. I don't agree with that in general. It's true only in some specific cases where integration of several services makes things more seamless. Your quote doesn't give a reason _why_ monopolies develop. It just states _that_ they do. Also, there is nothing about how they can unravel pretty quickly.