7 ms·
> He starts with one of his greatest hits: “People consistently tell us that if they’re going to see ads, they want them to be relevant.” This perpetuates the a
by crazygringo 8y ago
> He starts with one of his greatest hits: “People consistently tell us that if they’re going to see ads, they want them to be relevant.” This perpetuates the ad industry’s favorite false dichotomy: either consumers can have “relevant” ads—targeted using huge collections of sensitive behavioral data—or they can be bombarded by spam for knock-off Viagra and weight-loss supplements. The truth is that ads can be made “relevant” and profitable based on the context in which they’re shown, like putting ads for outdoor gear in a nature magazine.
I disagree, it's not a false dichotomy, it's a real one.
Most Internet content isn't nearly as "contextual" as a nature magazine. Probably 99% of the content I read won't help target ads much at all, because it's mostly NYT news articles and the like.
I'm probably in a tiny minority here on HN, but I accept that ads are currently necessary to fund companies (even though I wish it weren't true), and I genuinely prefer ads targeted towards my interests (I've gone so far as to customize my interests on Google to help it serve me more relevant ads -- most of them were accurate but there were a handful that weren't).
Targeting obviously isn't always perfect -- they still don't have the kink ironed out where I keep seeing ads for something on Amazon even after I bought the thing or a similar thing -- but it really does benefit users, if they've got to put up with ads in the first place.
- cobookman 8y ago+100 I love ads that give me relevant new information. Linus tech tips is a great example of this. Some of his reviews are paid sponsorships, however the info is still relevant. Same goes for Casey neistats review of the diji drones.
- beezischillin 8y agoThe thing is that Linus has been pretty visionary about when it comes to the state of the internet and creators and when YouTube first started shafting creators he began to look for an alternative way to monetise his content. That's why he weathered the whole BS-carousel around advertising on YouTube pretty well. He's built a brand based on sponsorships inside the tech industry, a brand where they take care to only lend their name to brands and products that are worth it. I would wager they put a lot of work into selecting what paid product features to do or not. There still is a bit of a difference between sponsored spots in their videos and general upset about the internet advertising industry, however. I will always gave him a lot of credit for that. It's not possible for all creators to do the same, but the ones that can should follow his example for everyone's benefit.
- StudentStuff 8y agoLinus has been well poised to survive the demonetization apocalypse much better than other shows by building brand sponsorships that are somewhat relevant to his prime content. That being said, I can't stand most of his content. He tried to build a server, bought the wrong case, and thought he could take a dremel and an angle grinder to the motherboard to fix it. This didn't work, so he RMA'ed it and took another angle grinder to the new one. His Ubiquiti and Unraid adventures are similarly ill informed, causing him to attempt things that won't work or work poorly for a short time, then fail spectacularly. Attempted Server Build: https://redd.it/3ktkmr https://redd.it/3ktkmr
- beezischillin 8y agoYeah, a lot of it is hard to watch. Remember the whole room watercooling project? That being said, I gotta say kudos to the business end of his operation.
- cobookman 8y agoTo quote the top reddit post: """ This is why I watch Linus for entertainment and not for learning. I enjoy watching these videos because he does things that I cannot afford to do myself and in my opinion the projects are entertaining to watch. The Techquickie videos are great to watch for learning, because they actually spend a lot of time on having correct information. """
- Kye 8y agoI wonder if this is similar to how CinemaSins makes up a lot of "sins" to draw in rage clicks. People make entire videos pointing out how catastrophically wrong it is! That's a lot of free press.
- DeRock 8y agoNeither of those are targeted advertising... you are arguing for the opposite point of the parent comment. From the article, the EFF is saying that ads relevant to the content being shown are effective (like you’ve described here) without needing to collect a wealth of information about individual users.
- fljsgekskfv 8y agoSpeak for yourself; I hate being manipulated.
- interpol_p 8y agoRelevant ads through tracking are different to relevant ads because your favourite author thinks "hey, my readers will be interested in this." I don't mind the latter, too. I usually have a lot of interest in the sponsorships chosen by my favourite writers to include on their sites. Automated ad networks and tracking though, I just block those.
- cobookman 8y agoHow are they different? Both are targeted. Sure the tracking ads aren't as good, but imagine they were just as highly targeted and relavent.
- tripzilch 8y agoWell, one doesn't violate your privacy. Also it's more relevant. I could imagine tracking ads to be more relevant, but they're not. So I don't really see the point of that hypothetical.
- kerng 8y agoThere are targeted ads, and then there are invasive ads. The tremendous intrusion of privacy falls more in to the invasive bucket. If you like ads, maybe there should be a portal you go to see ads just for you- if you'd like to surrender all your data to have someone else tell you what you should buy. Having ads be part of browsing experience is just an awful user experience.
- XorNot 8y agoSee weirdly enough I do this - that's in many ways what eBay and other classified sites are for me. When I visit them I'm very much asking for people to advertise to me, convince me to consider their wares.
- kace91 8y agoThe main concerns are not the ads themselves, but the uncontrolled amounts of information that are being collected to tailor those ads (and that can potentially be then used for far more evil purposes), the emerging tendency to try to get users addicted to content so they can see more ads (with unintended consequences like radicalization of news because extreme content receives more visits ), and the question of how effective a manipulation technique has to be before it crosses the line between marketing and control of masses.
- rayvy 8y ago> The main concerns are not the ads themselves ^ This. > but the uncontrolled amounts of information that are being collected to tailor those ads ^ Especially this. (side note: funny thing how so much of this information is gathered, yet targeting is still so bad) > the emerging tendency to try to get users addicted to content so they can see more ads Also very important. These platforms don't build features with "how to make things better for users" in mind, they do so with "how do we increase user engagement for ad spend" (see Snapchat as a prime example)
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThe targeting only looks bad because you don't know how valuable a lead is in the relevant business. If you're a tenth as likely to click on something with ten times the customer acquisition cost, then from the platform's perspective these are equally profitable to show. Case in point: do some searches on mattresses and see what ads you see over the next weeks. Huge value per customer, so if you can plausibly be lumped into mattress firms' targeting options they'll win the auction.
- ilovetux 8y ago> do some searches on mattresses and see what ads you see over the next weeks. This sounds like an interesting experiment. I mean, the result seems obvious for a search on mattresses, but I think we can expand on this to search for more controversial or political topics. I'm going to start planning this experiment and I'd be very interested if anyone knows of an existing study along the same lines.
- cco 8y agoThat's very surprising to me, why would you care what ads you get if it means mortgaging your privacy? If we grant that ads are a given, just give me whatever bullshit you want, I won't click on any of them and I'm ignoring them either way.
- themacguffinman 8y agoBecause bullshit untargeted ads aren't worth much. There's no point in accepting worthless ads that don't adequately fund the sites that serve them.
- JetSpiegel 8y agoBut if you are ignoring them anyway, won't the add value remain at 0?
- themacguffinman 8y agoSure, if you think all advertising never works on anyone.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThere's an incentive mismatch that's fundamental to advertising. Advertisers bid on platforms for specific cohorts identified by some piece of data, and their bids are determined by the value of a lead in their business. So from the perspective of an ad platform, advertising to you isn't just about what interests you and what you're likely to buy, but the product of producer surplus times likelihood to buy. Interested in something that makes a company more money? You'll see proportionally more ads for it at the same interest level.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThis is also a reason why I don't trust ads and sales/customer support recommendations when shopping. As you noted, companies try to push what makes them the most money, not what is best fit for my use case.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThis is particularly a good idea with investing. Anyone whose job it is to pitch things to you basically can't be trusted. The size of this sort of financial service industry makes it obvious how big of a deal the fees are in this area.
- throw2016 8y agoOn the contrary with web content you can get enough context about the information being served. Combine that with IP geolocation and you have more than enough information. But this is not about users or ads, its about self serving people thinking its ok to stalk people and hoover up data without a care about privacy because of an absence of regulatory constraints and inadequate privacy protection. The end result is the continuous building and expansion of highly invasive profiles to offer more and more extreme segmentation to advertisers and a toxic business model.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mikekchar 8y agoYoutube has started giving thumbs up and thumbs down to ads, which I think is a really good idea. I would be incredibly happy to offer information about what ads I want to see. I would even spend time out of my day to do it. This is an area which I think is sadly neglected -- they say they are collecting data to target ads, but actually they are using the same shotgun tactics that marketers always do. It's bizarre, though. I wonder if Youtube even looks at the results of those thumbs up/thumbs down. I never, ever, ever, want to see another ad for Grammerly. Never. But I'm inundated with them anyway :-( (And in case Google is watching: I don't pay for SaaS. Never have. Never will. Stop sending that stuff to me... Heh heh... One can only hope...).
- Phlarp 8y agoFrom the advertisers perspective; they may not want to spend ad dollars on people who are already highly likely to use their product or service. Ideally ad spends have you picking up customers on the margins that you otherwise would not have and this is very likely to play into targeting decisions.
- bungle 8y agoThe easiest is to sell more to people who are already your customers. That's the main target. Occasionally you also want to try to conquer new people, perhaps from your competitors. Those are the two targets, out of which the first one is more important.
- mikekchar 8y agoThe thing is, I'm actually interested in soliciting suppliers for various things. It would help me out quite a bit if they came to me rather than me to them. I make cheese. I need cheese making supplies. I travel from Japan to Europe once a year I need flight tickets. I'd love to upgrade to slightly bigger seats if I can afford it. Show me some comparison prices against your competition in that area. My bank is driving me crazy but it's the only one I can find that handles forex without charging me an arm and a leg. If you're good on that front, try to upsell me on something else. I'm interested in wet shaving and I need a supplier for products. I need a credit card, but I can't get one normally because I'm not a permanent resident in Japan. I know there are solutions, but I'm not aware of where to look. Various dry food staples are hard to get in the grocery store in the rural area where I live. I could give you a list if it would help. I am likely to travel somewhere in Japan 2-3 times this year for the purpose of visiting an onsen and staying over night in a Japanese style inn. I go to Saitama about 6 times a year to watch baseball and I often want to stay overnight. I'm not sure if it makes sense to stay in a hotel or AirBnB or something else. I need to buy tickets to Disney Sea this summer and I'd like to do it ahead of time if possible. Seriously, I could (and would) go on for a long time. I have tons of things I'm likely to buy for which I'd love some help. There is a lot of personal information in the above, but all of it is stuff I'm happy for the world to know. There is a lot of other stuff I don't actually want to advertise and I'd rather the two categories didn't get mixed up.
- jammygit 8y agoIf there wasn't ad supported content, people would have to buy high quality goods and services for money. That seems like a good thing in an economy. Edit: the problem is that the 'free' ad driven business model makes it extremely difficult for non-free legitimate business models to succeed.
- leguminous 8y ago> Most Internet content isn't nearly as "contextual" as a nature magazine. Probably 99% of the content I read won't help target ads much at all, because it's mostly NYT news articles and the like. The NYT cut behavioral advertising in Europe after the GDPR and still grew revenue: https://digiday.com/media/new-york-times-gdpr-cut-off-ad-exchanges-europe-ad-revenue/ https://digiday.com/media/new-york-times-gdpr-cut-off-ad-exc... Edit: I just read the EFF post and realized this article was linked. Did the parent poster mean that 99% of what he or she read was not NYT articles and the like?
- threatofrain 8y agoWhy do you prefer ads targeted to your interest? What % of your purchases are improved and not merely influenced by your ad viewing? I prefer untargeted ads since I'm not about to improve my knowledge or shopping performance just by viewing ads, and I'd rather not have my privacy compromised.
- leetcrew 8y ago> I prefer untargeted ads since I'm not about to improve my knowledge or shopping performance just by viewing ads. maybe this is true for you personally, but I don't think it holds in general. most of the time ads are completely useless (and I personally run ad blockers on every device I control) but every once in a while I see an ad for something useful I just wasn't aware of. for example, I recently saw an ad for an electric hot plate that can keep a mug of coffee warm indefinitely. at first I thought it looked like a piece of trash, but then I thought what the hell, it's $10 and my coffee often gets cold before I finish drinking it. it turns out that piece of trash keeps coffee at pretty much the ideal temperature for drinking. I have gotten well over $10 worth of enjoyment from the thing and I would never have thought to purchase it if I hadn't seen the ad.
- jgys 8y agoI can relate to this phenomenon (the “hey this $10 gadget I didn’t know existed but for an ad I saw has actually ended up being super useful to me!” thing), but the problem is that stories that end with me making a purchase with which I was satisfied, from which I got utility commensurate with the cost, are a vanishing minority of stories that begin with me seeing an ad. In fact, the vast majority of the ads I see I couldn’t tell a story about at all, because I see hundreds or even thousands of ads each day and they’re so fleeting. But the effects of seeing so many ads isn’t fleeting. Whether the deliberate manipulation of my attention is successful at influencing my behavior to increase the advertiser’s revenue is irrelevant, because my attention being manipulated either way, and relentlessly so, by numerous actors who are competing with each other for space in mind, using tools and techniques so sophisticated as to be heretofore unimaginable... and this results in much less space in mind being left for... me! This is the problem with which I take issue.
- pdonis 8y ago> I accept that ads are currently necessary to fund companies I don't. Facebook (and Google and Twitter) have inflicted the ad-supported business model on themselves. If they were really concerned about their users, they would figure out how to allow their users to pay directly for their services, without seeing any ads or having any personal information collected. Call it the "premium option" or something, like so many app developers do. These companies are perfectly capable of doing that; they're just too lazy to try.
- gehwartzen 8y agoFacebook had $15 Billion in US ad revenue (2018) and 214 Million US users. So ~$70/yr/person. I would gladly pay that for an ad free experience given the option.
- pdonis 8y agoI don't use Facebook, but the numbers are fairly similar for Google, and I would gladly pay that amount for ad-free, snooping-free Google search.
- reshie 8y agothats not how it works though. they would try to do both if they could. look at the cable company via tv. it is only a issue cause how the net began and why some companies have eased into these models.
- dennisgorelik 8y agoMost likely Facebook is making more than $70/year/person from users who are willing to pay $70/month for ads-free experience. The reason for that is that usually only people with higher than average income are willing to pay for their ads-free accounts. People with higher than average income - are more appealing target for advertisers. So, most likely, Facebook is making more ad revenue than average from wealthier users. Advertising allows to "implicitly charge" wealthier users more than poorer users.
- 8y ago
- tedunangst 8y agoWhat kinds of non targeted ads would be "relevant" to someone viewing Facebook? Like outdoor gear in a nature magazine, except Facebook isn't a nature magazine, so instead the ads should be for...?
- JetSpiegel 8y agoThe same for broadcast television. Products for old people, brand awareness campaigns, banks.
- username223 8y ago> Most Internet content isn't nearly as "contextual" as a nature magazine. Probably 99% of the content I read won't help target ads much at all, because it's mostly NYT news articles and the like. Really? What section were you reading? What was the article about? This seems way more "contextual" than an entire issue of National Geographic. If you're reading an article about college basketball from the sports section, you might be interested in shoes or a fantasy sports league. An article about the Hamptons in Real Estate? Polo ponies and expensive watches. One about Somalia? Either a Toyota Hilux, or you're probably not worth advertising to. And I honestly wouldn't mind the Viagra and diet pill ads. If I'm going to see ads, I don't care if they're relevant or not; I just want them to be unobtrusive. Google crushed AltaVista not just because it delivered better results, but because its keyword-based ads were plain text on one side of the page, not giant animated GIFs.
- austincheney 8y agoA real dichotomy is a binary choice. Any false dichotomy is that binary choice forced to the absence of other possibilities. This is a false dichotomy. First of all it excludes the idea that there are revenue options other than advertisements. Secondly, it excludes the idea that advertisements can be relevant to a user's session that are contextually valid and otherwise ignore user history, which often tend to produce the most relevant ads. Third, the relevance of ads shown to users is highly debatable as most of the supposedly relevant ads shown to me are only 1 step away from the spam I get in email. Fourth, relevance can be determined by factors other than user data, such as search term auction. Fifth, privacy violating ads have shown to be extremely effective, such that if a person buys something ads for that thing are shown to the person's friends with compelling social pressure.
- owens99 8y agoWell said. Not to mention the biggest issue here is not about ads. It is the potential for abuse of power and for Facebook or partners of FB to target and harm specific individuals.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoQuestion: have you ever bought anything from a targeted ad? Do you go out of your way to try to buy things from ads in the media you read? Do you feel bad if you don't make buy anything that was advertised to you in said media? Why or why not?
- mempko 8y agowhy would you want Ads targeting your interests? They make you spend more money than you otherwise would have. Ads work and manipulate you. To me the perfect Ads are those that are completely opposite my interest so that I don't spend that extra cash.
- chillacy 8y agoI usually find products by word of mouth or news articles but those are increasingly being monetized through “social marketing” and submarine articles. As time goes on everything just gets worse.
- hakfoo 8y agoI think the issue is more that there are large swaths of media that can't be effectively stuffed with relevant ads on their content alone.
- paulie_a 8y agoInternet advertising is no more targeted, relevant to the user or of higher quality than it was in 2000. SV engineers have absolutely utterly failed to push the needle forward.
- abalone 8y ago> I disagree, it's not a false dichotomy, it's a real one. This is very demonstrably false: Search engines can serve ads that are highly targeted to the user's query without knowing anything else about them. You can see the gangbusters revenue that Google generates just from simple keyword searches: "insurance", "loans", "mortgage", "attorney", etc.[1] Not that they don't also try to learn more about you, but it's correct to say "tracking vs. Viagra" is a false dichotomy. [1] https://www.wordstream.com/articles/most-expensive-keywords https://www.wordstream.com/articles/most-expensive-keywords
- the_mitsuhiko 8y agoI’m sure I’m not the only customer but I rather have non targeted and non contextual ads. In fact the only ads I would freely chose are ads for things I absolutely do not want to buy. Any ad for a product I would actually want just increases the likelyhood of me buying that product which in general is not what I want. I already spent too much money on useless things.
- tripzilch 8y agoSame. If it was information I wanted to see, they wouldn't have to pay to show it to me--I would go and find it myself.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- brownbat 8y ago> Targeting obviously isn't always perfect -- ... I keep seeing ads ... even after I bought the thing or a similar thing I'm sympathetic to your argument up until here, where you describe not just an edge case but nearly the entirety of my experience engaging with targeted ads. As an early evangelist of recommendation engines, I'm still hoping for ads to be useful. It feels more like waiting for godot every year. Sidenote- really appreciated the carefully argued contrary position, still upvoted.
- psycho_path 8y agoIt really is a sign of malignant deception, to spin the conversation in such a way that leaves the audience with an impression that anyone finds advertising desireable. Much worse is to offer a bargain between an experience involving ads that are merely irritating (a reflection of those most motivated to advertise) and being informed on and psychologically targeted by those who would drain your wallet (a reflection of the awareness of some of your most guarded secrets being placed in front of total strangers who want your money).
- monochromatic 8y agoAny benefits (to companies) of targeted ads are not worth the cost (to me) of the spying. Period.