5 ms·
I didn't really agree with this idea initially, but the argument was persuasive. Certainly I don't think any of them have the kind of monopoly that AT&T had, b
by dasil003 16y ago
I didn't really agree with this idea initially, but the argument was persuasive. Certainly I don't think any of them have the kind of monopoly that AT&T had, but Facebook might be close as they continue sinking their Facebook Connect hooks in.
The trouble is that monopolies are not good or bad per se. Google and Facebook are still mostly innovating and adding value. At some point the landscape starts to change, and that's when they get scared and start getting anti-competitive and the balances start to tip.
The tricky thing is determining when this is. Certainly the government is ill-equipped to figure it out, because it's all sound bites and popular opinion by an apathetic voter base. So the rationale for why a monopoly should be broken up gets sanded down to a slogan about monopolies being bad, and pretty soon politicians are jumping on the monopoly-busting bandwagon without any kind of legitimate rationale.
This is why, I really value the old-school intellectual movement that Chomsky represents of standing outside and speaking truth to power. Even if a lot of his analysis is flawed and ideas ultimately wrong, the honesty with which he pursues them is admirable and we need many more like him to keep America honest. The rich won't do it (as a group they are too fearful), the powerful won't do it, and government is certainly too awash in lobbyists and bureaucracy to have any hope.