5 ms·
It's worth noting that this blog post appeared less than 24 hours after BuzzFeed News posted an article explicitly highlighting the conspiracy theories in the r
by minimaxir 8y ago
It's worth noting that this blog post appeared less than 24 hours after BuzzFeed News posted an article explicitly highlighting the conspiracy theories in the recommended section: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-youtubes-recommendation-rabbithole https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-y...
I helped contribute to that article, feel free to ask any questions!
- luvjournalists 8y agoI noticed that you started the article by transferring guilt from an crude, anonymous Youtube comment about illegal immigrants, to a video posted by a think tank which was designated as a "hate group" by a private organization based on vague criteria, to a fickle recommendation algorithm which picked a valid (related content, just from a different angle) video, to Youtube and Google the company. I also noticed that every one of the "bad recommendations" you picked out in your article falls on one side of the political spectrum. My question is: when you cause a $1T monopoly with unprecedented control over the world's information to enhance its censorship algorithms with a news article, what motivates you? Is it just the feeling of power? Do you recognize that you have a particular viewpoint or philosophy that you're trying to protect? Or do you believe that you're only seeking the truth, that you're right, and everyone else is wrong? edit: forgot another possible motivation: getting paid to do it, raised whole life to do it, don't care any further than that. (I'm not just trying to impugn, I literally have no idea what goes through journalists heads when they write articles like this)
- webwanderings 8y agoHave you investigated their rabbit hole for children? YT for Kids simply needs to die. They are evil.
- claudiulodro 8y agoAgreed! What I have found is that most legitimate popular YT kids content (Blippi, Pinkfong, etc.) is also available repackaged and included in Amazon Prime. I've been using that for most kids content instead, as it's not just sponsored toy unboxing crap and I don't need to worry about weird auto-playing recommendations or commercials.
- minimaxir 8y agoElsagate videos would be a good next step; I suppose they wouldn't be covered by YT's announcement.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoTangent: I'm expecting a kid, and time will come in couple years, when I'll want to show them kid videos. I fully intend to set this up as streaming from a library curated by my wife & me, populated with youtube-dl and through other means. I know some people on HN have such setups; could you share recommendations for hardware and software stack? I suspect a Raspberry Pi may not be enough (having network and USB sharing capacity), especially if we want to simultaneously stream movies for ourselves. But I also don't want to turn it into some $1k+ server build, the way they do on /r/plex and elsewhere. Could anyone recommend a "compromise" setup, that would allow to comfortably stream HD videos to 2-3 devices simultaneously?
- reaperducer 8y agoIf you're in the United States, 90% of the population can receive the 24/7 PBS Kids channel over the air for free. If you're worried about the quality of content from YouTube, or the chances that someone gaming the system dumps questionable content into your stream, it's worth spending ten bucks on an antenna. It's also good for supplementing your child's YouTube viewing when YT starts showing the same stuff over and over.
- checkyoursudo 8y agoThe PBS kids website has a lot on it as well, all ad-free. Also PBS kids apps, ad-free as well.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoNot in the US; unfortunately, I don't think Poland has a dedicated government channel for kids. Still, I want to make it video-on-demand, but with content fully curated by us - to avoid age-inappropriate content, ads and recommendations. There's no way I'm going to let my kid touch raw YouTube in the next decade.
- rasz 8y agoWe do, tv-trwam.pl
- gundmc 8y agoHave you used YouTube Kids in the last ~6 months? They made a lot of changes and enabled a mode where only human-vetted videos from topics/creators you select can play. I don't have kids but had assumed that problem was largely addressed.
- webwanderings 8y agoNo it has not. An average person wouldn’t have time to tweak the unknown changes thrown by unknown developers at them for their kids viewing experience. Nobody should trust the YT for kids because their primary motivation is not kids safety or education. When my daughter uses PBS Kids or Khan Academy Kids, I don’t have to worry about what they are throwing at her (relatively). YT on the other hand is a pure disaster waiting to happen to parents, if they don’t know (I was in that boat for some time).
- switch007 8y agoIf the government labelled BuzzFeed a designated hate organization, would you still want YouTube to show your videos?
- JaimeThompson 8y agoHow does one report videos to Youtube that violate their policies and actually get them to do something about it. It appears one can talk about the Holocaust not being real / that people don't get killed in mass shootings in the United States all they want and keep their monitization / Superchats.
- minimaxir 8y agoUnfortunately, that's all you can do. The real remedy is shining sunlight on the policy violations, which is why the journalism is so important.
- jstanley 8y agoWhat's the problem with videos like you mentioned? Do you think all videos in which people are wrong about things should be taken down? If somebody writes on their blog that they don't think the holocaust is real, should their blog get taken down, or is there something different about it being a video? In my opinion, YouTube has gone much too far towards the side of taking down videos rather than leaving them up. We don't need to be calling for them to be even more strict with removing videos that people don't like. If you don't like it, you don't have to watch it. If your goal in taking down conspiracy theory videos is to kill the conspiracy theory, I think that may actually be counterproductive. If the video stays up and everyone laughs about how stupid it is, nothing bad happens. If the video gets taken down then it just provides them an opportunity to shout about how they're trying to spread the truth but they're being silenced by the establishment.
- JaimeThompson 8y agoI think that videos that say kids didn't die in school shootings should not be allowed to make money off of said videos especially when they try to get people riled up to harass the survivors and their parents. Furthermore I expect Google to apply their policies evenly which they don't. If violations of Google ToS are reported they should be taken care of don't you think. It isn't like you can actually debate them on their channels either as they delete comments that don't support them the vast majority of time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gwern 8y agoI see the Sinicization of US technology & media continues apace, and we're now thoroughly into the "encourage virtue, chastise vice" phase.
- maxerickson 8y agoSo when did you guys first notice twitter screaming about it? For me, at least right around the 2016 election...