3 ms·
> To be more concrete: > - Locale.Builder, Java 7, introduced in Android 21 > - java.lang.invoke package, Java 7, introduced in Android 26 > - java.nio.file
by wtallis 8y ago
> To be more concrete:
> - Locale.Builder, Java 7, introduced in Android 21
> - java.lang.invoke package, Java 7, introduced in Android 26
> - java.nio.file package, Java 7, introduced in Android 26
Should the legal status of Android really depend in any way on whether or not it is done? Is there any practical way to define public policy that allows a work-in-progress reimplementation for competitive purposes but prohibits an incomplete reimplementation that you don't intend to flesh out to 100% compatibility?
- pjmlp 8y agoYes, Google Android J++ should be slammed 100% the same way as Microsoft one was. Google has created a fork in the Java community.
- wtallis 8y agoCan you please try to address the distinction between work in progress vs. not even trying for 100% compatibility? Are you saying that neither should be legal, but a complete and 100% compatible reimplementation should? Or are you saying that reimplementations should not be legal regardless of how complete and compatible they are?
- pjmlp 8y agoI am saying that Google has done exactly the same to the Java community as Microsoft did with J++ and should suffer the same outcome in court as Microsoft did. It was wrong for Microsoft, it is just as wrong for Google. Implement whatever Android specific APIs they feel like, but just like ISO C or ISO C++, don't fork the Java standard library.
- wtallis 8y ago> I am saying that Google has done exactly the same to the Java community as Microsoft did with J++ and should suffer the same outcome in court as Microsoft did. As far as I can tell, Sun sued Microsoft for trademark infringement, and Microsoft settled. Which part of that applies to Google? It really seems that you've decided you want Google to lose regardless of the legal basis used by Oracle. Whereas I think Google should win because of the legal basis Oracle is attempting to use. I don't actually care whether Google ends up having to pay Oracle some money; I just don't want the entire legal foundations of the software industry to be retconned by this case.
- pjmlp 8y agoSun sued Microsoft for changes to the Java platform, making it not compliant with the trademark. I want Google to loose because they succeed where Microsoft failed, forking Java eco-system, and having a bunch of people that call Microsoft the evil empire, actually supportive of Google's actions.
- curt15 8y agoBut forking has always been a fact of life in software. E.g. MariaDB vs mysql
- pjmlp 8y agoNot for industry standards, try to handle interoperability and code portability with forks. MariaDB vs mysql fork doesn't matter as long as they execute the same SQL, which isn't in the case in standard Java vs Android Java.
- monocasa 8y agoWhere's the standard for Java?
- pjmlp 8y agoHere, under specifications. https://docs.oracle.com/en/java/javase/11/ https://docs.oracle.com/en/java/javase/11/
- monocasa 8y agoThat's not an "industry standard", that's just autogenned API docs. Contrast to C# which is an ISO and an ECMA standard.
- pjmlp 8y agoIt is a de facto standard, ever heard of those? C# ECMA standard is not updated since version 5. Just like Sun/Oracle, MSDN and the .NET Foundation are now the official source for .NET languages references. Better inform yourself when trying to pass around Google's PR messages.
- monocasa 8y agoA de facto standard is something that a community iterates on together. S-100, early iSCSI, etc. One company publishing specs and suing competing implementations is not a "de facto standard".