3 ms·
Before people celebrate, remember that Google's arguments are negotiations via the legal system, not a battle-to-the-death over principle. If Oracle offers Goo
by gojomo 16y ago
Before people celebrate, remember that Google's arguments are negotiations via the legal system, not a battle-to-the-death over principle.
If Oracle offers Google and its ecosystem a reasonable deal, in which Google publicly acknowledges that Oracle's patents are valid, the matter will be resolved -- and Oracle's patents will be stronger than ever, presumptively, because they were legally tested by a dispute with a deep-pocketed adversary who eventually agreed to license them.
Compare also: when first sued by the Author's Guild in a class action over book-scanning, Google originally argued they had a fair-use right to scan/index the books without prior permission. When a settlement deal favorable to Google's continued operations was proffered, Google stopped fighting for the general fair use principle, and instead has been defending the benefits of their settlement agreement. [1] What should others who want to scan/index books do? Now, Google suggests they should get explicit permission beforehand, using the precedents Google set. [2]
I don't blame Google for making necessary practical legal compromises for their mission, but I also don't put them up on a pedestal, as if they were a disinterested champion who will establish equal rights for everyone. They'll pursue their organizational interests, as with any other ambitious organization.
[1] http://www.publicknowledge.org/node/1828 http://www.publicknowledge.org/node/1828
[2] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/09/opinion/09brin.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/09/opinion/09brin.html?pagewa...
"If Google Books is successful, others will follow. And they will have an easier path: this agreement creates a books rights registry that will encourage rights holders to come forward and will provide a convenient way for other projects to obtain permissions. While new projects will not immediately have the same rights to orphan works, the agreement will be a beacon of compromise in case of a similar lawsuit, and it will serve as a precedent for orphan works legislation, which Google has always supported and will continue to support."
- jbooth 16y agoIn general, I'm inclined to agree with you, certainly with any other company, and probably with Google.. But Page and Brin probably have the muscle to make a bad business decision and fight out the patent if they think they can win, and it's far reaching enough that they might go for it.
- steadicat 16y agoCount on Google to fight the good fight! Like they did when they gave up Net Neutrality to make a deal with Verizon.
- redthrowaway 16y agoPlaying devil's advocate here, but their deal would secure net neutrality - for broadband. It's only mobile that gets fucked over. Now, anyone can see that mobile is the future, so this isn't much to hang your hat on, but it is something.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoYou're probably right, but let's see, it's not necessarily a rational self interest versus altruistic community spirit kind of question. In the case of book scanning, Google didn't have any other way to scan books. But in the case of Android, the cost of buying off Oracle and the cost of replacing the Android app runtime with V8 or Go have to be weighed against each other. There's also the open question of the Android/Chrome OS duality. If Java becomes too expensive for them, they might just resolve this issue with a unified Google OS that doesn't use Java at all.
- metageek 16y ago>they might just resolve this issue with a unified Google OS that doesn't use Java at all. I don't think that would be feasible. That would mean deserting all their Android developers, telling them that their investment in Android skills is now worthless. Nobody would develop for Google's replacement OS.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoI also think it is unlikely but if Oracle wins outright and demands excessive royalties Google might be able to justify the move. And it's not exactly rendering all skills worthless if you're forced to use the very same API from JavaScript or Go instead of Java. I would think it is much more likely that they would use V8 since it is already on every Android device and everyone already knows JavaScript.