3 ms·
As the article itself points out, the Chinese media is full of stories about Chinese people being targets of scams by food producers, eCommerce companies sellin
by onion2k 8y ago
As the article itself points out, the Chinese media is full of stories about Chinese people being targets of scams by food producers, eCommerce companies selling fakes, and scams by one another (dating scams and so on). These social-credit surveillance programs have been marketed to the people they're aimed at as a benefit that protects them from potential crime. It's the same everywhere - here in the UK we have the most CCTV cameras per capita than anywhere else in the world and they're always talked about by the government and the police as tools for "protecting the people from crime." TV documentaries about the police feature them 'following' criminals around town centres using CCTV. It's impressive. It works. The fact the cameras also gather data about everyone else who isn't a criminal is never mentioned.
People respond well to things that make them feel safer, regardless of whether they're actually safer, so privacy-invading surveillance technology is marketed as a something that does just that. The actual reason why governments want it, in order to keep the people in check, isn't good PR.
In the case of China, they've had decades of government PR telling the people to be fearful, and at the same time selling them the thing that means they can stop being fearful. It's not surprising the people like it.
- nerbert 8y agoIn normal countries you have a strong civil society & consumer associations that have the teeth to bite these scammers.
- ekianjo 8y agoAnd more importantly, strong entrepreneurship so you have many companies offering similar products, so that you can decide to "punish" with your wallet the companies that deceive you. It goes hand in hand.
- taurath 8y agoThat works for sugar water companies but private security not so much, unless you have a very very large wallet.
- ves 8y ago“normal” might be a strong word when the society in question is the largest single one on the planet. That’s not to say I agree with, or want to normalize, the Chinese government’s actions, though.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoWhere are these "normal" countries? The kind of scams GP mentions are rife here in the UK and from what I hear the story is the same pretty much everywhere.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYou can drink your milk in relative safety.
- netsharc 8y agoI won't agree with the "normal countries", but I wonder at what point does a society become uncivil? Obviously in a tribal village in the past you know who lived in the hut next door and it was like a big family who trusted each other (food was shared, mothers would take care of each others' kids). Maybe it's related to the Dunbar number?
- agent008t 8y agoFrom an outside perspective, Japan still seems extremely civil despite being very densely populated. I have never felt safer anywhere else as a visitor. I suspect a near-ubiquitous level of high homogeneous culture is a big factor.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- umanwizard 8y agoIf by "normal" you mean a society with highly developed rule of law, institutional maturity, low corruption, etc., then I think you are talking about a small minority of countries.
- ajdlinux 8y ago> People respond well to things that make them feel safer, regardless of whether they're actually safer So as privacy advocates, what do we say if we see a highly intrusive surveillance system that does make people actually safer? It's entirely possible that a highly intrusive surveillance system could well be extremely effective in combatting crime - and I mean the "universally-agreed" crimes, not political crimes - as well as providing spying capabilities to keep the population in check. Now I don't know what impact Social Credit has on crime rates, but it's not self-evidently a stupid idea in that regard.
- neuronic 8y agoThis is a difficult question because it boils down to whether we generally prefer safety over freedom. Privacy is just one pillar of freedom, albeit a load-bearing one. Freedom will crumble if we strike down this pillar and as a society - or even as Western hemisphere - we have to evaluate if safety from (state-defined) crime ends up being worth near-zero privacy. If I were to judge by some interviews I recently saw on "extra3", a comedic German television format [1], I increasingly fear that democracy, freedom and liberalism are doomed. Context: People at a meat convention (yes...) were asked about their opinions on climate change and animal farming. Boomer-aged visitors and young visitors alike not only showed complete lack of understanding of ANY issue associated with large-scale animal husbandry. But they turned questions on their head and answered in a sort of stupid and ignorant way I could have never imagined in my wildest dreams. One example: "What do you think about animal suffering in mass animal husbandry?" Answer, paraphrased, completely serious in tone: "Nothing, the humans here at this convention are also visiting in masses and obviously nobody suffers. They are all enjoying themselves, look around." A question about CO2-impact of animal farming brought another response forward, that had me baffled: "There is no problem here, we have been eating meat for thousands of years and now suddenly it's supposed to be wrong. The climate didn't change over the millennia either!" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extra_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extra_3
- threatofrain 8y agoPeople are looking for the right language to do what they want with dignity, but the specifics of the language and its content aren't of interest.
- mmsimanga 8y agoAs someone who lived under a dictatorship I would argue that China and UK aren't the same thing. It sounds the same but it isn't. Smart dictators never break any laws. A clamp down on protestors is always described as protecting law abiding citizens from rowdy protestors. I bet if someone did text analysis of report written by police from democratic country Vs dictatorship who both had to break up a riot the language would be the same. The only difference would be the number of dead people. It's common for dictators to "remind" people of their power by killing a few.
- agent008t 8y agoThe same capabilities that allow you to prevent crime are also always the same capabilities that allow you to prevent other kinds of unwanted behavior. In the end, the solution is a high level of culture in a society. A level of culture that would mean crime is naturally low (it seems to differ a lot between cultures) and that enables trust in institutions designed to control the powers that can use force, e.g. law enforcement and secret services.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]