3 ms·
I'm a bit confused about why Congress made appellate jurisdiction with CAFC work they way it does with patent cases. The usual justification for giving courts
by tzs 8y ago
I'm a bit confused about why Congress made appellate jurisdiction with CAFC work they way it does with patent cases.
The usual justification for giving courts supplemental or pendant jurisdiction over subjects for which they normally lack subject matter jurisdiction when a case involves both something they do have subject matter jurisdiction over and something they do not is that there they will usually be arising out of the same facts and involve the same witnesses.
If they were heard in separate courts, many witnesses would have to appear to both and that could be a hardship on them.
For appellate cases there aren't witnesses. It's just the lawyers arguing from the record from the trial court.
If the original case involved both patent infringement and something else, the patent aspects of the appeal are going to be handled by patent specialists, and the other aspects are likely to be handled by different lawyers.
Thus, I don't see why the appeals should be bundled together and all sent to CAFC. Why not send the patent appeals to CAFC, and the appeals for other aspects to the ordinary appellate court they would have went to if there weren't also patent appeals?
Furthermore, in the Google vs. Oracle case the second trial was just on the issue of copyright fair use, wasn't it? Apparently even though the trial court there was just dealing with copyright, because the original action why back at the beginning had a patent claim, it goes to CAFC even though there is now nothing involved that they normally handle.
If we are going to have this screwy appeals path, how about allowing CAFC decisions on matters that are normally out of their jurisdiction, such as copyright, to be appealed to the regular Circuit Court of Appeals they would have normally gone to? CAFC is supposed to follow the regular Circuit Court of Appeals for precedent on such matters, so it seems crazy that the appeals path does not go through that court. As a general principle, if court X is supposed to follow court Y's precedent for something, court Y should be in the appeals path of court X.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I'm a bit confused about why Congress made appellate jurisdiction with CAFC work they way it does with patent cases. Economy of justice; otherwise, an appeal of a mixed case would often actually be two separate appeals to separate circuits, each of which would often make some legal decision and remand to the trial court, which would potentially have to wait for both appellate decisions before proceeding, especially if either required a new trial, since those new trials would have overlapping witnesses, etc.