4 ms·
They only got that ruling by appealing a copyright question to the patent appeals court, who for some reason decided to just go off into the weeds and set their
by monocasa 8y ago
They only got that ruling by appealing a copyright question to the patent appeals court, who for some reason decided to just go off into the weeds and set their own precedent in open conflict with the appeals court these questions would normally go to.
That's why all the rulings keep getting overruled. The lower court judge is sane (he's actually awesome, you should check out Alsup) and keeps ruling in accordance with established case law, and the appeals court (who shouldn't even be answering copyright questions) keeps going 'nah, all that case law is stupid'.
Hence why this should go to the supreme court who'll most likely tell the court of appeals for the federal circuit that they can't just go make their own law.
- kadendogthing 8y ago>They only got that ruling by appealing a copyright question to the patent appeals court, Read the original ruling.
- monocasa 8y agoI've read all the rulings, what's your actual point?
- kadendogthing 8y ago>They only got that ruling by appealing a copyright question to the patent appeals court, That's not true and doesn't really fit within any legal timeline. That's my point.
- ilovetux 8y agoI believe that they are asking why do you believe that's not true. Your assertions are vague and do not help the discussion.
- kadendogthing 8y agoIt's not true that they won the legality of the case through an appeal. The original ruling sided with oracle on technical and legal matters. They just weren't awarded damages.
- geofft 8y agoBy "the original ruling" are you referring to https://www.eff.org/files/alsup_api_ruling.pdf https://www.eff.org/files/alsup_api_ruling.pdf , which says, "on the specific facts of this case, the particular elements replicated by Google were free for all to use under the Copyright Act. Therefore, Oracle’s claim based on Google’s copying of the 37 API packages, including their structure, sequence and organization is DISMISSED. To the extent stated herein, Google’s Rule 50 motions regarding copyrightability are GRANTED"? Can you point to what part of this ruling sided with Oracle on either technical or legal matters? (With the exception of rangeCheck.) Or can you link to what ruling you mean by "the original ruling"?