9 ms·
Ok, so the reason we have arbitration at all is to save the courts time. This makes sense. This seems like such an easy problem to solve too. Just don't let t
by jedberg 8y ago
Ok, so the reason we have arbitration at all is to save the courts time. This makes sense.
This seems like such an easy problem to solve too. Just don't let the company or the worker pick the arbitrator. Require by law that the arbitrator be picked by a judge, or be randomly assigned by the court system, who has presumably vetted the arbitrator.
The main problem with these things is that the arbitrator is picked by the company, so they have a strong incentive to favor the company. Arbitration wouldn't be so bad if the inherent bias is removed.
- dcosson 8y agoAren't there already systems in place within the legal system to allow this? Like small claims court or appealing a parking ticket, where you present the case to one judge and they decide rather than holding a full trial before a jury. I don't see why relying on one arbiter saves any more time than relying on one judge. Is it that the arbiter would be less qualified/lower paid than a judge?
- jedberg 8y agoIt's basically small claims court except with possibly less qualified people and for larger amounts of money. Small claims is like that specifically because it is a small amount of money.
- alistairSH 8y agoSmall claims is capped at very small values. $5000 in VA. $5000 (corporation) or $10000 (individual) in CA. Too low for sexual harassment or other career-impacting transgressions by an employer.
- maxlybbert 8y agoTo be legal, arbitration must be fair and protect the legal rights of both parties (although enforcing that requirement is obviously difficult). But arbitration doesn’t have to be as formal as a regular court, and that informality is supposed to save a lot of money, so US law actually prefers arbitration when it’s an option.
- hopler 8y agoYes. For example to NLRB and CFPB and the FTC and the EPA and every other agency the curtains us govt is trying to kill.
- learc83 8y agoThe problem is that companies favor arbitration because arbitration tends to favor companies. If arbitration were truly neutral, and it were easy to access with low costs to the consumer, companies would stop using them. So even if companies don't pick the arbitrator, arbitrators still have an incentive to find in favor of companies. Additionally, small claims court already basically works like what you're describing, no jury just one arbitrator not picked by either side--the judge.
- jedberg 8y ago> The problem is that companies favor arbitration because arbitration tends to favor companies. That's only because they are paid by the companies (and picked by the companies). If the companies didn't pick and the payment came out of the disputed amount or the loser paid, then they wouldn't have an incentive to favor the company.
- learc83 8y agoI think you may have missed the rest of my comment.
- jbottoms 8y agoAn article in Harvard Negotiation Law Review points out that courts can order arbitration if both parties agree to it, but cannot control the mechanisms of the arbitration. Therefore, if the company is paying any portion of the arbitrator's fee and the company is not leading in the process, they can elect to not pay the arbitrator's fee. In which case the arbitration fails and the case is dismissed. It appears to be in the plaintiff's interest to prefer mediation over arbitration. In essence, arbitration is broken.
- arethuza 8y agoThink about it from the arbitrator's point of view - who are they going to get repeat business from?
- munchbunny 8y ago
- siruncledrew 8y agoIANAL, but why not just have a special labor court with more judges to be the nonbiased arbitrators? Or use retired judges to be like “independent contractor” arbitrators as a special division of the courts? (I’m also not sure what the requirements to be an arbitrator are so please correct me).
- koolba 8y ago> (I’m also not sure what the requirements to be an arbitrator are so please correct me). It most cases the only requirement is a pulse. There’s usually no mandatory legal or industry training.
- cookiecaper 8y agoWhile true, arbitration is a popular side gig for retired judges: https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/events/labor_law/2013/02/adr_in_labor_employmentlawcommitteemidwintermeeting/z.pdf https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/events/labor_law... [PDF]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- martin_a 8y agoThis is what we have in Germany. It's called "Arbeitsgericht" ("labor court" basically) and as an employee you can go there and sue your employer. For employees this is free in the first instance and you will have a neutral judge to rule about the situation. I think you don't even need a lawyer as an employee but just "file a case" with the court, but I'm not totally sure about that. Anyway, it's a very important part of the system in Germany, those courts keep a lot of cases with work-related topics away from the "normal" courts while still providing a neutral platform for both parties.
- daddylonglegs 8y agoIn England and Wales there are Employment Tribunals. These are run by a government appointed judges in an informal manner that should let people represent themselves. They include a conciliation service. There are time limits on when a claim can be made and - if monetary compensation is ordered - how much can be paid out [1][2]. https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/work/problems-at-work/employment-tribunals/understanding-employment-tribunals/ https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/work/problems-at-work/empl... In 2012 the government imposed a £1200 (from memory) fee for taking a case to tribunal. So a low wage employee without union representation who was harassed out of a job or unfairly dismissed would have to: File a complaint while looking for a new job. Pay the fees during or after a period of involuntary unemployment. Prepare their case while working their new job. Arrange time off for themselves (and witnesses) and pay for transport to the hearing(s). Make their case. Possibly receive compensation totalling a few thousand pounds. Claims dropped a lot and it was five years before the Supreme Court told the government to knock it off. It's rough (and precarious) at the bottom. There have also been large cut backs in legal aid for dealing with the "proper" courts (and not just for civil cases[3]). [1] The tribunal can also order an unfair employer to give the employee their job back or change their employment conditions. [2] I think there are differences for cases involving some forms of discrimination. [3] https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/law/nigel-evans-rues-backing-for-legal-aid-cuts/5040864.fullarticle https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/law/nigel-evans-rues-backing-fo... Edit: formatting.
- Spooky23 8y agoExactly. Funny when unions go to arbritration, it’s always a big todo.p and terrible thing.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y ago> Just don't let the company or the worker pick the arbitrator. That's already the case. If the company and the worker can't agree on an arbitrator, they each pick one, and then the two get together and agree on a third arbitrator to use. Or a judge will pick one. The employee is not required to accept whatever arbitrator a company picks.
- ldiracdelta 8y agoHow about we reduce the court load by instituting loser-pays tort reform.
- kyrieeschaton 8y agoThis effectively makes it impossible for a small plaintiff (or defendant!) to justify the risk of fighting anyone with a multi million dollar legal team at their disposal.
- ldiracdelta 8y agoIf the case is likely to win, then a lawyer or investor will pony up his own cash for a cut of the outcome. This means that only cases that people feel are overwhelming will be litigated. Marginal cases to bleed your enemy dry do not work, because they work against you.
- harimau777 8y agoIsn't that a bad thing since likely to win doesn't map directly to being right? For example, even if I was seriously wronged, my opponent could have access to greater legal resources, or my position could be socially unpopular, or the situation could be difficult to prove, etc.
- CaptainZapp 8y agothen a lawyer or investor will pony up his own cash for a cut of the outcome. This is outright illegal in countries where lawyers are not allowed to work on contingency and may get a lawyer barred.
- jsmith99 8y agoIn the UK, claimants using a 'no win no fee' deal usually buy After The Event insurance to protect them against having to pay the other sides' costs.
- arethuza 8y agoCertainly litigation in the UK can be very difficult to stop once started as if either side gives up there is a good chance they will be expected to pay the other sides fees up to that point.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- temp231239 8y agofrom what I understand, arbitration is a way to come up with a resolution if possible before taking case to court. If arbitrator decision doesn't seem just to employee then why don't they appeal for court? Who own the cost of court proceedings in such scenario, company or employee? But given the exorbitant legal fees its not is favor of employee to take this route.
- jonstewart 8y agoBecause you signed a contract to abide by the outcome of the arbitration proceedings (i.e., it's "binding"). If you appeal, the judge will toss it out and you'll have wasted your money.
- puszczyk 8y agoThis is not really obvious if you’re not from the US. In Poland (and I guess other continental Europe countries) you can appeal to a regular court. The possibility to appeal to court is considered one of the basic rights one has.
- zuppy 8y agothat should be illegal, it should be impossible to waive a basic right. this will affect poorer people much more, as they have less experience, money to invest into a good lawyer and job options. it's not a fair process.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoCourts exits to protect citizen rights and, ultimately, protect democracy. Creating ways to circumvent the legal system (e.g. plea bargains, private arbitration and so on) is rarely done in good faith. No law of physics prevents the creation of a cheap, equitable and efficient legal system.
- CogitoCogito 8y ago> Ok, so the reason we have arbitration at all is to save the courts time. This makes sense. Honestly I think it does _not_ make sense. If courts are too overloaded, then we need more courts or we need to change the laws/processes that overload them. > This seems like such an easy problem to solve too. Just don't let the company or the worker pick the arbitrator. Require by law that the arbitrator be picked by a judge, or be randomly assigned by the court system, who has presumably vetted the arbitrator. > The main problem with these things is that the arbitrator is picked by the company, so they have a strong incentive to favor the company. Arbitration wouldn't be so bad if the inherent bias is removed. I think these are good ideas, but I think there's another very big one to consider: why should anyone be allowed to choose arbitration before the dispute at hand arises? I simply think it should be disallowed. I always here people supporting arbitration say stuff like "it's better for both parties", but if that's actually the case then both parties would choose the arbitration at the time of the dispute. Allowing people to tie themselves to arbitration ahead of time entirely removes the incentive to actually provide a fairer and better process to both sides.
- pc86 8y agoI agree with you on all counts, but just to play devil's advocate if you had to mutually agree to arbitration after a dispute arises, odds are likely in bitter disputes one side will refuse only to cost the other side more money in legal fees. I don't think that's enough of a reason to disagree with your point but it's certainly one to consider, especially if one side has a lot more resources and jurisdictionally each side will need to pay their own legal fees.
- CogitoCogito 8y ago> I agree with you on all counts, but just to play devil's advocate if you had to mutually agree to arbitration after a dispute arises, odds are likely in bitter disputes one side will refuse only to cost the other side more money in legal fees. Honestly I think that you shouldn't have any inherent right to arbitration. You should have a right to access to a court. Arbitration should only there if both parties agree to it. If one party doesn't agree because they want to make it more expensive for you, so be it. I mean I can't really see what's fundamentally different than someone deciding they want to force you to a court trial for that reason versus them forcing you for another reason. It's just a legal strategy at the end of the day. If they are truly acting in bad will, they should be assessed court fees down the road. I know that that's difficult in the US court system, but that is a problem that should be fixed with the court system not by just side-stepping it with arbitration.
- tboyd47 8y agoAmerican court decisions are strongly based on precedent. If these contests were to move through the court system naturally for a few years, don't you think that over time the volume of work would diminish as each decision became precedent for the next?