6 ms·
As someone who also reads a lot of fiction, I think this fic is in great need of a good editor... but that after the normal publication process it would be as g
by Symmetry 16y ago
As someone who also reads a lot of fiction, I think this fic is in great need of a good editor... but that after the normal publication process it would be as good as anything Asimov or Heinlein wrote.
- mdemare 16y agoSadly, because it is fan fiction, it will never be published.
- Eliezer 16y agoBut because it's fan fiction, I wouldn't object if, after the story finishes, someone produced their own edit of it.
- swombat 16y agoOh wow, there you are. I just wanted to say that I absolutely love this series of Harry Potter stories. Awesome. Brilliant. Genius. This is as someone who does read a lot as well. It's really, really, really excellent. It's the only mostly static website on the web which I go and manually check every couple of days, excited at the thought that maybe there's a new chapter up. It's like having a child's Christmas every few days. I love it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
- Eliezer 16y ago"Thanks," he said in the small, awkward voice of someone who'd never quite figured out how to take a compliment like that gracefully.
- Alex3917 16y agoIt strikes me as slightly ironic that this book is so popular here. After all, it's in praise of rationality, whereas HN is a community of entrepreneurs; A profession where the odds against you are so great that you almost couldn't get out of bed in the morning without delusions of grandeur, or at least a healthy dose of narcissism.
- Eliezer 16y agoRight, and the main character of this story never faces heavy odds, nor tries to do anything ambitious, and nobody in his universe ever accused him of having delusions of grandeur... I gotta ask here, have you read up to Chapter 5?
- Alex3917 16y agoNope, didn't read it. I didn't realize the book touched on this, though it wasn't meant as a criticism of the book (or HN) anyway.
- pjscott 16y agoI hope I'm not raining on your Christmas, but if you register at FanFiction.net, you can subscribe to get an email whenever a new chapter is posted. That way you find out about new chapters quickly, and you don't have to check manually. That's what I do, anyway. There's also an unofficial RSS feed: http://demented.no-ip.org/~feep/rss_proxy.cgi?5782108 http://demented.no-ip.org/~feep/rss_proxy.cgi?5782108
- swombat 16y agoOh, I know about the RSS feed, I just prefer it this way. :-)
- stcredzero 16y agoHighly irrational, but I understand and approve!
- pjscott 16y agoWhat's rational depends entirely on what you want. For someone who enjoys the excitement of periodically checking FanFiction.net to see if HP:MoR has been updated, it's a deliciously rational thing to do.
- inklesspen 16y agoI actually built a feed-builder: http://ffnetupdates.inklesspen.com/ http://ffnetupdates.inklesspen.com/ Sign up (no email or password, just a UUID), track as many authors or stories as you like in one Atom feed. It will let you know when wordcount changes even if there's no new chapter, or when your favorite author has a new story.
- araneae 16y agoAhem. You don't happen have that .tex template hanging around that was used to produce the .pdf? Because it's absolutely beautiful and I would like to co-opt the template for my NaNoWriMo novel :D.
- Eliezer 16y agoThat would be Bogdan Butnaru's work. Email me and I'll forward your email to him.
- mattmanser 16y agoHave you read Asimov recently? In the cold light of adulthood it is unfortunately not as good as my inner child remembers. Nowhere near as bad as Rowling, who is an awful writer, but still pretty bad. To be fair to Rowling her first book actually introduced some good ideas, the rest were pretty much universally crap. Some of Asimov's themes and ideas are also feeling very dated now too, he seemed to be heavily influenced by the US/Russia situation and early electronics and those inspirations have not stood the test of time. A visionary in his time and for a generation afterwards, but I'm starting to doubt he'll be much read in 10 or 20 years time.
- araneae 16y agoHis writing is pretty bad in the original Foundation trilogy, but it was his early work. He got a lot better later on. Have you read Stephen King's first novel, Carrie? The writing is awful. And yes, there are a lot of direct cold war references in something like Fantastic Voyage II that make it seem outdated, but I think that his really futuristic stuff doesn't have that flaw.
- MrJagil 16y ago@ araneae and mattmanser I really thought Hacker News was a more intellectual place, than to condone empty blanket statements like "their writing is crap". Please, if you are going to state something, especially in a thread regarding rationality, please back it up.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- cynicalkane 16y agoIf you're going to posture as an amateur writing critic, thinking about the social context of Asimov's writing, you probably shouldn't also condemn a writer loved by readers, writers, and critics as "pretty much universally crap". It's counter-cultural and pretentious yet very shallow, and so you lose a lot of credibility as a critic.
- gwern 16y ago