3 ms·
The isolationists of 1940 often travelled overseas, married immigrants, or sometimes even were immigrants themselves.
by philwelch 8y ago
The isolationists of 1940 often travelled overseas, married immigrants, or sometimes even were immigrants themselves.
- jessaustin 8y agoOh great, now I'm a Nazi sympathizer, and you're still using the wrong definition of "isolationist". I guess we're done here...
- philwelch 8y agoThe archetypal historical example of "isolationism" was American isolationism between the World Wars. And those people also called themselves "pacifists" and "non-interventionists" and "anti-war". I'm not saying you're a Nazi sympathizer, I'm saying your expressed opinions are indistinguishable from the views of people, some of whom history later came to judge as Nazi sympathizers. > I've paid attention to lots of awful things going on around the world for a few decades, and I've noticed that many of them can be traced back to USA Yeah, this is the kind of Noam Chomsky crap that makes you come across as "far-left", or "the kind of person who sympathizes with foreign dictatorships". My apologies.
- jessaustin 8y agoI told myself I was done, but you've committed a foul here. By cutting off the quote at 'USA' rather than including the full 'USA Wars On X, where X is "Communism" or "Terror" or "Drugs" or "Oil Pipelines" or whatever', you make it seem that I don't value this country and its citizens. What I don't value are the stupid wars those citizens are tricked into feeding with their sons and their taxes. Also, Noam Chomsky is twice the man and twice the American that anyone in this thread can claim to be. You don't know that, not because it isn't true, but because you are ignorant.
- philwelch 8y ago> ...you make it seem that I don't value this country and its citizens. What I don't value are the stupid wars those citizens are tricked into feeding with their sons and their taxes. This could have been an exact quote from a publication of the America First Committee in 1940. > Also, Noam Chomsky is twice the man and twice the American that anyone in this thread can claim to be. You don't know that, not because it isn't true, but because you are ignorant. Noam Chomsky is a genocide denier. That's a hard moral line to me. Sorry it isn't the same for you.
- jessaustin 8y agoYes, let's take it as read, all pacifists are actually secret Nazis. How do you know what you think you know about 1940, anyway? Lindbergh accepted a medal from Germany before the war, so that means he was culpable for Auschwitz? The same brave pilot who in his forties flew 50 combat missions and helped the Army Air Corps and Marines develop better tactics that shortened the war? Wait, you're not criticizing him for shortening the war, are you? Also, these fucking genocides. Yeah, they're terrible. (You're also completely misrepresenting what Chomsky said about Cambodia, another clusterfuck caused by CIA when they sponsored the coup in 1970, after NSA executed the Tonkin Gulf Deception in 1964 to destabilize the entire region in the first place.) I really thought it was a bad idea to kill half a million Iraqis. I don't care that you don't feel the same. There is nothing holy about a bunch of people who have nothing to do with America being killed by another bunch of people who have nothing to do with America. The problem is that USA keeps destabilizing legitimate governments in all parts of the globe, arming terrorists, and using the resulting chaos as justification for our own disastrous military operations. The problem is USA soldiers using USA munitions to kill people who have nothing to do with America. You are not well enough informed to make moral judgments about USA military activity. You should blame the popular news media for your ignorance.