4 ms·
And if she had visited reddit or HN or any one of numerous sites they would have repeated the meme that "no one knows what they're doing anyway, just fake it ti
by SilasX 8y ago
And if she had visited reddit or HN or any one of numerous sites they would have repeated the meme that "no one knows what they're doing anyway, just fake it till you make it", and she would have shrugged and kept on trucking.
- dmix 8y ago[citation needed] I'd love to see examples of this idea being promoted here. I personally remember Theranos being attacked on HN first for being full of shit, well before it became popular in the press. Not to mention the ~2yrs where 'lean' stuff that was endless parroted here which is all about not faking it but actually talking to customers. I also highly doubt any YC type company would fit that criteria either. Maybe you see that stuff on Reddit but HN is full of some of the most skeptical and critical people when it comes to reviewing startups.
- SilasX 8y agoThat's cheating though: "Hey, I already know your idea doesn't work, so obviously I don't endorse it." The problem is what to do when you personally don't know the viability of your own idea and have to take advice while not having access to the same knowledge. If you stripped off the specifics, in every other context, HNers would by-and-large repeat the tropes about "oh yeah, you feel like you don't know what you're doing, but so does everyone else! It doesn't matter!" Obviously, you can come after the fact and say "See, now that the idea failed and I expressed skepticism before, I obviously don't mean the fake-it-till-you-make-it crap for that startup, just the good ones." That's not impressive. What matters is whether you know whether self-confidence is justified being the person in that situation.
- kodablah 8y agoI don't believe this is true unless you are intentionally assuming all ventures are painted with the same brush. It's not true with self driving cars, med tech, or anything else having to do with human safety. Not only is there not one shared voice on these sites, even if you pretended there were it would not be in favor of faking it until you make it when human safety is involved. I think this subscribes to the more-frequent meme of assuming people apply their mindset on some types of tech business to all types of tech business.
- SilasX 8y agoI'm not talking about advice given about ventures' viability, but to the people running them, who, like Holmes, might say, "gee, I'm in way over my head, I don't feel like I know what I'm doing" and are consistently told that everyone feels that way so it doesn't matter.
- kodablah 8y agoYeah, about their little web service they are building. I don't think anyone, here or elsewhere much less the majority of them, would say that advice is globally applicable.