5 ms·
"Most people in the United States" haven't admitted to themselves that the overriding purpose of all popular news media is constantly, insidiously to advocate f
by jessaustin 8y ago
"Most people in the United States" haven't admitted to themselves that the overriding purpose of all popular news media is constantly, insidiously to advocate for more spending on armaments and war. Historically that would have been considered rightist, but in the current context one could be forgiven some confusion...
- pixl97 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent
- NorthOf33rd 8y agoSuch an important book (and movie.) In my other comment I discussed a class I was lucky enough to take in highschool where explored media bias. But, I bring it up again because I think it's so important that every single person understand that "media bias" isn't necessarily a bad or good thing, it's just reality. However, it is necessarily bad when collectively we do not recognize it. Everyone should go through a civics class at least once where learning about the reality of the media landscape, bias, and motivations are key topics along with lessons on how to responsibly engage.
- philwelch 8y agoI'm sure that's how it comes across to a far-left isolationist, just like the popular news media probably comes across as "insidiously advocating for greater globalization and surrendering American sovereignty" to a John Bircher, but that's probably because the commentators who say these things are extremists, not because the vaguely-centrist media has an appreciable agenda.
- neetdeth 8y agoThat's what it looks like to a "far-right" isolationist, too. If you hadn't noticed, Trump has been trying to extricate the US from conflict in Syria, with the media nearly unanimous in opposing this goal. US news media is in fact generally pro-war and pro-globalization, and these are appreciable agendas which are only deemed "centrist" because they are shared by the two major parties. Outlets like CNN closely reflect the consensus of the governing elite, even when it is quite markedly out of step with the prevailing opinion of the public on any given issue. Labeling positions which don't enjoy the endorsement of state-affiliated institutions as "extremist" is a common tactic to solidify control of the discourse. This comment reads to me as nothing more than naked worship of power.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Trump has been trying to extricate the US from conflict in Syria, with the media nearly unanimous in opposing this goal. The media, the left, and the remotely sane parts of the right are largely opposed to the specific mechanism; very few are opposed to the (purported) goal of extricating the US from the conflict in Syria.
- neetdeth 8y agoThe specific mechanism of withdrawing US forces from the area? I seem to recall a lot of hand-wringing from neocons about specific withdrawal strategies from Iraq, but the bottom line was that Americans would remain in Iraq. You can't say oh, I'd like to extricate myself from this conflict, but also force a specific outcome. That's having your cake and eating it.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The specific mechanism of withdrawing US forces from the area? The timing, manner, and surrounding supporting activity (or lack thereof) of that withdrawal, yes. > You can't say oh, I'd like to extricate myself from this conflict, but also force a specific outcome. Perhaps, but you absolutely can choose the manner in which you attempt to extricate yourself from a conflict with an eye toward the likely impacts of that extrication.
- neetdeth 8y agoWe could quite literally reparent your comment under a discussion about Iraq circa 2007 and it would not look out of place coming from a neoconservative. And no wonder -- those are the same people who now form the "remotely sane parts of the right," according to the so-called left. > The timing, manner, and surrounding supporting activity Presumably the timing is too soon, the supporting activity not vigorous enough, etc, etc. Let's kick the can down the road another year, surely our underspecified war aims will be closer to fruition.
- jessaustin 8y agoHaha "far-left" that's hilarious. I'll need to take the 2A bumper stickers off my pickup... "Isolationist" that's pretty good too. That must be why I lived and worked overseas for years and why I'm married to an immigrant. "Isolationist" has been redefined in USA (with the popular news media's help, of course) as "reluctant to drop bombs in other hemispheres". In every other place on Earth, it would mean something like "reluctant to do business or socialize with those from other nations". (Hint: we're the ones who have this wrong.) Really I'm just a pacifist. I've paid attention to lots of awful things going on around the world for a few decades, and I've noticed that many of them can be traced back to USA Wars On X, where X is "Communism" or "Terror" or "Drugs" or "Oil Pipelines" or whatever. Our nation continually commits and suffers myriad evils in order that armaments manufacturers may be further enriched. It would be difficult to respect anyone who isn't an "extremist", by the lights of the popular news media who support those evils.
- philwelch 8y agoThe isolationists of 1940 often travelled overseas, married immigrants, or sometimes even were immigrants themselves.
- jessaustin 8y agoOh great, now I'm a Nazi sympathizer, and you're still using the wrong definition of "isolationist". I guess we're done here...
- philwelch 8y agoThe archetypal historical example of "isolationism" was American isolationism between the World Wars. And those people also called themselves "pacifists" and "non-interventionists" and "anti-war". I'm not saying you're a Nazi sympathizer, I'm saying your expressed opinions are indistinguishable from the views of people, some of whom history later came to judge as Nazi sympathizers. > I've paid attention to lots of awful things going on around the world for a few decades, and I've noticed that many of them can be traced back to USA Yeah, this is the kind of Noam Chomsky crap that makes you come across as "far-left", or "the kind of person who sympathizes with foreign dictatorships". My apologies.