12 ms·
This is basically the sole "feature" of credit cards I value. Any time I'm buying something from somewhere that might act poorly, I use a credit card for the fr
by Waterluvian 8y ago
This is basically the sole "feature" of credit cards I value. Any time I'm buying something from somewhere that might act poorly, I use a credit card for the free leverage I have in a disagreement.
Had an old phones screen repaired at a store inside a Walmart. They fixed it but half the screen had no touch capability. They were highly resistant to doing anything about it until I said I would just do a charge back. Tone instantly changed.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI've started using privacy.com after I saw a post here on HN about it. It's pretty nice. Basically you link up your bank account and they create debit cards for any online vendors you use, and you can set limits, destroy cards etc. I usually put monthly / transactional limits. Like with Uber Eats I know I only spend x amount, if anybody tried to use my Uber Eats card for 100 USD it would decline it. But also it locks itself to the vendor you choose, so it can't be used elsewhere.
- Waterluvian 8y agoThat's an interesting idea. But I find a far easier solution is to turn on notifications. I get an email on my phone within a minute of every transaction. It's really nice having that feedback loop.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI have those on too! I saw the suggestion here, so I get: app notifications and emails. I also get notified if my balance gets too low. I used to want all that off, but email is a reasonable "paper trail" to know I'm not going crazy if I see an odd notification.
- e40 8y agoIt doesn't save the PITA that is getting your card stolen, though. With a virtual CC you don't have to do anything except close that card out (which you can on Citi's website, which is the version of this I use).
- loeg 8y agoI haven't found the occasional card replacement to be a pain, but I have two or more credit cards at any time.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoIt's not just being without, is updating all other services that are tied to your card. Now I personally don't let third parties store my cards, but it's quite common in this day and age of saas everything
- loeg 8y agoOh, that's true. I guess I just don't have that many 3rd party services regularly billing my credit card without prompting for a specific one to bill. I've only had to replace two credit cards over about 10 years, though.
- e40 8y agoI've been using this feature with my Citi CC for 10+ years. And with Citi, I don't need to give my CC to a 3rd party.
- stronglikedan 8y agoSame with BoA MC's ShopSafe feature.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoShopSafe works with BoA Visa cards too.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoNever tried that instead, might just try it, but I got have other banks that might not support this at all (Credit Union). That's where privacy.com works best for me.
- murph-almighty 8y agoSome credit card companies offer virtual credit cards as a service as well! Disclaimer: I work for one of those companies, but not on that product.
- howard941 8y agoI loved this feature when I had Amex. The unique number-vendor pairing makes it easier to track down the vendor that spilled the beans to the charge defrauder. I was thrilled when capone started offering a similar service but its offering requires a browser addon with a backend anal about matching domain names to merchant names and sometimes rejecting valid purchases (I'm looking at you Dell factory refurb outlet).
- cabalamat 8y ago> I've started using privacy.com Which is US only. Is there anything like it for the UK?
- Sahhaese 8y agoUK banks are already very good about refunding fraudulent transactions and associated fees: https://www.fca.org.uk/consumers/unauthorised-payments-account https://www.fca.org.uk/consumers/unauthorised-payments-accou... "In most cases the bank must refund the payment without undue delay and by the end of the business day following the day on which it became aware of the problem, unless it has reasonable grounds for suspecting that you have acted fraudulently." "When your bank refunds an unauthorised payment it must also refund any charges and interest you have paid because of the unauthorised transaction."
- kennethp 8y agoI would be very careful on this one. Some providers are interestingly stubborn when it comes to charge backs and can hold on to the (fraudulent) vendors side even if you're clearly right. Monzo in the UK is a prime example for that. An internet vendor charged me more than he should and refused to void the transaction (basically text-book fraud) and I filled for a charge back with monzo. I was extremely confident that it wouldn't take much however monzo customer service resisted to help. The monetary value wasn't much however in the end I perfectly understood that this "protection" does not exist on the credit card issuer/bank side of things. Be careful.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoYou didn’t file for a chargeback with Monzo, because they don’t offer credit cards. There’s less protection generally with debit cards. Generally guidance is that you are entitled to a refund from the bank only if you did not authorise a particular transaction.
- kennethp 8y ago
- mcv 8y ago> This is basically the sole "feature" of credit cards I value. Any time I'm buying something from > somewhere that might act poorly, I use a credit card for the free leverage I have in a disagreement. But without a credit card, they wouldn't even have been able to get your money without authorisation. I don't see how something like this would have been possible with a system that requires explicit authorisation per payment.
- richardwhiuk 8y agoWith a credit card, (at least in the UK) you can cancel a transaction post final authorization. In this scenario, the bank is jointly responsible for the transaction, and should refund you if the transaction isn't completed satisfactorily
- dwild 8y ago> But without a credit card, they wouldn't even have been able to get your money without authorisation. I don't see how something like this would have been possible with a system that requires explicit authorisation per payment. I don't understands your point. Are you saying the ideal scenario would be to fill the cards information each time? The fact that it's a credit card doesn't change that it was prefilled, a debit card or wire transfer is the same. Credit or not, if it's already there, the one that access your account can use it. With a credit card though, you can do a chargeback, which not only give you your money back, also add a direct cost (and a steep one from what I understood) to the merchant that made the transaction. As far as I know you couldn't do the same with a debit card.
- lozenge 8y agoThey could require the CVV when delivering to a new address - it's only three digits. But we're talking about a company that doesn't even refund obviously fraudulent transactions, so never mind.
- gpderetta 8y agoA few years ago, I made the mistake of buying some furniture using my debit card instead of credit card (about £1k). Between the payment and the delivery the company went bust. I though I was out of the money, but after a brief search I found out that, although there is no legal requirement to do so, VISA in the UK offers (or at least used to) the same chargeback facility to debit cards as for CCs. I visited my bank branch which gave me a phone number to contact, sent in a bunch of paperwork and after about 2 weeks I got my money back. I was very pleased as you can expect.
- zaarn 8y agoSEPA offers chargebacks on debit charges as well, same effect if you use it (and I prefer it over a CC).
- joering2 8y agoJust so you know - charbegacks are reported to credit burreaus. Sometime they will show on your report for few months sometimes they don’t. Just letting you know if you ever be wondering why you have good credit score but bank doesnt approve your loan or doesnt want to extend your credit.
- zaroth 8y agoI’ve never had a credit card of mine report a chargeback, and if they ever did I would cancel the card immediately. Mostly chargebacks are for actual fraudulent use of the card, and the process also includes getting a new card number. Lately, most chargebacks I’ve done have actually been issued by the card itself after they detected suspicious activity and sent me a text alert asking about specific charges. In one case, it was a debit card which I had received in the mail, activated, and never used and had never left the house. That one was particularly bizarre and I let them know something was very wrong there.
- joering2 8y agoCredit cards do not report, merchants banks do directly With credit bureaus. from there they decide if certain card holder triggered too many they put it on.
- joering2 8y agoOh boy don't you love being downvoted when you give people a genuine good-faith advice. I miss HackerNews from 5 years ago... Google this: "Account information disputed by consumer, meets FCRA requirements" and you will learn more.
- iagooar 8y agoThis doesn't work in Germany, for example. If you charge back, they'll just put you into a central register (called Schufa) that will basically make it impossible for you to get a credit or even to rent an apartment.
- chopin 8y agoCharge back for a credit card? That's the first time I hear of this. Do you have citations for this?
- zaroth 8y agoContesting a charge is a primary feature of credit cards — at least in the US. There’s a prominent link when I login to my credit card account allowing me to contest any charge, and a litany of reasons which you can then select from, ranging from “I don’t recognize / didn’t make this charge” to “Item was not delivered”, “Item was returned”, etc.
- mcv 8y agoIt's the one saving grace for using something so insecure for payments. At least the credit card company and/or merchant share that risk.
- jacquesm 8y agoThe CC offloads all of the risk + a fine to the merchant, they assume none of it.
- chopin 8y agoI've been imprecise, sorry. What I meant: how lead chargebacks to a credit card to a negative Schufa entry? I've never heard of this.
- entity345 8y agoIt's not a charge back in that sense when you report fraud or card theft. And I suppose that the effect you describe results from abusive requests from charge backs. I doubt you will be refused a mortgaged because you were a victim of theft in the past...
- YeahSureWhyNot 8y agoall repair shops inside Walmarts are either Cellairis or iFix&Repair franchises. A quick call to parent company would have resolved it too.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoThis is also the reason why creditcards are so ridiculously expensive. But then is there literally any alternative payment method in the US that does not involve a creditcard? It seems like the US banking system has just not invented anything in the last 30 years. Its not rocket science: money from my bank account to Deliveroo's bank account in (near) real time.
- anitil 8y agoThis is a peculiarly US phenomenon. Much of the UK, EU, Aus etc are much more willing to adopt new payment technology. (Can't speak for the non English speaking world but obviously China is way ahead) Surprisingly the US is much harder to convince. Ask people under 30yo in Aus or the UK when they last wrote a cheque, and the answer "what's a cheque?" is likely the response. Signing for a payment, magstripe, even using a PIN is mostly a distant memory.
- sundvor 8y agoYeah what is a cheque? ;) I can go weeks without my wallet now, Samsung Pay on my phone works just about everywhere in Australia, and it's great. Banking app even lets me generate a code to get cardless cash from ATMs, should I need notes. For transactions bigger than ~AUD100 I do have to enter my pin but that's a minor inconvenience.
- entity345 8y ago> Ask people under 30yo in Aus or the UK when they last wrote a cheque, and the answer "what's a cheque?" It's what train companies in the UK send you 3 weeks after you fill a compensation for delay claim...
- gnicholas 8y agoA related tip, given to me by a Capital One rep when my card was compromised: get a second card (which has a different number) that you use just for automatic payments. Then when your “regular” card is compromised by a restaurant, skimmer, or shady online vendor, you don’t have to notify your autopay accounts, since your autopay card is unaffected.
- rlue 8y agoAs a matter of principle, I would rather just do the chargeback (and get it really fixed somewhere else) than use it as leverage to negotiate for what I want on the spot. If a company is prepared to stiff me like that, the convenience of having it fixed right away is not worth the concession of letting them have my money when all is said and done. Is that just me?