4 ms·
More years of education => More student debt More years of education => Higher likelihood to get a city job that pays well enough for a decent lifestyle The a
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
More years of education => More student debt
More years of education => Higher likelihood to get a city job that pays well enough for a decent lifestyle
The above can explain the correlation between existence/level of student debt, and the likelihood of moving from rural to urban areas.
I don't see why we would assume student loans are the cause.
EDIT: The report on which this article is based presents the correlation, but is explicit about not suggesting causation:
"Importantly, we have not determined whether the relationship between loan balances and borrowers’ migration patterns is causal—for example, if, in order to repay their loans, high-balance borrowers seek higher wages in metropolitan areas.
Instead, we may be observing the effects of factors correlated with loan balances,
but not included in the CCP. These may include factors such as family income, degree completion, school selection, or the pursuit of an advanced degree."
- bayesian_horse 8y agoThe student loans may force you to choose a city job instead of one in a rural area, even if you otherwise wanted to move back to your home town...
- usrusr 8y agoSure, education is draining rural areas even without student loans, but they make the problem worse. And this effect is even more pronounced when we move focus one level of urbanization higher: Truly rural areas just don't have that many highly qualified positions outside the medical field. But in their regional capitals, definitely not what you would call a town anymore, every position exists that you would also finds in a world class metropolis, just on a much lower payscale. That's where much of the education-caused movement would go in absence of student debt. But when you add debt to the equation, the lure of first tier metropolis money turns from "but on the other hand, cost of living etc" to an offer you cannot reject.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoYour explanation is plausible, but people early in their career are always short of money, with or without student loans: Need to save a large down payment to buy a home => Better to move to the city where I can save more $$ each year Need to pay down a large student debt => Better to move to the city where I can pay down more $$ of my debt each year I'm not disagreeing with you: student debts make the hole larger, so strengthen the effect. But the effect is large in any case (due to most of us being born with a 'short position' on housing).