4 ms·
One feature that faders have is clear visual and haptic feedback - a thing that is not as clear with knobs. For rotary controls not only are the markings smalle
by weinzierl 8y ago
One feature that faders have is clear visual and haptic feedback - a thing that is not as clear with knobs. For rotary controls not only are the markings smaller if they exist at all but you have to deal with angles instead of distances, for which we know from studies of pie charts for example, our brains are not well equipped for. Then there is the problem that for haptics you need a marking on the circumfence which you can't see in every position, so you need another marker on top - I,ve rarely seen this design. I assume a blind person could use a fader easily but not necessarily a knob.
Where all of this becomes relevant is when we consider digital controllers. If we accept knobs without any visual and physical markings at all we gain an important feature - we can save and recall pot positions. Visual feedback can be regained with a display or a ring of LEDs around the knob or both. With a physical fader all of this is hard to achieve. You need motorized faders, which exist, but are expensive and have a bunch of disadvantages.
- AstralStorm 8y agoThe only problem with save/load in faders is haptics. Touch screens can show dynamic content and work like a fader just fine. (As opposed to a knob, which does not work right without the physical form.) Once someone invents a display with programmable shape, there's your programmable true fader.
- hammock 8y ago>As opposed to a knob, which does not work right without the physical form What about the iPod circle? That is basically a digital pot. In fact that idea is used on a bunch of Bluetooth speakers including Harmon Kardon and Google Home to control volume.
- laumars 8y agoI think you've covered the real crux of it. Any DJ worth their salt can switch between faders and rotaries but faders do offer an additional visual feedback plus are a little easier for doing some turntablism effects (which is why I tend to favour faders when given an option between the two). However rotaries really come into their own on digital mixers / MIDI controllers.
- mxfh 8y agoFirst it signal's "I don't do superfluous effects and scratches even if I wanted." The boutique type mixer has a whole different niche market than most comparably mass market mixers. Also with faders it's easier to do audible mistakes (especially when not sober) since smooth linear motion seems harder to control, than a mapping to rotary motion. And they're harder to accidentally move, (and kids stay away from them, since they dont know what to do). Let just look at the recently announced Denon Prime 4 all in one solution. Looks great on concept, specs and useful features, but still manages to look like a flashy plastic toy in.
- laumars 8y ago> Also with faders it's easier to do audible mistakes (especially when not sober) since smooth linear motion seems harder to control, than a mapping to rotary motion. I think that's more a case of what you're used to because I used to make more mistakes on rotaries than I did on faders. > First it signal's "I don't do superfluous effects and scratches even if I wanted." In fairness it really depends on the style of music you play. However I do agree with you that less is more - generally speaking.
- thirdsun 8y ago> First it signal's "I don't do superfluous effects and scratches even if I wanted." I wish that included the kind of DJs that can't resist driving their isolators hard every 30 seconds.