8 ms·
Three Men Charged in ‘Swatting’ Schemes
- hermitdev 8y agoSeveral things need to be done. These idiots should be charged with something along the lines of conspiracy to commit murder. The phone system needs to be updated to prevent apoofing of numbers. I know it jas its reasons for corporate exchanges and whatnot, but safety outweighs that. A Telco should be able to uniquely identify precisely who made a call. Along the way: no blocked numbers on caller ID. I dont answer a blocked number, anyway, but you shouldn't be able to hide.
- sowbug 8y agoWe should also make it illegal to steal cell phones.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> should be charged with something along the lines of conspiracy to commit murder How do you prove the intent was to murder rather than to harass? You think you’re being clever by charging with something more serious, then the charge fails because really you just wanted what they really did to have a steeper punishment. > I dont answer a blocked number, anyway They don’t call you - it doesn’t matter what you’d do - they call the police, who have to answer the phone.
- danharaj 8y agoBecause then they wouldn't be SWATting people then, they would, idk, order 10 pizzas to the place. Does this really need to be asked?
- peteretep 8y ago... yes? We have specific legal terms for death caused by actions where prosecutors don't think they can prove murder, and there's a reason for that
- root_axis 8y agoA SWAT team is a heavily armed killsquad. I think conspiracy to murder is pretty apt.
- peteretep 8y ago... which is presumably at least one reason you’re not a prosecutor
- root_axis 8y agoWell that's a pretty snarky response but it is also devoid of substance.
- peteretep 8y agoHow's it devoid of substance? The issue is about the fact that the legal system distinguishes between manslaughter and murder, has different burdens of proof for each, and you've come back and said "well in my opinion it's the same". And that's nice for your opinion, but if you worked in the legal system in any capacity you'd know that the two things are distinct, and the reason they're distinct is there's a difference in burden of proof, and that the layman's wild-ass opinion on things rarely factors in.
- root_axis 8y agoIt's devoid of substance because it's a sarcastic and condescending quip about whether or not my comments qualify me as a prosecutor in your view. That's not the topic at hand and it's pretty obviously a low quality response meant to insult rather than address what I wrote. Anyway, I'll defer to your credentials as an experienced prosecutor, but it seems pretty reasonable to me that painting an individual as an imminent danger and directing a paramilitary kill squad to their location (resulting in their subsequent execution) is an intentional murder. Obviously, the courts will tease out all the pertinent details but I don't see any details that preclude that possibility.
- hurray_brt 8y ago> How do you the intent was to murder rather than to harass? Are you serious? If I want to harass someone I'll ring the doorbell and run, order 40 pizzas, throw toilet paper all over their house, etc. Police armed to the teeth is pretty obvious this isn't about harassment. If it is, you need help. https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/29/16830626/call-of-duty-swatting-prank-kansas-man-dead-police-shooting https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/29/16830626/call-of-duty-sw...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- masonic 8y agoHow do you prove the intent was to murder rather than to harass? That's not their burden. The Felony Murder rule means that the person shares responsibility for the homicide.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI thought to convict someone of conspiracy to murder, one of the conspirators had to commit the 'overt act' of murder? In this case all the accused are conspirators, but which one committed the overt act? Calling a false report to the police is not an overt act of murder is it? If this was a contract killing for example they'd be in conspiracy with the hitman, who was clearly the murderer. Who's the murderer in this case? The police officer isn't committing murder. I think if you charged with conspiracy to murder you risk facing a jury who says 'ok I get they conspired but which one do you think committed murder?'
- aharrison 8y agoI'm a little surprised you didn't mention anything about police being held accountable when responding with unreasonable force to anonymous tips. If we are going to start talking about fixing this issue, I'm not sure getting rid of blocked numbers is going to materially impact these outcomes. Likewise, what is your recommendation on eliminating the threat of burner phones?
- djsumdog 8y agoThere's an audio clip of the 911 call posted on here. It wasn't an anonymous tip; the person on the phone pretended there was a situation/serious domestic dispute. The police should have still been more accountable, but let's get the context right.
- AstralStorm 8y agoSure, and that is a bad reason to go in guns blazing. It is even worse than if it was a hostage situation. It is even worse if the subject capitulated and went outside. What could they do, take aim at someone and then get shot? This is stupid trigger happy gangster style policing.
- oh_sigh 8y agoThe alternate side of officers using unreasonable force from a scam anonymous call is getting officers or members of the public killed from a real anonymous call. Police are going to be on high alert regardless, even if they think the call was a hoax
- aharrison 8y agoYou will note that I did not say "scam" anonymous call. I said "anonymous call" which includes both real and anonymous calls. Police officers should respond with force dictated by the circumstances of their situation, trained in such analysis, and held accountable to their decisions - both as individual officers and as departments. The source of the initial investigation should have little if any impact on the level of force used in the encounter.
- fenomas 8y agoSurely the robust solution is for police/swat teams to treat unverified threats differently? Any real world system needs to be able to handle faulty inputs. If this particular system wasn't so terrible at that, bad actors would have no reason to make the false reports in the first place.
- oh_sigh 8y agoWhat happens when an unverified threat isn't considered quick enough, and the hostages are killed while the police are standing around outside taking a wait and see approach?
- ClassyJacket 8y agoThe fact that this only happens in America indicates that their approach is the wrong one. They could ask any other developed nation for advice.
- wnevets 8y agoor we can just train our police force not to murder unarmed civilians
- qwerty456127 8y ago> The phone system needs to be updated to prevent apoofing of numbers. I know it jas its reasons for corporate exchanges and whatnot, but safety outweighs that. A Telco should be able to uniquely identify precisely who made a call. I would never (unless I have a serious reason to believe this can save a life) report a crime non-anonymously as I neither want to become a suspect (for many kinds of crimes this is possible) nor to be forced to participate in a court or anything like that as a witness.
- sigstoat 8y ago> nor to be forced to participate in a court or anything like that as a witness. indeed. lay witnesses are treated rather poorly.
- masonic 8y agoA Telco should be able to uniquely identify precisely who made a call It can, via ANI, when 911 is called (ANI for landline, another mechanism for mobile). Swatters, however, generally spoof Caller ID and call a general police switchboard or dispatch line directly. Police don't have the discretion to just ignore blocked numbers.
- narrator 8y agoI think the threat of getting 25 years in prison, as one of the guys got, ought to be enough of a deterrent to prevent this kind of stuff.
- reshie 8y agoit has always been illegal. the thing is these few jerks think they are anon and are in many cases(to extents). swatting too can happen from anywhere in the world. bringing them to justice will definitely make them think twice though.
- rhizome 8y ago>The phone system needs to be updated to prevent apoofing of numbers. I know it jas its reasons for corporate exchanges and whatnot, but safety outweighs that I've been agitating for something like this for a long time now, but really, I'm fine if CallerID can be spoofed, but I should be able to get the billing account for the line it's using. Phone companies as a rule resist giving out this information (which they've made available to law enforcement for a century).
- hanging 8y agoFirst responders need to be hardened against these simple redirection calls that don't come through 911 -- spoofing Caller ID is easy, but spoofing ANI is not.
- specialp 8y agoThe main perpetrator whom gave up his friends Tyler Rai Barriss actually did cause the death of someone in Kansas by "Swatting" them. He then was completely unapologetic. These new indictments are after he accepted a plea deal for 20-25 years in federal prison. Here is his twitter: https://twitter.com/goredtutor36?lang=en https://twitter.com/goredtutor36?lang=en. He boasted about swatting people and somehow got internet access in prison and posted his latest post. https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-tyler-barriss-swatting-20180106-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-tyler-barriss-swat...
- Memosyne 8y agoAccording to a police statement regarding the 2017 Wichita Swatting event: "Officers gave [the victim] several verbal commands to put his hands up and walk towards them. The male complied for a very short time and then put his hands back down to his waist. The officers continued to give him verbal commands to put his hands up, and he lowered them again." [1] I'm not well informed on the subject, but wouldn't equipping tactical teams with non-lethal weapons have prevented tragedies like this? The moment a team feels uneasy, they should feel free to stun the suspect. I know electroshock weapons have their own risks, but surely they aren't greater than firing a dude acting suspiciously with a live round from a Colt AR-15? 1. https://www.kansas.com/news/local/crime/article192244734.html https://www.kansas.com/news/local/crime/article192244734.htm...
- sixothree 8y agoAt the end of the day, it seems to be that police killed an innocent person. There has to be a better way.
- djsumdog 8y agoThis is just the audio of the swatter though, right? I don't think there's any video of the actual incident is there? Maybe the dude didn't understand what the big deal was and kept dropping his hands? Someone probably jumped the gun? I wonder if that team had non-lethal weapons and just didn't get them out. If he didn't have a firearm, a beanbag rifle could have ended this much differently.
- hate 8y agoI've confronted these types of people many times in the past. They're usually quite childish. If anything, they probably thought it was humorous. Things like this happen all the time with content creators and it won't stop anytime soon. Many people contact authorities beforehand to whitelist their address but I'm unsure if it's effective. I've also heard about pets that get murdered for having vicious tendencies in the victims household. How sad...
- Buge 8y agoTwitter names @internetlord @defeat @tragic and @spared Those seem like some pretty high value names. Although internetlord and tragic don't look like what I'd expect a swatter's account to look like. They don't appear very popular or active so saying they're "known by" those names seems a little strange. Also strange how much more valuable those look compared to the mastermind's twitter names swautistic and goredtutor36 .
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- siruncledrew 8y agoswautistic is the most fitting name of the bunch.
- nope96 8y agoA developer in the Bitcoin community got swatted. He wrote up an extremely detailed (and unrealistic IMO) guide on how to avoid it & stay private online as a public figure - https://medium.com/s/story/a-modest-privacy-protection-proposal-5b47631d7f4c https://medium.com/s/story/a-modest-privacy-protection-propo...
- nostromo 8y agoShouldn’t local law enforcement do a little more triage before sending in paramilitaristic swat teams? How many hostage situations actually happen in middle class boring suburbs such that a single unverified call turns into a full blown swat response?
- sn41 8y agoAnd police must be given training in de-escalation. There are a lot of skilled hostage negotiators in the police, probably every team needs one. Getting rid of overpunishment for victimless crimes will go a long way in avoiding needless crises.
- ddtaylor 8y agoThis conversation has been had on HN many times. Someone will come and say that they have to assume all reports are good faith and then someone else will counter that they're the ones using deadly force and should apply it as needed. Endless loop debate.
- anjellow 8y agoI'd assume in any situation where a swat team is necessary, 5 minutes of triage would drastically decrease effectiveness.
- bitwize 8y agoI don't think it's unreasonable for SWAT teams to respond to a credible call. What is unreasonable is American LEOs, SWAT and otherwise, being too quick to use de-escalation equipment that works by firing lead projectiles.
- anonytrary 8y agoAbusing the protection system like this should be life in prison. This is one of those things you don't fuck with. When you're 6 years old and call 911 because you don't know any better, that's one thing. These kids are 23 and 19, etc. and they understand the potential consequences of their actions, but they continued to act anyway.
- nasseri 8y agoI will say that there is a lot of pessimism in these threads which may be warranted, but it is good to see the judicial system beginning to take these people to task. Laws and regulations often move slower than we would like, especially when lives are at stake, but I remember years of this type of stuff going unpunished. This is a step in the right direction.
- R0uterR00ter 8y agothere are 2 problems i see with the swatting issue. 1] obvious, but the mentality of self elevated importance, and attachment of personal loss with a game [combatsimulator] that primes a person into an aggressive mentality. 2] there is no carrot and stick for LEO's. There is qualified immunity from prosecution, ideally this prevents a cop or other responder from being sued for adverse results, of acting "whithin legal authority" and "as a reasonable person" The end result is No Consequences fro screwing up under the veil of legal authority and reasonable actions. This veil has been stretched so thin that it is starting to breakdown, as there are now LEO and other responders actually doing some prison time, vs 15 years ago when police were heavily militarized and 911 was fresh in our heads; when any degree of force was legitimate to intercept domestic threats.