3 ms·
Now we have two promising candidates for the cause of Alzheimer's -- gingivalis, and herpes-family viruses. That doesn't mean one is right and the other wrong.
by ncmncm 8y ago
Now we have two promising candidates for the cause of Alzheimer's -- gingivalis, and herpes-family viruses.
That doesn't mean one is right and the other wrong. Maybe herpes gets in first and lets gingivalis in, or vice versa, or some other, more interesting interaction.
What's tragic is that effectively none of the present researchers are virologists or bacteriologists. As consequences, (1) progress studying and generating a useful clinical response will be radically slowed by resistance from the old guard to the threat to their livelihood, and (2) they will all need to find something else to do, because you can't pick up those specializations overnight.
The herpes connection was noted twenty years ago, but is only now getting traction. If it's right, then almost everybody who died of AS since then was killed by the structural resistance to the idea.
The best way to accelerate progress, now, would be to find another urgent health problem that seems to need the skillset that had previously been brought to bear on AS, so they jump ship and get the hell out of the way.
- Something1234 8y agoIf they don't have any background in infectious disease then what do they have a background in?
- ncmncm 8y agoAsk them? Biochemistry. Genetics. Proteinomics. Maybe they can design drugs? They have the disadvantage that everybody will know they have been staring the solution to their central problem in the face for decades without seeing it. ("What, infection? Too conventional.")
- Latteland 8y agoWhat blocks someone who has expertise from trying it? There's no secret cabal of scientists who stops people from studying other ideas. This is quite a bit different than a new physicist studying a perpetual motion machine.
- ncmncm 8y agoNothing blocks them from trying it, except (1) grants are controlled by existing researchers and (2) publication is controlled by existing researchers. Progress will happen eventually, but many, many people will die first.