4 ms·
ICE is a hugely complicated issue. Eg, I can see a political thread that illegal immigrants should be allowed into the country, and a notionally separate thread
by roenxi 8y ago
ICE is a hugely complicated issue. Eg, I can see a political thread that illegal immigrants should be allowed into the country, and a notionally separate thread that the most vulnerable should be supported by the government (eg, medically, minimum income, etc). How are these two threads expected to interact? To me, at a strategic level, they are mutually exclusive. Not mentioning all the very well discussed stuff like humanitarian issues, effect on the jobs market, fairness, long histories, etc.
I don't see how protesting in the tech sector is a fair and reasonable way of of resolving these issues - too many people involved are not part of the tech sector. Resolving such issues fairly is one of the reasons the West has a complicated systems of public voting and it seems a bit naive of the political system to try and force change at the corporate level. It also hopefully won't work as corporations are stripped of power by Ye Invisible Hand of the Market finding companies that will just do what is asked of them. Corporate political activism annoys me, I don't want to be told what is moral by a corporate entity or its non-representative employees.
- m0zg 8y agoYep. Some simple numbers. There are about 12M of illegal aliens in the US today. Between them they pay $11.6B in taxes (approximated). The math is just not very complicated, particularly if you consider that public schooling for a single kid in the US costs about $10k/yr.
- tomatotomato37 8y ago~$1000 per head in taxes really isn't a lot; just the federal tax rate on a full-time $7.50 minimum wage comes out to $1,500 in taxes after marriage deductions, and with state and local taxes that could rise to over $2000. For reference the simplistic average rate for the American household of $10500 spread over an average household size of 2.5 comes out to around at $4200 per head, which yields $50.4B in potential taxes over an equivalent sized population.
- m0zg 8y agoThat's what I was pointing out, essentially. And that's just the very tip of the iceberg of how much it costs to de-facto have no Southern border.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]