4 ms·
I'm tired of HN stories about the TSA.
by jgrahamc 16y ago
I'm tired of HN stories about the TSA.
- tomjen3 16y agoAgreed, but on the other hand I just simply hope that they become so hated in the hacker community that they will stop flying and embrace the online presence fully.
- lukeqsee 16y agoHonest question: why?
- davidw 16y agoBecause it's not the proper forum for it. You have N sites on the internet where you can talk about the TSA / tasers / politics / whatever to your heart's content. Please stop spamming one of the few good sites about startups and hacking with this stuff.
- lukeqsee 16y agoThanks for the answers (both davidw & jgrahamc). (I expected getting downvoted out of existence.) Points are totally understood and taken to heart. Thanks for clarifying.
- jgrahamc 16y agoBecause I think it's irrelevant to HN. These stories are all over Reddit and you can go and read about the TSA there. If the stories here were a discussion of technical aspects of the TSA equipment or procedures I'd be interested. But most appear to be scare stories (the rape victim one). Also, I don't care about the TSA for two reasons: firstly I'm not in the US and the TSA is an internal US body and secondly it doesn't bother me if someone sees a weird black and white picture of me naked. And I don't want HN to be consumed with a single issue with story after story because then it becomes another site where political/social stories are aired.
- jdp23 16y agoas somebody in Seattle, traveling is a big part of my startup life -- and I think the same is true for a lot of people here.
- jgrahamc 16y agoFair enough, so campaign against US policy around the world that has put the US in a position where there are people who want to kill its citizens on board aircraft. Fighting the TSA is dealing with a symptom and not the disease.
- jdp23 16y agoso your position is that we should just give in to the TSA and stop fighting?
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoIn my personal opinion (as opposed to my professional one) I think stories about the TSA are interesting, but don't belong on HN. The point is being done to death. So I've started flagging them, simply believing them to be inappropriate. My criterion is that they are of interest, but not specifically to hackers or entrepreneurs. They should be of interest to everyone who travels. If enough other people are of the same opinion then they'll start dying.
- jdp23 16y agoas a newcomer here, I'm not sure how to respond to this. it seems to me that there's a fair amount of interest in stories on the TSA that have been posted here. and a lot of us here travel, so statistically are at risk here. it's a well-written, short, actionable blog post by somebody who's an expert in the field. why is this so much more off-topic than some of the other things that make the front page? and RiderOfGiraffes isn't content just to let it go by without reading it the way we all do with some of the HN fave topics that don't personally interest me. no, he also is going to downvote it and announce to everybody here what he's doing. he can downvote, and presumably so can his buddies; as a newcomer, i can't. so my karma is probably taking a hit. suggestions on how i should respond?
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoI'll be interested to see what responses you get to that. A couple of points. I don't think TSA stories are any less or more valid than some of the other stories that hit the front page - and probably I flag them too. As I say, my criterion is that I don't think they are of interest specifically to hackers or entrepreneurs. They are, and should be, of wider interest. To me, that means they don't belong here. And for what it's worth, there are stories that I am interested in that I flag for exactly the same reason. Yes, I'm interested. No, I don't think it belongs on Hacker News. And you're confusing down-voting with flagging. And no, I'm not content to just let it go by. If I did, where would I draw the line? LOL catz (or whatever they're called? Hell, why not just ignore them too ... I think articles that are not appropriate should be flagged. Hence I flag them. I need a way to decide. I have one. I'm only one person here - my actions will mean pretty much zip if no one agrees with me. My $0.02.