3 ms·
I do not understand why the US (and Germany, which switched only a couple years ago to TETRA, as one of the last countries in Europe) took/take so long to encry
by mschuster91 8y ago
I do not understand why the US (and Germany, which switched only a couple years ago to TETRA, as one of the last countries in Europe) took/take so long to encrypt EMS communication.
I get the argument that people have a right to information - but at what cost? The data that is spoken on open frequencies is incredibly private: names, addresses or what a person is suspected of having done, or which car belongs to which person (=transmission of license plate, followed by the name on the driver license). All out in the open, ripe for all kinds of abusers to be harvested just like arrest data. Not to mention that criminals can also take advantage, e.g. by having one or more dudes off-site who simply listen to the police comm to inform if and how much police will be responding to a bank robbery or a theft.
And if you want to see examples of how this fucks up peoples' lives, just read this article or dozens more about such schemes: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2018/05/18/this-site-will-remove-your-mug-shot-for-a-price-now-its-owners-are-charged-with-extortion/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2018/05/1...
Fun fact: a friend and I used to listen to German police years ago. You didn't even need a scanner, just an iPod with the FM radio receiver and the region set to Japan so that the lower FM radio ranges could be listened to (which happened to match with part of the EMS channel range). We picked up all kinds of shit ranging from addresses, names and plates to tactical information (e.g. during a knife stabbing). Now we just laughed our butts off when they announced to dispatch they're logging off for grabbing a burger, but if we were evil we could have done a lot of damage to innocent people.
- detaro 8y agoAt least in Germany, it wasn't a transparency thing (even if easy, listening to responders comms is illegal), but a tech/admin thing. The switch to digital and adding encryption both add complexity that you need to be sure your people understand and can handle, even in crisis situations: analogue gear has it's own failure modes, but is more forgiving in other aspects. Add the general organizational issues of introducing large tech projects, coordination across many different organizations that all need to switch and be able work together at all times, and it's not too surprising it took long...
- mschuster91 8y ago> even if easy, listening to responders comms is illegal Yeah but it was difficult to prosecute - the only way to get into trouble was if police directly caught you in the act of listening in. Possession of scanners and frequency tables itself was made basically legal in 1998 by a court in Wuppertal, so unless you turned up to a crime scene with a scanner in your hand or got caught streaming the feed into the Internet, you couldn't get prosecuted (even if you admitted doing so on the Internet). > coordination across many different organizations that all need to switch and be able work together at all times Indeed, but now there are a number of success stories worldwide from which the US could learn on how to implement a switch to digital encrypted EMS communication. In the US however people still want to have the ability to snoop, or to distribute arrest records to the permanent Internet record, and I just ask myself why.