3 ms·
The difference is that back then there were experimental observations that couldn't be explained and that led to completely new branches of physics like general
by Anon84 8y ago
The difference is that back then there were experimental observations that couldn't be explained and that led to completely new branches of physics like general relativity and quantum theory. Right now that is nothing than can point the way. General Relativity, Quantum Mechanics and Electromagnetism are extremely successful with no obvious flaws (other than not always working well with one another) and the few things about which we have no clue (dark energy, dark matter, etc) are so removed from our capabilities that they're intractable.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoThere are a lot of dark matter searches out there which would disagree with your last statement. But further than that, we still have a lot of puzzles to solve. Proton radius, muon g-2, proton spin, ...
- Anon84 8y agoAnd they'll keep searching... and finding nothing. :o) And is solving those puzzles worth the tens of billions of dollars needed to build the next generation of accelerators? How much further would that same amount of money go if invested elsewhere? Hell, invest a few billion in building a true quantum computer or working towards true AI (just to name two areas where there are many more puzzles and obvious directions to explore) and see how much more impact that has and how much faster you can solve those same physics puzzles.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoWe don't know how to build a true quantum computer. But if you suggest we should also spend money on that, I agree. I don't think it's a smart idea to compare the validity of physics sub-fields. Look at the total amount of money that is spend on science compared to any other program. It's a joke. And it's not that we the people don't want it. Ask them, ask how much they think should be spend on science. It's multiples of what's actually spent.
- Anon84 8y agoIt's not a matter of comparing validities... just a matter of where can we get the most bang for our buck? The 20th century was the century of physics and we made tremendous progress in all areas of Physics. Precisely because of this progress, it is now time to look elsewhere. Throwing more and more money exploring increasingly esoteric regions of particle physics just because that's what we are used to doing isn't the best policy. And while I do agree that much more money should be spent on Science, I don't think particle physics is the right area in which to invest. We can make much much more progress in other fields.
- craftinator 8y agoThere is currently no quantum computer that can factor the number 15. And no one knows how to make one that can. Is this a useful field?
- Someone 8y agohttps://phys.org/news/2014-11-largest-factored-quantum-device.html https://phys.org/news/2014-11-largest-factored-quantum-devic...: ”New largest number factored on a quantum device is 56,153” Still something you can do in your head in less time than reading the paper takes, but more than 15.
- rjf72 8y agoYou can't separate A from B in the above. For instance dark matter and relativity. Dark matter was invented (or at least expanded) precisely because certain rotational characteristics of distant galaxies seem to contradict what we'd expect based on relativity and gravity. But we believe these theories are correct, so there 'must' just be a bunch of matter there we can't see or measure. And it must be invisible to the point that it only interacts with itself and gravity -- dark matter by another name. However, another recent discovery now indicates that galactic rotational curves are fully explained by visible matter alone, which poses a direct contradiction to the dark matter model that can't be so easily massaged into it. [1] The point of this is that 'something' is very wrong, and nobody really knows what it is. And this something could be something incredibly fundamental. If it turns out dark matter simply does not exist then we'll 'set physics back' (it would be progress, but the effect would be the same) many decades, but also open the door to an explosion of new knowledge and exploration. Then there are question like why is the universe accelerating? As you mention the bandaid here is dark energy, but again A cannot be separated from B. There are even open questions about things such as the big bang. Why are things like the cosmic microwave background radiation near homogeneous, even in areas of space that should not be causally connected (light has not had time to go from A to B since the birth of the universe)? One explanation for this is cosmic inflation which in turn created it's own dark matter analog - the 'inflaton' that's even more bizarre than dark matter, but once again it's just a bandaid to try to explain something that goes against everything we'd otherwise expect. There's an immense amount of room for progress in physics by removing these bandaids - either by testable physical explanations, or by providing better bandaids. And this is also just scratching the surface. There's so much we have no clue about. Even basic observations remain inexplicable, fast radio bursts, the rapid dimming of stars such as KIC8462852, and so on. I would speculate that there are probably more 'known unknowns' in physics today than ever before. Of course all of the questions seem incredibly difficult to answer, but this is what it always looks like when you're at any given state in science. We only see the answers as obvious or easy once we already know what they are. And then the next questions are the ones that suddenly take the place of seeming incredibly difficult to answer, only for this pattern to repeat to seemingly no end. [1] - https://phys.org/news/2016-09-spiral-irregular-galaxies-current-dark.html https://phys.org/news/2016-09-spiral-irregular-galaxies-curr...