4 ms·
A big question is which marginal tax rates. Because whilst millionaires mostly aren't going to run away from their homes and business, a $10m income tax isn't
by notahacker 8y ago
A big question is which marginal tax rates.
Because whilst millionaires mostly aren't going to run away from their homes and business, a $10m income tax isn't difficult to turn into equity grants or royalties paid to a holding company etc for the relatively few people earning that much in salary rather than on their capital. Which means the net result might be millionaires structuring their income in a way where they actually pay less tax without any running away at all.
If you take the more radical step of slapping the marginal tax rate on dividend income and capital gains as well, you start significantly changing investment behaviour: if you don't allow writeoffs for losses then VC becomes a really, really unattractive way to park your money, and if you do allow writeoffs for previous years' losses you might well be making the risky punt relatively attractive. Obviously changing people's investment behaviour is a desirable side effect, but it's something that needs very carefully thinking though
If you really want to change the imbalance between rich and poor you probably go after untaxed extreme wealth rather than earned income though...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If you take the more radical step of slapping the marginal tax rate on dividend income and capital gains as well, you start significantly changing investment behaviour: if you don't allow writeoffs for losses Why on Earth would you not allow write-offs for capital losses? Heck, if you are taxing capital gains as normal income, there's no reason to limit the deductibility of losses against normal income to a small amount per year with carryover the way we currently do (though for the same reason you might want to allow people to recognize gains in advance of or defer part of large ones after realization, you may not to allow deferring recognition of some portion of large losses.)
- notahacker 8y agoI finished the sentence you've truncated on the assumption that the government would choose the option of allowing write-offs rather than the investment-killing theoretical option of not doing so. But that approach radically shapes investment decisions too: capital will be allocated to riskier projects when the government takes 70% of a good year's return on capital but allows capital owners to write off years of losses against it than when the equivalent tax rate is 15% or 20% of a good year's return on capital. Sometimes that might actually be a good thing for the economy, but either way the effects are a lot more complex than the government simply earning higher revenue.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> capital will be allocated to riskier projects when the government takes 70% of annual return on capital but allows capital owners to write off years of losses against it than when the corresponding tax figure is 15% or 20%. I'm not convinced that's actually true at the level of large investors; as long as write-offs are allowed, the break even point is the same (and a lot of big investors are corporate and corporate capital gains are taxed as normal corporate income, so are unaffected by personal capital gains shifting from preferential rates to normal personal income rates.) The big difference for write-offs comes from smaller, less diversified individual investors if you allow full write-off against regular income rather than limiting to $3000 a year.
- notahacker 8y agoThe breakeven point looks the same until you factor in inflation (assuming no relief for that) as a benchmark and realise that at 70% tax you need ~9% annualised gross returns instead of ~3% to beat it (but with writeoffs for bad years, that's still achievable). Even with the superrich already being risk tolerant and willing and able to pursue high yields, that's going to see some rebalancing of portfolios Obviously this doesn't apply to regular public companies and financial institutions not paying 70% tax rates, but we could expect to see corporate vehicles entirely controlled by people paying 70% tax on dividends and capital gains from them behaving a little differently too.