5 ms·
Well yeah, when there's never any cops to kick off the homeless insane, people are going to prefer the privacy of their own car.
by ravenstine 8y ago
Well yeah, when there's never any cops to kick off the homeless insane, people are going to prefer the privacy of their own car.
- HillaryBriss 8y agowhat I love about LA's governance is that there's no solution to the "there's never any cops" problem. it just cannot be fixed.
- cimmanom 8y agoCould you elaborate on that?
- HillaryBriss 8y agoI think it's an accounting problem, or a flow of funds problem. IOW, the flow of benefits from hiring more police officers goes in directions that make it politically difficult or impossible to get the additional money. And you need a lot of it. Though adding officers would benefit rider safety and increase the quality and pleasantness of the rider's experience, the increased taxes would fall mostly on people who do not use the system much or at all. (To raise fares would discourage ridership.) And police officers aren't cheap - each one costs about $150,000 per year (according to a 2011 article which estimates that adding 725 officers to the LAPD added 110 million dollars a year in costs. [0]) [0] http://articles.latimes.com/2011/nov/22/opinion/la-oe-ridgewayheaton-police-20111122 http://articles.latimes.com/2011/nov/22/opinion/la-oe-ridgew...
- magduf 8y agoThe increased taxes would be cheaper than the effects of traffic, the deaths caused by cars, the cost of building and maintaining more roads for cars, etc. Public transit will never be a profitable enterprise. It must be subsidized. But we already subsidize roads for cars, but somehow the car-lovers just ignore that.
- HillaryBriss 8y ago> The increased taxes would be cheaper than ... that's probably true overall, but it matters where the benefits flow to and where the taxes flow from. in LA, how are we going to increase taxes on car travel enough to reduce car trips to the point where deaths and pollution are noticeably reduced and then redirect those new tax revenues to improving public transport? what politician or government leader can deliver that message and actually succeed? one of the first political realities that leader will discover is that the increased taxes must not be levied on working poor drivers. (most of them still need to drive their cars because public transport is not everywhere yet.) there will be a lot of complaints. and such taxes could actually increase levels of poverty because some poor workers won't be able to get to their jobs in their cars anymore. such a leader would be demonized for hurting low income people. that means the leader will have to propose an even greater tax hike on the middle and upper classes. well that's a hard fight too. those people vote. they fund campaigns. they also do not use the public transport systems as much as other income groups.
- magduf 8y ago>that means the leader will have to propose an even greater tax hike on the middle and upper classes. well that's a hard fight too. those people vote. they fund campaigns. they also do not use the public transport systems as much as other income groups. So basically, there's no realistic solution at all, and that society is headed for an inevitable collapse because of its own shortsightedness. Every nation gets the government it deserves, and this case is no different.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoi wouldn't say collapse, just that the status quo is surprisingly durable. there won't be a significant improvement in quality of experience for LA's public transit riders. the existing local political processes seem insufficient. i've seen it play out this way for a long time. but i believe an externally imposed shock (e.g. oil rising to $5000/barrel or a deep local economic depression) might accomplish what local politics cannot
- james-mcelwain 8y agoThere's tons of police on the metro -- I see them nearly every time I ride.
- ravenstine 8y agoWhere on the metro do you normally ride? I took the Gold Line almost every day from 2016 to 2018, and there were hardly any police either on the trains or at stations. Maybe 3 times a month I would encounter some guy shouting obscenities at random riders or harassing people on the platforms. Each time, I ended up having to be the one to call the police. About 6 months after the completion of the Gold Line extension, the number of police on trains dropped off dramatically and I almost never had my ticket checked. I gave up taking the Gold Line anywhere in early 2018 because I got tired of the exposure to belligerent riders, as well as those who are foul smelling; I'm glad I can start my days without having to smell mildewy body odor.
- magduf 8y agoBy contrast, I just took a vacation in Germany and took public transit a fair amount, and never did see any police in the subways. But I didn't see any belligerent riders or all these other problems either.
- james-mcelwain 8y agoRed line going downtown, which might explain it. I've definitely seen some craziness, but overall I've been pretty happy with the LA metro.