3 ms·
" vs even the 1960s with Vietnam war (where <70k Americans dying was a massive tragedy) " Kind of a US-centric view, as there were also some dead Vietnamese as
by hutzlibu 8y ago
" vs even the 1960s with Vietnam war (where <70k Americans dying was a massive tragedy) "
Kind of a US-centric view, as there were also some dead Vietnamese as well as civilian casualties as well.
So if you take those numbers:
WW1, 9.7 million dead soldiers, 10 million dead civilian and compare it to 1.3 million dead soldiers and 3-5 million civilians - then WW1 was actually much more civil, as the ratio of dead civillians vs. soldier was around 1:1 vs 2 or three dead civilians for every dead soldier in vietnam.
Might have to do with the fact, that the US dropped more bombs on Vietnam than in whole WW2 together (plus poisening with agent orange etc.)
But yes, also 60000 us boys died. The only real tragedy here.
- dmix 8y ago> But yes, also 60000 us boys died. The only real tragedy here. I never said that. I never made any moral judgement about any entire war or country. Since you're clearly inventing your own strawman to argue with I won't get in your way. Other than to say I was making a very specific analogy to make a point. An analogy about the evolving tolerances of nation states towards evil... using two related historical examples (keyword: related). No where did I say that was the "only real tragedy" of any war or time period, nor make any grand statements about the Vietnam war in general. I know 'progressives' think every phrase and paragraph has to be prefaced with a 100x conditionals as to not offend every party and cover all bases. I'm also aware people feel the need in a self-interested way to add in these conditionals - as to not be misconstrued by social media outrage culture - who are more than happy to take your words out of context. But I'd rather not go down that road in life. It's anti-intellectual and anti-rational.
- hutzlibu 8y agoI did not say you said that. I just pointed out that your thinking of the vietnam war by only mentioning US losses is telling. And went further on that road.