3 ms·
Debating the world as it was in 1492-1800s is hardly relevant to colonization in the 'modern world'. Even the mindset of World War 1 where 70k French or German
by dmix 8y ago
Debating the world as it was in 1492-1800s is hardly relevant to colonization in the 'modern world'.
Even the mindset of World War 1 where 70k French or German people would die in a single day vs even the 1960s with Vietnam war (where <70k Americans dying was a massive tragedy) sounds silly today. We evolve as a species and the tribes in South America and North America and Africa and (insert historical region) who were in constant war prior to foreign intervention weren't much different at a far smaller scale. The primary different is the absence of modern technology, communication, population levels, continental level geopolitics, etc, at their finger tips to ramp it up to 1914 levels.
The ideological parties who are obsessed with viewing history through the lenses of these power dynamics as the only defining metric are inherently irrational and intentionally ignorant of all of the macro/micro-level realities of the lifestyles of all people at that times. The difference between a colonizer and a local war lord starts to look very thin once you take a high level view of history, factoring in the historical day-to-day realities of the era.
If you're going to talk about colonization, as it is used in modern political discourse, keep it in your political debates not historical ones.
Otherwise it took time and the invention of political and legal systems to constrain these sorts of power abuses. But to only judge those in history who held a particular imbalance in power is a ridiculous way to view history. And an ever worse ideological foundation on which to run a country (as we've seen with countless examples of failures in history where economic/social systems were built around power imbalances as the prime motivation over the actual realities and needs of people within a society).
- staplers 8y agoweren't much different at a far smaller scale You are literally saying the exact thing this article is arguing against. There were nearly 100 million people living in the Americas before Europeans arrived. It was in the direct orders and manifesto of the invading parties to conquer and enslave these lands and NOT integrate peacefully. It applies to the modern world because this forced coercion still exists today. Sad to see so many here not understanding of that.
- AvocadoPanic 8y agoHow exactly would you have peacefully integrated the indigenous people (some / many that were essentially still living a Neolithic existence) with what were some of the most powerful and advanced civilizations at the time?
- ZenPsycho 8y agothe aztecs had an empire, a civilization, with pyramids, systems of agriculture, public schools, museums full of massive detailed gold statues, and organised sport. they invented basketball and chocolate. there were many kther advanced civilizations that we will only ever know the tiniest amount of, because they all died of smallpox. the only groups to survive were the nomads, cherokee, lakota, apache, etc. because they could avoid the spread of disease. the view that they were cavemen is part of the whole terra nullius argument, trying to cast them as essentially fauna.
- Yetanfou 8y agoYou forgot the bit which told of how the Aztecs [1] became to be the power they were back in the day: by a combination of military conquest and, to a lesser extent, trade. Before the Aztecs became the power they were there were the Toltecs, another militaristic culture which lost steam and got overrun by Chichimec tribes. It was from those tribes that the Aztecs rose, seemingly out of a group of a few thousand Chichimecs which had been forced out to a group of islands after sacrificing a princess from a neighbouring tribe. They gradually rose in power after conquering a few cities on the mainland and forming alliances with other tribes. First under Montezuma I and later under his successor they 'evolved an ideology of themselves as a chosen people destined to conquer' according to [2]. This ideology served them well and lead them to become the dominant power in what is now Mexico until they came into contact with another group of people who saw themselves as conquerors, better known in their own language as conquistadores [3]. In other words, those Aztecs with their pyramids and systems of agriculture were just like those who came before them and those who came after them. All they lacked was the firepower of those who conquered them and immunity to - to them - exotic diseases, otherwise the world would look different from what it looks like today. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aztecs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aztecs [2] https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/daily/military-history/the-rise-of-the-aztec-civilization/ https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/daily/military-history/the... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquistador https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquistador
- hutzlibu 8y ago" vs even the 1960s with Vietnam war (where <70k Americans dying was a massive tragedy) " Kind of a US-centric view, as there were also some dead Vietnamese as well as civilian casualties as well. So if you take those numbers: WW1, 9.7 million dead soldiers, 10 million dead civilian and compare it to 1.3 million dead soldiers and 3-5 million civilians - then WW1 was actually much more civil, as the ratio of dead civillians vs. soldier was around 1:1 vs 2 or three dead civilians for every dead soldier in vietnam. Might have to do with the fact, that the US dropped more bombs on Vietnam than in whole WW2 together (plus poisening with agent orange etc.) But yes, also 60000 us boys died. The only real tragedy here.
- dmix 8y ago> But yes, also 60000 us boys died. The only real tragedy here. I never said that. I never made any moral judgement about any entire war or country. Since you're clearly inventing your own strawman to argue with I won't get in your way. Other than to say I was making a very specific analogy to make a point. An analogy about the evolving tolerances of nation states towards evil... using two related historical examples (keyword: related). No where did I say that was the "only real tragedy" of any war or time period, nor make any grand statements about the Vietnam war in general. I know 'progressives' think every phrase and paragraph has to be prefaced with a 100x conditionals as to not offend every party and cover all bases. I'm also aware people feel the need in a self-interested way to add in these conditionals - as to not be misconstrued by social media outrage culture - who are more than happy to take your words out of context. But I'd rather not go down that road in life. It's anti-intellectual and anti-rational.
- hutzlibu 8y agoI did not say you said that. I just pointed out that your thinking of the vietnam war by only mentioning US losses is telling. And went further on that road.