5 ms·
Light travels in perfectly straight lines (geodesics in spacetime). The trip takes 0 time and 0 distance for the photon, from emission til absorption.
by gowld 8y ago
Light travels in perfectly straight lines (geodesics in spacetime). The trip takes 0 time and 0 distance for the photon, from emission til absorption.
- balabaster 8y agoLight's path is affected by gravity of the bodies it passes in space, so technically it doesn't travel in perfectly straight lines at all.
- saagarjha 8y agoThe parent commenter mentions this when discussing "geodesics in spacetime".
- peanutz454 8y ago0 time due to time dilation, but 0 distance?
- 12298765 8y agoYeah, due to length contraction
- jstanley 8y agoI think the reason it experiences 0 time is actually because of length contraction. The photon experiences the entire universe contracted to 0 length, so of course it travels along its path in 0 time.
- Retra 8y ago"For the photon" and "the photon's experience" are nonsense concepts. There is no such frame of reference, so it makes no sense to postulate what things would look like from it.
- warent 8y agoUnless you have a better theory of spacetime and gravity than Einstein, it's safe to say frames of reference are a fundamental aspect of the nature of the universe. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observer_(special_relativity) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observer_(special_relativity...
- Retra 8y agoI didn't say frames of reference don't exist, I said frames of reference don't exist for photons. I'm not sure Einstein or his theories indicate any disagreement on that point.
- warent 8y agoYou're right, I misread and jumped the gun. That being said, can you cite photons having no frame of reference? Not denying it to be true, but would like to know more about it.
- Retra 8y agoFrames of reference are identified by the objects which have zero velocity relative to them. A photon cannot have zero velocity, so there is no frame of reference for a photon. You can tell how much nonsense it is by reading the conclusions of the posters above: that 'time doesn't pass' and 'length is contracted to zero', which are just funny ways of saying spacetime doesn't exist and that's not a position any physicist will take seriously.
- pixl97 8y agoSo if you are on planet A and want to get to planet B that is 1 lightyear away. You have a magical space ship that can accelerate to c in one minute planet A relative time. How long does it take to to planet A on the travelers watch. No copping out and saying they've been destroyed by inertia. I am going to assume it takes one year and and one minute-ish compared to synced clocks in the AB pair.
- czbond 8y agoI needed some more details of how the photon experiences time, and found this (first good google result). But useful. https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/ask-ethan-109-how-do-photons-experience-time-94756eab8bf9 https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/ask-ethan-109-how-do-p...
- bookofjoe 8y ago"If time travel is possible, then there is no such thing as time."— Kurt Gödel
- omarchowdhury 8y agoIsn't the emission from a star, and the absorption within an eye or a telescope? There is clearly distance and time between the two here, how are you reducing it to 0?
- sk5t 8y agoTime passes for us, but not for the photon traveling at lightspeed.
- omarchowdhury 8y agoWould you explain why this is so? The speed of light is finite, not infinite.
- zaarn 8y agoA photon is moving at the speed of light. Things moving at the speed of light do not experience distance or time (and have no mass), for them their creation and destruction are the same event. This effect is also valid for objects with actual mass, the faster you go the slower your time moves relative to everyone else and the shorter distances become. You can't hit the speed of light but you can get fairly close.
- omarchowdhury 8y ago> A photon is moving at the speed of light. Things moving at the speed of light do not experience distance or time (and have no mass), for them their creation and destruction are the same event. How does this follow? There is still a traversal of spacetime at a limited speed between the creation and destruction. If the speed of light was infinite then yes I would agree with the proposition that no time or space experienced. You are offering a description without the explanation.
- zaarn 8y ago>There is still a traversal of spacetime at a limited speed between the creation and destruction. From your point of view, that is correct. From the hypothetical point of view of a photon, an object moving at the speed of light, time does not pass and the distance gets squished into zero. You can observe a partial effect by looking at cosmic rays. We can detect several decay products of cosmic rays on the ground despite these decay products being far too short lived and too slow to have actually reached the ground. However, due to their high speed, their internal clock runs "slower" compared to ours and the distance between the top of the atmosphere where they are created in a collision or decay and the ground is much shorter than they can travel at their speed. A photon experiences the same effect times infinity; distance and time no longer have a reasonable meaning other than being 0.