In my opinion, it's perfectly fine either way unless you're worried about performance. I personally tend to try to use the more performant option when there's a

In my opinion, it's perfectly fine either way unless you're worried about performance. I personally tend to try to use the more performant option when there's a choice, but a lot of times it just doesn't matter. That said, I suspect the example would be much faster if you didn't use the pipeline, because a single tool could do it all (I'm leaving in the substitution and column print that are actually unused in the result): awk '/^x/{gsub("a","b");print $2; count++}END{print NR}' foo.txt