3 ms·
And yet people seems to have a problem when I suggest that we freeze these little nazis out, or that we remind people that these are cancer machines. You are d
by tomjen3 16y ago
And yet people seems to have a problem when I suggest that we freeze these little nazis out, or that we remind people that these are cancer machines.
You are dealing with the same kind of bullies you were dealing with in grade school, cept they have grow up now and now don't even have to feel sorry for what they do.
Edit: to prove my point the first two replies to this tells me that I am wrong and cite sources - this isn't a science debate, this is politics.
- scythe 16y agoI take issue with the bad science involved in saying that terahertz radiation causes cancer. Terahertz radiation is very low energy, far too low to ionize DNA the way that UV rays do. If they're using actual X-rays, that's another thing entirely.
- tomjen3 16y agoBad science hasn't prevented the anti-vaccination movement, the creation movement, etc, etc. You may take issue with the science - but you would be missing the bigger picture: this is about politics, not science.
- davidw 16y ago> this is about politics, not science. So keep it the fuck off Hacker News, dammit! You people can downvote me all day long, but I don't give a shit. I'd give away all this stupid "karma" to keep HN from being filled with TSA/taser/injustice of the month stories ala Reddit.
- marze 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backscatter_X-ray http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backscatter_X-ray Well, it does use x-rays, they are called "x-ray backscatter scanners". Serious scientists have expressed concern. The concern is with the fact that inadequate testing has been performed, and comparisons made with other radiation sources are flawed because they take the absorbed dose and average over the entire volume of a person. Anyone in radiation safety understands the important number is the dose absorbed in specific portions of the body. In this case, the x-ray radiation is absorbed in the skin (minus the very small scattered fraction), not your entire body volume, resulting in a much higher local dose than you would expect if you modeled the exposure as uniform through the volume. Since the x-ray source strength is quite low (assuming the machine isn't multifunctioning), the health risks to occasional travelers are assumed to be low. Maybe frequent travelers or airline employees should have greater concern, or those at risk of cataracts.
- petercooper 16y agoA lot of things are cancer machines. Including our earth and solar system. I certainly hope they continue to test these devices and analyze the risks, but I'm not feeling too scared by things like this: The UK Health Protection Agency has completed an analysis of the X-ray dose from Backscatter scanners and has written that the dose is extremely low and "about the same as people receive from background radiation in an hour". Flying itself exposes you to significant levels of radiation in any case (compared to being on the ground). They even have to reroute flights due to it sometimes. Dr Robert J. Barish, an expert in aviation related radiation, even claims the average minute spent in flight exposes you to the same level of radiation as a single full body scan. Given the different types of scan available, though, this strikes me as only a vague estimation at best.
- loewenskind 16y agoSo you're saying with these scanners we're now going to get twice as much radiation? Which side are you arguing for? :)
- tlrobinson 16y agoNo, he's saying it's insignificant. 1 body scan = 1 hour normally = 1 minute aboard a flight By comparison, last time I got a real x-ray the x-ray tech told me the radiation was about equivalent to a cross country (~5 hour) flight.
- ErrantX 16y agoNow, I am against these machines and such actions myself. But "little Nazi's" is just Godwins law (i.e. a silly thing to say) and "cancer machines" is the typical climate of fear nonsense we are trying to resist from the TSA. So yeh, people probably have a problem not with the sentiment but with the language you use :) Seriously, c'mon.
- tomjen3 16y agoMy point exactly - the reason I use these things are that they _work_. Not on hn, maybe, but in the real world. And I don't give any amount of fecal matter that people are scared, I just don't want them to trample on other peoples rights.
- ErrantX 16y agoAnd I don't give any amount of fecal matter that people are scared And that is why I hate and despise such a sentiment. It highlights what is wrong with society that it is ok to push a position through fear. People are controlled through fear, and persisting that method of making a point is only prolonging the problem. You're no better than them. I apologise for being blunt, no offence intended.
- tomjen3 16y agoThe method may be the same, the intend is different and no real harm is done, unlike the tsa. Look I would love to have a rational discussion with people about this, but that will have to wait until they come down, people who are already scared shitless can't think straight, so either we step in and direct them -- though means one of us like -- or we let the politicians do so for us -- and end up in a place we have even more.
- sorbus 16y agoThe ends do not justify the means. Ever. That doesn't mean that you can use bad means for good ends, though. It just means that you can't say that "the intend [sic] is different," and act as if that makes it okay. Bad means are always bad; if something is harmful when used for one purpose it's harmful when used for another.