8 ms·
Repeat after me: Wealth is not a zero sum game. Wealth is not a zero sum game. Wealth is not a zero sum game.
by fastball 8y ago
Repeat after me:
Wealth is not a zero sum game.
Wealth is not a zero sum game.
Wealth is not a zero sum game.
- ihalip 8y agoRepeating something 3 times doesn't make it true.
- fastball 8y agoYou're right. The good news is that it's true regardless. The repetition just makes it more likely to get into the skulls of people who have a hard time grasping the concept.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThat's, at best, extremely misleading; outside of the most extreme absolute deprivation, relative deprivation (or prosperity) appears to be much more of a contributor to experienced disutility (or utility) than absolute deprivation or prosperity, such that, in practice, and modulo alleviating the most crushing poverty (which isn't where marginal gains go in the developed world, even where such poverty still remains) and maintaining illusions which shield the less well off from the prosperity of th well off (consumer-oriented capitalism actively seeks the opposite), wealth is, in practice, zero sum [0] in terms of impact on ezperienced utility, even if it isn't in measures of absolute possessions or consumption. [0] or, at least, rivalrous, in that for anyone to gain utility from wealth compared to an alternative scenario, someone else must lose; it's not real clear that utility can be meaningfully aggregated across individuals.
- fastball 8y agoI am impressed with the level of nonsense in this comment.
- claudiawerner 8y agoI'm impressed by the fact that people on a site like HN, supposed to be held at a higher caliber than Reddit, prefer to downvote rather than engage with the substance of comments.
- fastball 8y agoWhat substance? That comment reads like someone fed a thesaurus of non-words and a copy of the Communist Manifesto into a Markov chain.
- selimthegrim 8y agoNot just that, my God, the Alpine sentence structure!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rhacker 8y agoWho fucking cares? Is this the new calling card to prevent another Occupy? That kind of "end of discussion" is likely going to end up with another 500 bankers mysteriously suiciding again.
- wonderwonder 8y agoShould I just chant this as I drive past the food banks at the people in line?
- fastball 8y agoPlaces where people get free food This is somehow a problem Hmm.
- wonderwonder 8y agoIs that... is that really your argument? That everything is fine because these people in line at the food bank are able to get free food so that their children don't starve to death? So we can ignore the massive wealth disparity and the vast number of people living in poverty because we don't force them to die of hunger. That's very magnanimous of you. Imagine what they could accomplish with both free food and knowledge of your mantra.
- fastball 8y agoI was responding to your complete lack of an argument ("FOOD BANKS EXIST!?!!") in turn. Seems like the best way to respond to people who interject completely useless comments into conversations. If you want to have an actual discussion we can, but I doubt it will be productive, as it is already very clear that you either lack the critical reasoning skills to recognise the difference between wealth disparity and poverty, or you are deliberately obfuscating the difference and are arguing in bad faith. Either way, it's a problem. But I'll give it a go anyway: wealth disparity has no impact on poverty levels. There is no causal relationship between the two things. Nobody is dying of hunger because Jeff Bezos is a billionaire instead of a millionaire. Nobody is struggling to take care of their kids because your neighbor has three cars when you only have one. In fact, in recent decades the relationship between wealth inequality and poverty reduction has been positively correlated. Wealth is not a zero sum game. Phrased another way: economic productivity is greater than the sum of its parts.
- mdorazio 8y ago
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt absolutely is. Western economies have been growing at about 0-4% percent yearly over the last few decades. That means if somebody's wealth grows at a faster rate the money has to come from somebody else. If the US was suddenly full of people like Bezos or Gates I don't think the economy would grow much faster. They would just fight for the same piece of the pie.
- vertexFarm 8y agoSure, okay. What about inflation? If we have 1% of people with 90% of money and assets, either: A.) The upper class are extremely rich and the rest are desperately poor, or: B.) The masses have enough money to live comfortably and the upper class has 9x of that growth because that's how percentages work--thus this world has to have many times more total wealth relative to the world in option B. It works if that is feasible considering that world's industry. But what about when inequality keeps growing as projected, and the 0.1% have 90% of the wealth? Then the 0.01%? For the rest of the people to have a similar quality of life, the total number of assets in the world would have to grow by 10,000x. Otherwise, some people have to get poorer for a perpetually smaller percentage of people to have 90%. Wealth isn't strictly a zero-sum game, but at a certain absurd point the math doesn't work. At that threshold, cold hard physics kick in and physics is most certainly a zero-sum game. Physics is as zero-sum as it gets. Nature balances her books mercilessly. If wealth inequality is at reasonable levels and there's a reasonable amount of growth, it's perfectly possible for the middle and lower classes to be prosper while wealthy classes obtain much more money than they. But when the wealthy have an extreme majority of all assets--in order to keep the rest of society at a tolerable standard of living you'd be raising the total assets in the world by like ten thousand times. Obviously that wouldn't work. It assumes totally unrealistic rates of growth, which is a recurring issue for our civilization these days. Wealth does become a zero-sum game under specific conditions. Our civilization isn't a perpetual motion machine.
- zjaffee 8y agoWealth is absolutely a zero sum game depending on how you segment things. Increases in productivity and innovation are not zero sum, but things like land ownership on earth is absolutely zero sum.