4 ms·
Why is this the top comment? What value does it add? This is almost a textbook case of “the middlebrow dismissal”. Paradise Lost is one of the single most infl
by keiferski 8y ago
Why is this the top comment? What value does it add? This is almost a textbook case of “the middlebrow dismissal”.
Paradise Lost is one of the single most influential and brilliant pieces of literature in the history of the English language.
- magic-chicken 8y agoHe asked : why is it important ? You answered : because it is important. His comment has value because he's questionning an ill defined 'authority'. You accused him of a commiting a logical fallacy while committing one yourself. I learned more by reading the answers to his question than by reading your comment.
- keiferski 8y agoTo quote Wikipedia, "Paradise Lost has had a profound impact on writers, artists and illustrators, and, in the twentieth century, filmmakers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_Lost_in_popular_culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_Lost_in_popular_cultu... I'm sorry, but the idea that a single paragraph HN comment is some kind of deep philosophical point about the nature of authority is absurd. It was a glib dismissive comment, skeptical not for any well-thought out reason, but simply because they personally didn't understand it. I don't know how precisely I'd define anti-intellectualism, but that comes pretty close.
- magic-chicken 8y agoThis quote is gold, and I think this is the best answer you could have come with in the first place.