5 ms·
I remember when this was originally posted 10 years ago. I've got mixed feelings about this. It's not 2008, and there's no reason to expect another 75-year eco
by dehrmann 8y ago
I remember when this was originally posted 10 years ago.
I've got mixed feelings about this. It's not 2008, and there's no reason to expect another 75-year economic event again. On the other hand, tech and VC investment has more than tripped since 2008.
- jodrellblank 8y agoWhat is the "75-year economic event" timeframe based on? We now have "1000-year floods" five times in a year [1], is there good reason to think the economic predictions are more accurate than the climate ones? [1] https://www.edf.org/blog/2016/09/01/we-just-had-five-1000-year-floods-less-year-whats-going https://www.edf.org/blog/2016/09/01/we-just-had-five-1000-ye...
- whatshisface 8y agoIf there are at least 1000/5=200 floodplanes in the country it's not that surprising; and there are a lot more than 200 floodable areas.
- cperciva 8y agoI think you mean 5000 floodplains.
- whatshisface 8y agoYou're right, that was a silly mistake.
- shakethemonkey 8y agoHouston had 500-year floods consecutively in 2015, 2016, and 2017. Oh and one in 2001. Must be a terrifically unlucky place.
- SeanBoocock 8y agoThat or the context in which such events were considered 500-year events has radically shifted in the last 100 and especially the last 50 years.
- fyolnish 8y agoWhich is kind of the point
- wongarsu 8y ago"500 year flood" just means that in any given year there's a 1/500 chance of it happening. In theory history has nothing to do with it. In practice it's calculated with models that are tuned with historical data (among other things), so if you fail to notice some important changes and update your models you might be wildly off.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoHe's saying that they were 1/500 events previously, when the frequency was determined to be 1/500, but conditions have changed (climate, development, etc.) and they are no longer 1/500 events.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoNormally caused by non maintenance of flood channels and excessive building - that's what caused two 250 year floods in my village.
- SkyMarshal 8y agoThere are reasons to expect another such event again. First, those kind of shocks are not necessarily isolated, can happen in clusters. Second, the fundamental problems of 2008 were never fully solved, just transferred to govt/Fed balance sheets and pushed forward in time. It’s worth stress testing your current endeavors against a repeat.
- shakethemonkey 8y agoThe 1987 market crash (October 19, 1987, single-day loss of 23% in the S&P 500 index) was a 25 standard-deviation event. Mind you, an 8 standard-deviation event is an event that should occur once every 3 trillion years. And 25 standard-deviation events are unfathomable given the age of the Universe.
- nickles 8y ago> The 1987 market crash (October 19, 1987, single-day loss of 23% in the S&P 500 index) was a 25 standard-deviation event. Adding to this, the Swiss Franc revaluation in 2015 was called a 20 standard deviation event [0]. [0] https://www.ft.com/content/5a06ef16-b5e4-11e4-a577-00144feab7de https://www.ft.com/content/5a06ef16-b5e4-11e4-a577-00144feab...
- darkerside 8y agoI'd assume that statement presupposes a normal distribution. Is the stock market return normally distributed?
- shakethemonkey 8y agoIt's a power law distribution (Mandelbrot's work). That's why these numbers are outlandish.
- airstrike 8y agoStock returns are modeled based on the assumption that they are lognormal. Whether they really are is a different story.
- jayalpha 8y agoDescribing market moves in "standard-deviation events" does not really make sense. It is something for normal distributions and "random walks". It has been known for a long time that his is not the case: https://www.amazon.com/Fractals-Scaling-Finance-1st-First/dp/B0086PPXLM https://www.amazon.com/Fractals-Scaling-Finance-1st-First/dp... The conclusion is: due to faulty mathematics, far out of the money options are underpriced. Or, who Mandelbrot concluded, "investing on the stock market may be riskier than you think".
- draw_down 8y agoYour choices are “it will happen again”, or “it’s different this time”. Choose wisely!
- james_s_tayler 8y agoHaven't banks also consolidated and gotten bigger?
- nostromo 8y agoYes, but balance sheets of US banks have also improved fairly dramatically. While I think a downturn may be in the cards, I don’t think another financial crisis is for the US. China however...
- james_s_tayler 8y agoI read The Road to Ruin last year. I don't know if it's viewed very credibly or not but the guy purports to have had a ringside seat to the 2008 GFC. That book reckons it's all about complexity theory and it's just becoming more and more complex and the next time it happens the complexity will be unparalleled and hence it is going to get hectic. Now maybe that is just a way to sell books and it was a fun read, but I don't know. I get the feeling we all know something is coming because it always has and it always will. Some suspect it's going to be catastrophic like never before. It's at least assumed it's going to hurt. We don't know when but it seems people are in agreement it's edging closer and closer and things are about to get really unfun for a while. I just hope all the pain and misery happens to other people and I get through it unscathed. Totally going to take my share of the hurt most likely and that's OK I suppose. It's sort of fingers crossed at this point.
- lmm 8y agoFinancialization follows a cycle much like the hype cycle: something gets securitized, immense profits are made, people overextend and there's a crash, then it's reined in and becomes boring, and the next crash happens in something further out. If you read Liar's Poker, even in the '80s corporate equities were boring and all the action was in bonds. After the S&L crash, bonds were made boring (at least in the US for established companies) and the action moved to "emerging markets" and hot new IPOs. Asian crash of '97, dotcom crash of '99, these things get made boring and the action moves to mortgage securitization. 2008 crisis, mortgages get made boring, and the action now is in... well, if you can figure that out then there's a lot of money to be made. Car loans? Corporate loans? Foreign exchange? Commodities? I've seen all of those bandied about.
- caseysoftware 8y ago"another 75-year economic event again" How do we know it's a 75 year event? Because it happened once 75 years before? How often should it happen? We can't honestly answer how often it's going to or should happen. We can't honestly assess these sort of risk patterns because we don't have models that take enough of the variables into account (or even could?) Check out Taleb's Black Swan. His big thing is understanding what risks are measurable (very few), which have a bounded/estimable impact (still very few), and which are both unbounded and immeasurable or most of them.
- caminante 8y ago>How do we know it's a 75 year event? Because it happened once 75 years before? How often should it happen? We can't honestly answer... We do have models that take it into account. Taleb's argument isn't that you can't model the market, it's that most people aren't using the appropriate models [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat-tailed_distribution#Fat_tails_and_risk_estimate_distortions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat-tailed_distribution#Fat_ta...
- fromthestart 8y agoInteresting. The gist seems to be that we model market events with normal distributions, which is consistent with what I've seen in other "natural" and/or emergent processes, and this underestimates risk, because the true distribution is fat tailed.
- fnord123 8y agoThis came out in the same year as Taleb's Black Swan: https://www.springer.com/us/book/9781846284199 https://www.springer.com/us/book/9781846284199 Enjoy!
- C1sc0cat 8y agoYou can have a 75 year event in successive years - the UK village I live in once had two 250 year floods inside of 5 years.
- rchaud 8y agoThe post-08 tech boom is almost perfectly correlated to the rise of smartphones, which built a market for products like Facebook ads, Uber rides and the like. That too is a one-off event; we're at smartphone saturation these days.
- ksec 8y ago>there's no reason to expect another 75-year economic event again Because that so called 75-year economic event never really happened, or at least its full consequences, has been delayed by doctors injecting lots of adrenaline keeping it alive. Japan, China, EU, and US has since printed unprecedented amount of money. A lot of people think there wont be another 2008, I would be happy if it was only 2008 recessions. I am worry it will end up like 1930 with Great Depression.