I have no idea why this is being downvoted. Logically, that both these arguments can be made is a truism. Practically, we see versions of this on both sides e

I have no idea why this is being downvoted. Logically, that both these arguments can be made is a truism. Practically, we see versions of this on both sides every day. It doesn't mean that the left and right are both wrong, or both absurd. It means that this issue can't be settled by principle alone.