3 ms·
I've seen this many times, but I've never really bought it. I will draw an analogy: "The Paradox of Democracy". --- "In order to maintain a democratic societ
by paulddraper 8y ago
I've seen this many times, but I've never really bought it.
I will draw an analogy: "The Paradox of Democracy".
---
"In order to maintain a democratic society, the society must prevent undemocratic members from voting.
"Unlimited democracy must lead to the disappearance of democracy. If we extend unlimited democracy even to those who are undemocratic, if we are not prepared to defend a democratic society against the onslaught of the undemocratic, then the democrats will be destroyed, and democracy with them."
---
This is in fact, what many have believed for centuries -- that of evils of populism will overwhelm democracy egalitarianism.
I understand the view, but on the balance, I believe it to more false than true.
- _red 8y agoThe problem is one of game-theory. In the past decade, the US has become where nearly 50% of the population either doesn't pay any taxes and/or are primarily subsidized by government entitlements. In this situation, there is no downside to them crashing the system. They will come to demand ever more entitlements since they have no skin in the game. The politicos, of course, will pander to them for votes and try to implement every different kind of redistribution scheme they come up with. Take this same scenario and apply to the too-big-to-fail banks and the military industrial complex, and you have "our democracy". How will this end?
- michaelchisari 8y agonearly 50% of the population either doesn't pay any taxes and/or are primarily subsidized by government entitlements. Five Myths About the 47 Percent https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/five-myths-about-the-47-percent/ https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/five-myths-about-the-47-p...
- paulddraper 8y agoThe more precise statement is that 45% of U.S. households pay no federal income tax. [1] [2] There are other kinds of taxes, such as sales tax, payroll tax, gas tax, etc. But talk about raising taxes usually focuses on income tax since nearly half of Americans don't pay it anyway. In fact, the top 1% of taxpayers pay 39% of the federal income tax burden. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/beltway/2015/10/06/new-estimates-of-how-many-households-pay-no-federal-income-tax/#46e2bb9e61cb https://www.forbes.com/sites/beltway/2015/10/06/new-estimate... [2] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/81-million-americans-wont-pay-any-federal-income-taxes-this-year-heres-why-2018-04-16 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/81-million-americans-wont-... [3] https://taxfoundation.org/summary-federal-income-tax-data-2017/ https://taxfoundation.org/summary-federal-income-tax-data-20...
- Kye 8y ago>> "the US has become where nearly 50% of the population either doesn't pay any taxes and/or are primarily subsidized by government entitlements." I don't know if this is true (probably not), but let's pretend it is. Framing is everything. Try this: "50% of the population is too poor to be taxed." The judgement shifts from those with the least to those with the most.
- zaarn 8y agoIt's implemented; in germany we call it "Defensive Demokratie" (defensive democracy); a democracy with the institutions to defend it from itself to ensure that democracy continues. It's a product of post-WW2 germany, so it's quite understandable on the why of it's existence.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoI think your analogy is kinda missing the point. The point isn't that you somehow have to sort people into "tolerant" and "intolerant", and then remove the rights of those you have categorized as intolerant. The point is the simple observation that tolerance is not unconditionally a virtue, but rather lends itself to its own destruction when regarded as such, and therefore you should have a limit on your tolerance if you actually care about it. And that is obviously true of democracy as well: Democracy can be used and has been used to put dictators into power, and if you actually care about democracy, you therefore should have a limit on what democratic decisions you are willing to accept, and not just go with whatever the majority has decided as the supposedly "most democratic" way of making decisions. So, yes, you kinda have to "prevent undemocratic members from voting", but you may not need to sort people into "democratic" and "undemocratic". You can do it by banning undemocratic parties, for example. Or you may not need to really do anything at all, except for watching out for when something does need to be done. Noone is saying that "populism will overwhelm democracy". But it obviously can, and has, and you should not discount that possibility, and refuse to prevent it just because it is superficially "anti-democratic".