I picked up one of the 2017 MBPs with the first gen butterfly keyboard and although I’ve not had a key failure due to the dust issue, barely a day goes by witho

I picked up one of the 2017 MBPs with the first gen butterfly keyboard and although I’ve not had a key failure due to the dust issue, barely a day goes by without a coworker asking if I have something against my laptop because of how loud it makes my typing sound. The second generation ones are a significant improvement over the first but even those have other slight quirks, such as random double typing even on fresh devices. When I’m at home I’m happily back on my 2013 rMBP with the old fashioned keyboard, and if it was my money again tomorrow I’d think very carefully about what to buy, but still probably end up with a MacBook.