5 ms·
This seems like the wrong tool for the job. They seem to have good reasons for doing what they did. So I don't fault them, but this should be a contract disput
by benj111 8y ago
This seems like the wrong tool for the job.
They seem to have good reasons for doing what they did. So I don't fault them, but this should be a contract dispute/fraud.
- davweb 8y ago> We took legal action, they ignored attorney's demand to return our app id. Can't afford to escalate further because we're already few months in debt. We are 100% in the correct side of the law and had full rights. But nothing could be done. It seems they tried that route but then resorted to DMCA when the money for lawyers ran out.
- rflrob 8y agoThe developer seems to agree, “The law defaults to letting them get away unless you can pay several year worth of salaries and wait several months”. But when you’re out of other options, you do what you can.
- klodolph 8y agoIsn’t it the contract which gives the publisher rights to publish the game? If the publisher hasn’t executed their side of the contract, wouldn’t that mean that they don’t have rights to the game? DMCA sounds like an appropriate tool, then. From what I understand, the way a breached contract gets handled varies a lot from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and I’m no expert.
- benj111 8y agoThe publisher is UK based, as far as I'm aware contract law is somewhat similar in the US. The DMCA isn't against the publisher as I understand, its against the sites actually selling the game.
- klodolph 8y ago> The DMCA isn't against the publisher as I understand, its against the sites actually selling the game. Well, yes, that's how DMCA takedown notices work. If Lex Luthor posts my video on YouTube, I don't send the DMCA takedown notice to Lex Luthor, I send the DMCA takedown notice to YouTube. Lex Luthor has no responsibility to accept DMCA takedown notices, and there's no way to send them to him. The sequence is (1) publisher breaches contract (2) developer voids contract in response (3) publisher no longer has right to distribute game (4) DMCA takedown notice. This makes sense to me, but again, I'm not a legal expert and I'm willing to entertain arguments. I feel like the only thing in question here is whether the contract was voided properly, and whether it could be voided in the first place.
- benj111 8y agoMy point is, is that the publisher isn't involved in the prices at all, which as they are the wrong doer suggests to me that this is indeed the wrong tool. Its like Superman going after Lex Luther's office supplier, rather than destroying his underground lair.
- klodolph 8y agoI think you may misunderstand what a DMCA takedown notice is, or how they are used. You send DMCA takedown notices to innocent parties, that's how they work, that's how they're designed to work, that's the only way they work at all. If you want to send something to a guilty party then you send a lawsuit instead. You can't send a DMCA takedown notice to Lex Luthor's office supplier, because the office supplier doesn't claim DMCA safe harbor. YouTube does, Steam does, so you can send DMCA takedown notices to Steam and YouTube. You can't send DMCA takedown notices to Lex Luthor, his office supplier, or the publisher at fault here. In effect, the DMCA takedown notice is just a way of telling YouTube, "Lex Luthor does not have the rights to this video." This is not going after YouTube in any meaningful way. This is exactly what the DMCA is designed to do... prevent YouTube or Steam from being targets of lawsuits. Because Steam accepts DMCA takedown notices, they are protected from certain lawsuits for copyright infringment. DMCA takedown is a process where you tell Steam about third-party copyright infringement, and they remove the content and this clears Steam of liability. When Lex Luthor posts my video on YouTube, I can do two things: I can send a DMCA to YouTube and I can sue Lex Luthor. Suing Lex Luthor is expensive, so I start with the DMCA takedown notice to YouTube.
- benj111 8y agoOk then its like Superman sending DMCA takedown notices to Youtube over Lex Luther's unauthorised use of Superman's S. Rather than destroying the space laser that's about to destroy the earth. :P
- klodolph 8y agoNo, Superman's S would be covered by trademark. Sending DMCA takedown notices in response to trademark violations may expose you to liability under DMCA section 512(f). It seems like you have an objection to the DMCA, but the story about space lasers is a bit hard to understand. I'm not sure what your complaint is. The reason I chose "Lex Luthor" is because choosing a name makes it easier to understand hypothetical scenarios (instead of using them/they everywhere, or "the infringing party"), and because he took forty cakes, and that's as many as four tens.
- Chazprime 8y agoIt appears to have been the developers only option as the legal route to resolving the problem would cripple them financially. So perhaps not the right tool, but certainly an effective one.