6 ms·
I think they are perfectly free to present an unticked "personalize ads" box as a reasonable default. > For vast majority of users advanced configuration optio
by xg15 8y ago
I think they are perfectly free to present an unticked "personalize ads" box as a reasonable default.
> For vast majority of users advanced configuration options look like mumbo-jumbo, so most users will learn to quickly accept whatever mumbo-jumbo they are presented with -- without reading it at all.
Hiding the (pre-ticked) consent boxes in "advanced configuration" UI has been the default strategy so far. This fine made clear that this doesn't actually work to obtain valid consent.
- dennisgorelik 8y agoWhy do you think that an unticked "personalize ads" box is a reasonable default? I, personally, when I browse internet, strongly prefer personalized ads (over non-personalized ads). Most users, probably, do not care either way (because they do not understand the implications). But the business (e.g. Google) cares about ads personalization a lot, because ads personalization significantly increases tax revenue and reduces number of irrelevant ads that users see. In this situation the reasonable default choice is to allow ads personalization, so the business will have ad revenue to function and deliver functionality users need.
- xg15 8y agoIn this case, the EU per their democratic processes decided they need additional consent. Easy as that. > because they do not understand the implications This is the point. Relying on people not understanding something is not ethical and certainly not "reasonable".
- dennisgorelik 8y ago> EU per their democratic processes decided Do you imply that democratic process never make mistakes? > Relying on people not understanding something is not ethical CNIL bureaucrats rely on people not understanding, that these GDPR regulations make internet worse (annoying "accept/deny cookies" questions, less relevant ads, less revenue for businesses to create functionality users want). Would you say that CNIL is unethical?
- xg15 8y agoHow does the GDPR force any of that? Anyway, that's whataboutism.
- whyever 8y agoIt's not about personal preference. The GDPR does not talk about a "reasonable default", but about "freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous" consent from the user. There must be a "clear affirmative act" by the user, so consent has to be opt-in.
- dennisgorelik 8y ago> There must be a "clear affirmative act" by the user ... according to GDPR. My point is that GDPR is bad (for internet users) at the very core (intent) of GDPR legislation. I claim that it is bad for internet users to force them to make cookies decisions for every website that wants to use cookies.
- DanBC 8y ago> I claim that it is bad for internet users to force them to make cookies decisions for every web site. Which EU law do you think forces this? Please can you link to it?
- dennisgorelik 8y agoI meant "make cookies decisions for every website that wants to use cookies" (I just updated my comment). ========== https://eugdpr.org/the-regulation/ https://eugdpr.org/the-regulation/ The request for consent must be given ... ==========
- detaro 8y agomore precise: for every website that wants to use cookies and choose (or had to choose for lack of alternatives) consent as their justification for processing. Not all data processing requires consent.
- DanBC 8y agoPlease can you paste the text that you think forces websites to gain consent for all cookies if that website uses cookies? The site you linked is not the law, it's some kind of blog. But let's use this site: where does it say that all cookies require opt-in consent?
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoPersonalized ads require some sort of your information to be stored, which is why I think that it is not a reasonable default. In addition to that by making the information collection opt-out you could easily track the privacy-minded that decide to disable it - see DNT for example.
- zrobotics 8y ago>>I, personally, when I browse internet, strongly prefer personalized ads Which is fine if you want to click the checkbox to enable personalization. But not everyone wants that personalization and tracking. For instance, I've found personalized ads to be worse than generic ads, where Google tries to sell me a product for weeks after I researched and purchased it. If you enjoy the personalized ads, there is nothing to stop you from opting in, but that shouldn't be the default behavior.
- M2Ys4U 8y ago>Most users, probably, do not care either way (because they do not understand the implications). But the business (e.g. Google) cares about ads personalization a lot, because ads personalization significantly increases tax revenue and reduces number of irrelevant ads that users see. This is exactly the reason for the GDPR. Users don't understand the implications and so they shouldn't be automatically opted-in to systems that violate their human rights.