5 ms·
"Part of that may be that Facebook is quietly telling people, never in writing, that there’s no reason their stock won’t hit $100 billion in total valuation ove
by jonknee 16y ago
"Part of that may be that Facebook is quietly telling people, never in writing, that there’s no reason their stock won’t hit $100 billion in total valuation over the next couple of years. No guarantees, yadda yadda, but hey if you get 1/10 of 1%, that’s $100 million in stock. Now it’s a party."
Shady shady. Not only are there plenty of good reasons for Facebook not hitting $100B market cap (that would be 100x revenue, making the P/E amazingly high), but they also aren't handing out .001% of stock to many new hires. There's just not that much stock available, there are already more than 1,000 employees and a lot of the shares are spoken for (Zuck's got ~30%, the VCs have another huge chunk, etc).
- tafle 16y ago"that would be 100x revenue" They are already expected to make well over 1B this year. Why would that be the same a few years from now?
- ams6110 16y agos/Facebook/MySpace/ and ask again
- tafle 16y agoThe point is that, in a scenario where their market cap reached 100B, we would not expect their revenue to remain stagnant between now and then.
- mikeryan 16y agoAt a point where their market cap reached 100B we'd expect their profits to be between 2-3B a year. (P/E between 33-50) Considering that's 2-3x their current revenues can you understand the skepticism?
- andreyf 16y agoThe people running Facebook clearly know their ass from their face a little better than those running MySpace.
- netcan 16y agoThe point is that startups can go either way. Facebook's doing well now, but it would not be shocking if fewer people used it in 5 years.
- fleitz 16y agoAnd Google couldn't fail spectacularly in the same period?
- jonknee 16y agoIt can, but on the other hand they aren't telling new hires that Google could be a $2 trillion company and that would make their stock options worth an amazing amount (which would be the same amount of increase for Google that Facebook is suggesting). They're just handing out stock that's already worth a lot.
- netcan 16y agoThey could. I'm not saying they can't. But, the chances are probably lower than Facebook failing. The chances of Google failing are much lower than the chances of Facebook growing its revenues (or prospects) 5X. Price (ie working for shares) is an estimation of probability. I'm not saying Facebook is worthless. It's worth a lot. The reason Facebook's valuation isn't $100b already is because the road from here to there is an uncertain one. The two factors I would consider to be important are: (a) Facebook's revenue model is relatively immature.(b) Facebook might be a trend. *I think Facebook might even have the potential rival Google in advertising. I'm not a Facebook pessimist.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- evgen 16y ago
- klochner 16y agos/Facebook/AOL/ may be more appropriate. MySpace just blew it. AOL was a safe walled garden for people who didn't know what the internet was. As the internet outside AOL increased in value, people had less use for their walled garden. The same thing could happen to facebook if the rest of the internet gets more inherently social. s/Facebook Fan page/AOL Keyword/ s/Facebook email/AOL email/ s/Facebook Games/AOL Games/
- jonknee 16y agoFrom what I read last year's revenue was ~$800M and this year is looking like $1.2B. I hit it right in the middle. Regardless, this is revenue and revenue gets you shit on Wall Street. No one knows what their profit is, but even if it's in the $250M range (which I think is about 5x high), it still has to increase ~10x to get into the territory that a $100B valuation would need. They're also quickly running out of people with money to register, so I doubt we'll continue to see such huge growth. Not saying they won't make a great business out of it, but tantalizing would be hires with a $100B valuation seems pretty shady to me.
- rokhayakebe 16y agoRumor has it, it's more like 2B.
- jonknee 16y agoSweet, so they only have to raise that 50x before it's not a ludicrous statement. All they need to do now is get 25 billion people with as much money as the current 500m do signed up and they are good to go.
- NZ_Matt 16y agoNo, you are assuming that Facebook have already reached their maximum revenue per user. Facebook's revenue potential is massive and is only going to go up.
- jrockway 16y agoIndeed. Advertising is the easy way to make money, but I see a lot more creative ways to sell their social graph. One would be to sell it to credit-rating agencies and insurance companies. If all your friends have totaled their cars and defaulted on their loans, then you aren't going to get one either. The only problem with this is that it's extremely evil (because even non-users of Facebook can be fucked by this, thanks to the "steal all of your email addresses" import method), and that there aren't very many banks and insurance companies. Another model I see is using the photo service and the photo graph to help the police solve cold cases. Match the artist's sketch to the Facebook photo database, find some matches, and talk to their friends. Also very scary and evil, but potentially profitable. "Won't someone please think of the children?" Anyway, once Facebook feels like they have a fairly complete graph and don't need any more users, then the money making can really begin.
- tedunangst 16y agoAt this point, I have to wonder if it's really Facebook telling people that, or if it's TC repeating that line over and over for everyone to read.
- fleitz 16y agoIt only matters that TC may be making this stuff up if you work at Google. If you work at Google, go find an offer from Facebook that is better. If you get such an offer, then you can see if you get a counter. If not, go collect more money at Facebook. Worst comes to worst, you're getting paid more, it makes morale worse at Google leading to others getting offers. Google isn't a unicorn, it's a business, the purpose of working at a business is to extract as much value as you can from the 'business resource'. And in return you should expect the business to extract as much value from their 'human resource' as possible. That's how life works. Google provides snacks and benefits because it allows them to extract more value, if the expected value from such benefits were negative they would not do it.
- dflock 16y agoValue isn't measured solely in dollars, even at work.
- fleitz 16y agoI agree with you that value is not always measured in dollars. However, if the value is not measured in dollars, then why is Google offering dollars? I think what is happening is that Facebook is offering more dollars (likely, via stock) and the developers would prefer more dollars to more non-dollar denominated value Google is offering. Developers are not always the best investors, but at this point in time Facebook would appear to have much more upside in their stock than Google. It's just a matter of time before enough developers vest that Facebook is forced public like Google.
- zuckerborg 16y agoIt's absolutely hilarious (and sad) that people here are jumping all over that nonsense line, and now's there's an actual debate over whether Facebook is worth $100 billion. 1) These are numbers Arrington pulled out of his ass. 2) 0.1% at present valuation is already beyond his $3.5 million counteroffer. Nobody is getting 0.1% anymore.
- jrockway 16y agoI can't believe anyone would buy that, though. Facebook makes almost no money. That's not going to change. People are leaving the platform. There is constant negative publicity. Facebook is not a sure bet, so if you want to work there, do it because you like the project you're going to be working on. If you want to get rich quick, start buying lottery tickets. (If you want to get rich slowly, then take Google's $500,000 stock offer! While Google's growth may be slowing, they still have a solid product that makes them a shit-ton of money.)
- younata 16y agoI wonder what the ratio of new people signing up to people leaving facebook is. I personally think it's more than just slightly higher than 1 to 1.
- zuckerborg 16y agoThere is no way to possibly find this out. What you 'personally think' this number is should suffice.
- endtime 16y agoThe derivative of that ratio is far more interesting than the ratio itself.
- drusenko 16y agoIt's clearly not. When they state user numbers, they only ever state active user numbers. And it's growing like a bat out of hell. Let that sink in for a minute. Almost 600 million people use Facebook every single month. That's not the number that's signed up, and left. It's the number that is still actively using Facebook.
- mcosta 16y ago> they only ever state active user numbers Yeeeeeessss...? just as anyone else, amirite?
- 16y ago
- jamiequint 16y agoI would be extremely surprised if anyone that joins as an engineer now is getting 0.10%. I would guess its more around 0.01%. 10 basis points is more like a 30th engineer offer than a 300th engineer offer.
- robk 16y agoBut very very few people would get 1/10 of 1% these days at FB. More like a tenth of that. Nothing to sneeze at, but it's a long way to that $100B valuation still.