6 ms·
I agree with Norquist. You make things too easy, and people will just let it happen. As someone who owns a business and has to make quarterly tax payments, pay
by jjeaff 8y ago
I agree with Norquist. You make things too easy, and people will just let it happen.
As someone who owns a business and has to make quarterly tax payments, paying taxes is painful. I know how much it costs me every time I write a check and I am very reticent to vote for any politician that thinks we should raise those taxes.
On the flip side, I have many friends whose taxes are just pulled out every paycheck. And at the end of the year, they get a tax refund. They act like the government is giving them money! Many don't even seem to realize that all they are getting is a repayment for an interest free loan they have been giving to one of the largest and wealthiest organization/government in the world.
I understand and agree that taxes are important, but if we make it too easy, we make people complacent and the next thing you know, we will wake up with a 75% tax rate.
This is the same reason I disagree with adding the tax in on product prices. People in other countries that do this don't realize how much of the price is going towards taxes - and to keep a government in check, information is key.
- skh 8y agoThe scenarios you suggest happening if taxes are easy to file don’t have to be the consequence. It’s a possible consequence but overall I don’t think it would happen the way you suggest. I think it highly unlikely that it would lead to what you fear.
- koyote 8y agoMany western countries have very simple or near-automatic tax systems and I would argue that the tax you pay is actually much more visible to residents of such countries. In the UK, for example, most employees do not have to file a tax return. The HMRC files it for them and sends them a letter every tax year with their calculation. It even comes with a nice chart to see how much tax you've paid and where it went to (https://secure.i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02871/taxtable1_2871685b.jpg https://secure.i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02871/ta...). The tax brackets are also very straightfoward and everyone knows which bracket they are in. The same is true with tax on product prices. Everyone knows the tax rate on items because it's a simple number and there's a lot of public discussion whenever politicians decide on reducing/increasing it. If you ask anyone in the UK (or any other country other than the US with VAT) what the current VAT rate is, they will be able to tell you. Good luck getting an answer to such a question from someone in the US; you just pay what the cashier tells you to as VAT depends on so many factors.
- edko 8y agoTechnically, there is no VAT in the US. There is sales tax, and it can vary from city to city. I guess that is why it is not included in the price by default.
- koyote 8y agoYep; sales tax, VAT, GST, they are all pretty much the same thing. And the fact that in the US they vary by location was what I was alluding to. > I guess that is why it is not included in the price by default I hear that argument a lot but it does not really make sense to me. The place of purchase knowns what their tax rate is in their current location because the cash register has that information (and I assume this sales tax does not change very frequently?). So why not print out or display the prices with that tax included?
- gok 8y agoNo, they are not the same thing. You pay VAT on the value added at each part of the process. So a retailer pays VAT to their wholesaler, unlike American state sales tax systems.
- koyote 8y agoWhich is why I said 'pretty much'. In this discussion they can be regarded as the same thing.
- icebraining 8y agoYeah, but the retailer then deducts that VAT from the amount charged to the customer, so in the end it's the same, only the final customer pays VAT.
- steve_gh 8y agoNo. VAT is across the supply chain, provided they are all VAT registered. So as a business you only pay The net VAT between sales and purchases.
- notyourwork 8y ago> I understand and agree that taxes are important, but if we make it too easy, we make people complacent and the next thing you know, we will wake up with a 75% tax rate. This is simply not true.
- elyobo 8y agoDefinitely not true. Even people that have no idea what the rate is will notice if you increase it, because their take home pay will suddenly drop.
- eropple 8y ago> Many don't even seem to realize that all they are getting is a repayment for an interest free loan they have been giving to one of the largest and wealthiest organization/government in the world. Ah, hmm, yes, they just don't realize. Those poor benighted fools. Or maybe? Maybe they don't care. Take me, for example. I don't care. I've thought about it. I could spend more time screwing with my taxes to optimize my returns, or even go to no withholding whatsoever. Or I could enjoy my finite time on this planet, 'cause the amount of money we're talking about is marginal for me and I do pretty well for myself. (And to make one thing very clear: the downright fearmongering about a "75% tax rate" are just that and are not worthy of further address. Even were there a salient point in the bottom of this well, this isn't it.)