3 ms·
> It's got its downsides, but so does at-will employment. On the other hand, the downsides of at-will employment are basically solved by having unemployment in
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> It's got its downsides, but so does at-will employment.
On the other hand, the downsides of at-will employment are basically solved by having unemployment insurance.
> So have it kick in once you hire N employees or make more than $M in revenue.
The trouble with this is well demonstrated by the instant case -- Tesla has lots of employees and revenue but also major operating costs. It's more likely that a large company can absorb x% in overhead than a small one, but that doesn't mean it's always the case. And it doesn't help anybody for 100% of the employees to lose their jobs instead of 7%.
- geofft 8y agoThis law would be known to Tesla when they hired those 7% of employees in the first place. They'd take it into account when deciding if they could afford to hire them. They'd know that their budgets for 2019 would include some non-negotiable salary costs. And of course it is possible for any company to make short-sighted decisions that result in bankruptcy. Hiring too many people and being obligated to pay them is just one of several; if we're worried about companies going bankrupt and that being bad for ... employees? investors? society? ... then we should prevent them from making all kinds of bad decisions, not just from having to employ people.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoYou can't solve the problem with only partial foreknowledge. Being required to continue to pay redundant employees is a cost whether you know about it ahead of time or not. And not hiring employees you're not sure if you'll need is a catch-22. If you hire them and don't need them you're screwed, and if you need them but didn't hire them you're also screwed. Which one is the "bad decision" at the point in time when you don't know whether you'll need them or not? The solution is for employees to negotiate their employment contracts. If you want X months of notice before being terminated, demand that it's in your contract before you agree to work there. But that will mean the employer will want to offer less compensation, because they're incurring a cost and it's always a quid pro quo. Putting the rules in the law instead of the contract only prevents you from choosing the other thing -- lots of people would rather get paid more than have more notice when being laid off.
- solveit 8y ago>They'd take it into account when deciding if they could afford to hire them. Sounds like a great way to incentivise companies to discriminate against old people and people with preexisting conditions.