5 ms·
completely free means you have one less legal reason to kick out the bad kind of homeless.
by baq 8y ago
completely free means you have one less legal reason to kick out the bad kind of homeless.
- yardie 8y agoUnlike The MTA the Paris metro shuts down at 1AM. So no one is camping out on the platform, for long. And last time I was there the controllers were scanning passes quite frequently.
- tom_mellior 8y ago> So no one is camping out on the platform, for long. I've never been in the Paris métro after it shut down, but are you saying the homeless people camping in some stations in the evenings, wrapped in their sleeping bags, get up at 1 a.m. and file out? I somehow doubt that.
- ahakki 8y agoThey are kicked out. The doors are locked.
- iodbh 8y agoI have spent a couple of nights in locked metro stations myself : before locking, they just warn that they're going to lock. Whoever's still inside is locked in until morning, but there's no kicking out.
- hopler 8y agoUsing subway stations as shelters during off peak hours is a masterstroke of efficient infrastructure. Every city should do that.
- pelasaco 8y agonope, the right would be everyone be able to have a place to live. There is no dignity in supporting the poverty.
- icebraining 8y agoWhat if some people don't want a place to live, just somewhere dry to spend the night?
- yardie 8y agoThat must be one of the bigger stations like Châtelet. There are endless hallways and tunnels to hide in. A simpler 1-train station will have 2-4 exits and they will certainly put you out.
- kweks 8y agoIt depends on the station and season. In winter, station masters have a higher tolerance for camping - and it's worth mentioning that it comes down to the decision of station controller, not the RATP.
- johannes1234321 8y agokind of a strawman. Maybe one could also find better ways to give shelter to homeless. And for the bad kid there are other ways than using tickets for that.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 8y agoLaws are kind of a non sequitor. Maybe one could also find better ways to motivate people to treat each other decently. But I’m going to continue funding homicide investigations. “Don’t make things livable in small and practical ways, just hold out for total structural revolution and the solution to multigenerational and intractable social problems” is an infuriating line that unfortunately guides much of San Francisco policymaking.
- hopler 8y agoAre you saying that depriving people of places to sleep makes the city more livable.
- closeparen 8y agoIt only takes one person reeking of urine to make a whole train car a vile place to spend any time. So yes.
- alehander42 8y agoif there are so many people with problems that this happens often, your city has much more important problems to solve(helping those people) than "nice transit" (my city & most cities have to do this as well tho .. i am probably hypocritical in this)
- closeparen 8y agoWe are not going to solve the problem of democratic governance by a majority-homeowner electorate. To the extent that a homeowner electorate would ever allow homelessness to be solved: - Can't solve homelessness without mass affordability. - Can't have mass affordability without density. - Can't have density when voters are worried about congestion and parking impacts of development. - Can't stop worrying about congestion and parking impacts of development when you drive everywhere. - Won't stop driving everywhere until transit is attractive. Homelesness and repulsive transit are a feedback loop. We have to break it somewhere. Fare enforcement is a lever we actually have.