3 ms·
There are really two questions when it comes to a purported termination of a free/open license on existing software. 1. What affect, if any, does the attempted
by tzs 8y ago
There are really two questions when it comes to a purported termination of a free/open license on existing software.
1. What affect, if any, does the attempted termination have on existing licensees?
2. What affect, if any, does the attempted termination have on the ability of people currently without licenses to obtain them?
Most of the discussion on these matters usually just actually considers the first question, and either is unaware of the second or assumes that the answer is automatically the same for both.
Discussion is also often muddled by a tendency to think of licenses as being attached to the software, when in reality licenses are agreements between people concerning the software.
The second question is important because even if it turns out that a license cannot be taken away from those who already have one, either because the license says it is irrevocable or there is some sort of estoppel going on, that doesn't necessarily mean that the copyright owner has to issue new licenses.
One might argue that part of the license terms between the owner and the existing licensees was a promise that new licenses would be issued that those the existing licensees distribute to.
That argument is by no means certain to succeed. If it does, that then raises the question of what happens if the owner refuses, and the existing licensees sue. Would a court order the owner to issue new licenses? Or would they award damages to the existing licensees? (Another issue is whether any such obligation to existing licensees to issue licenses to their distributees extents to tertiary distributions from those people. Really, it is going to be a legal mess if this ever gets to a court).
A small number of free/open licenses allow their licensees to sublicense. The situation is quite a bit clearer with those licenses. If I get the software from Bob, who got it from the author Alice, and the license allows sublicensing, then my license can come as a sublicense from Bob instead of directly from Alice, and so I don't care if Alice claims she is no longer issuing licenses.
Probably the most common free/open licenses that allow sublicensing are the MIT license and the Apache 2.0 license. Apache 2.0 is also explicitly irrevocable.
- mc22ec 8y agoA license without an attached interest is revocable by the owner. Here the licensees paid nothing, did nothing, promised nothing, etc for the license. It is a pure gratuity. Bare permission. Without the permission they have no right to modify, make derivative works, redistribute etc. The license simply grants permissions, for nothing. It can be rescinded, and has been.