3 ms·
Doesn't make sense. Consciousness is a survival trait for self replicating agents. The universe doesn't need to survive, and has no external reality to be consc
by visarga 8y ago
Doesn't make sense. Consciousness is a survival trait for self replicating agents. The universe doesn't need to survive, and has no external reality to be conscious of.
Consciousness doesn't exist in a vacuum, or for no reason at all. The reason for its existence is that it protects the agent and helps in self replication. We shouldn't expect to find consciousness outside these settings. Maybe AI could be conscious, but it is just copying the architecture and receiving a purpose from outside.
In the case of biological consciousness, the purpose creates the tool. The only self-reliant purpose I know of is self replication, which doesn't apply to the universe.
- Zarath 8y agoWhy can't the universe be self-replicating?
- crimsonalucard 8y agoFor something to self replicate you need some sort reproductive system. A penis and a vagina are the main ingredients. For a universe to self replicate their must be at least two parallel universes. A male universe and a female universe. The male universe has a penis and the female universe must have a vagina. Then the two must have sex to produce child sibling universes. There is a flaw in this theory. Ask yourself "How does the child universe self-replicate?" The answer is the child universe must commit incest. This is a problem with the theory of self-replicating universes. So I'm now going to introduce a new speculative and pointless made up theory about how a universe can self replicate asexually. By introducing this theory I've solved the other pointlessly speculative problem that was basically made up out of thin air in the first place. However by adding enough metaphysical mumbo jumbo to my arguments I make everything seem more legit. Think about it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Zarath 8y agoThere's really no reason to assume one way or the other that the universe has a reproductive mechanism, whether sexual or asexual, or some other way. The parent comment was just so sure that: - Consciousness belongs to self-replicating agents only - The universe does not/cannot replicate These are both silly assumptions. In fact, I'd be more surprised if the universe didn't replicate in some form.
- visarga 8y agoI don't understand why you say that the self-replication requirement is silly. Without self replication there can be no evolution. It would be much less probable that a sentient entity appeared without an evolutionary mechanism. About universe replication, it's just a supposition, I am not opposed to it but I just don't find the reason to take it seriously yet. There would also be other requirements, such as the ability to process information which I don't see how it would work at universe scale considering the light-speed limit. It the universe were sentient, then it would think at a very low speed. Maybe the universe self replication mechanism could be us (or more probably a more advanced civilisation)? Supposing such a civilisation could learn to control the conditions for the creation of black holes, that would also fit with the anthropic principle. Or maybe they learn to create universe simulations, either way, it's sci-fi for us at this moment.
- tylerjwilk00 8y agoUniverses may very well self replicate. It's has been theorized that our universe's Big Bang singularity is not unlike the singularity of a black hole. And they may be two sides of the same coin. If a black hole creates a child universe and inherits physics from the parent that gives you self replication and possibly natural selection. In the set of universes any universe that can replicate and pass on it's physics "genes" would be found to have more survivors in existence of it's type. Lastly, if the physics required for black holes (and associated replication) are the same as those required for life then universes are naturally selected for life.