4 ms·
”felt like I was doing real work, important stuff, even if I was just messing around. I don't know what changed” You got more experienced. When you’re looking
by Someone 8y ago
”felt like I was doing real work, important stuff, even if I was just messing around.
I don't know what changed”
You got more experienced. When you’re looking at your second, third, etc. system, there always are cases where you think “This is so easy on ‘Foo’, why does ‘Bar’ make it so difficult?”, and feel like wasting time, even if it isn’t really difficult on that system, but just different, or if it is difficult because you are working on step A, but the new system has a better workflow that does steps A thorough Z in one go.
If you ask people what’s the most fondly remembered or impressive OS, computer game, word processor, mobile phone, music player, etc., it often is the first one they really used.
- dijit 8y ago> If you ask people what’s the most fondly remembered or impressive OS, computer game, word processor, mobile phone, music player, etc., it often is the first one they really used. I feel like this is an odd statement to make with no data. I can only speak for myself and my partner, but our current systems hold much more love than anything that came before. For me i3 on Linux is mature enough to not be intrusive into my life, mpd as a music player and so on. For my partner, she uses a Mac/iPhone/Apple Watch, and after coming from windows 7 she finds it “much better”, and “I would never go back” Games are another example. I played hundreds of computer games in my youth, from donkey king on the Commadore64 to rayman on the PlayStation. And my most fondly remembered game is almost certainly grand theft auto: vice city which is a much later title. I don’t think it smacks true that people love the first thing they learn on. I’m not keen on MS Windows 3.1 today, or MS operating systems in general, in fact quite the opposite.
- majewsky 8y ago> If you ask people what’s the most fondly remembered or impressive OS, computer game, word processor, mobile phone, music player, etc., it often is the first one they really used. Anecdata: I used Windows for the first 10 years of my computing life, and today I'd rather use any obscure Unix over any Windows. The "Unix philosophy" as an attempt to produce a consistent UX has held up pretty well over 40+ years.
- addicted 8y agoI don’t think it’s just personal experience. I had a similar feeling as the OP, but my feeling happened at a very specific time. I upgraded my MacBook from Snow Leopard to either Lion or Mountain Lion (I cant remember which version it was), and overnight I went from having my entire life spelled out on my calendar to basically not being able to use iCal (it might have been renamed by that point as well) at all. The new version of iCal’s only purpose was to look pretty and offer very basic functionality. The older version might have started looking dated, but I could use keyboard shortcuts and see details about my appointments easily at a glance. The new version didn’t even want me to know details existed. The same story played out in Mail.app, Address book, iWork, etc. MS’s new “Modern” apps show that the same influences have driven Windows development in recent times as well.
- pygy_ 8y agoIndeed, for me as well, every update up to Snow Leopard felt like Christmas. I didn't understand Lion, at all. As much as I loved skeuomorphism on iOS, it felt out of place on the desktop.
- njharman 8y agoWhat changed is that computers went from a tool used by professionals who didn't start out as, but expected to become power users. To mass market devices intended for casual users who expect to not have to learn anything, to think/decise. aka for things to be intuitive. Neither is inherently bad. The problem comes when you're apower user forced to. Use casual product or vice versa.
- vvillena 8y agoWhen did we give up on tools that scale well from casual users to power users?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoAbout when the internet started taking off as a consumption medium I think. Desktop computers started to show up in every home and were largely there just as a gateway to the internet. Prior to that, they were mostly for office work and computing enthusiasts with the occasional non-computing-enthusiast gamer thrown in. Since the consumer market was much, much larger the focus shifted. The strange thing to me, though, is that once smart phones and tables took over as the preferred platform for internet consumption the desktop OSs didn't start reverting to targeting the market that still wants them. Instead they doubled down on trying to turn desktops into smart phones.
- njharman 8y agoThat, there are things that are great for everything, is a false belief. Everything is compromise. If something is good for everything, it is optimized for nothing. Power users don't want good. The need 100% optimized for purpose, the #1 best. Which, btw, means giving control and power to the user. The UI and design worlds push for the opposite extreme. All control (away from user), scripted, "experience" to the user. Those professions selling point "we know what's best for users". A sentiment which doesn't work for power users.